Skip to main content
Gianelli & Morris attorneys Alex Gianelli, Joshua S. Davis, Robert S. Gianelli and Loring Rose

Protecting insuredrights since 1979

We fight insurance companies that refuse to pay.

Insurance companies don’t always play fair. Our insurance claim attorneys help policyholders fight denied, delayed, or underpaid insurance claims and recover what they’re owed.

Free Consultation

California Surgery Insurance Denial Lawyer

Free Consultation

In California, a health plan that denies surgery as not medically necessary must base that decision on review by a licensed physician or competent licensed health professional and explain its criteria and clinical reasons in writing under Cal. Health & Safety Code § 1367.01. You can grieve the denial and seek Independent Medical Review. Private employer ERISA plans limit lawsuit remedies.

Your surgeon recommended an operation, and your health plan said no. Robert S. Gianelli, a Los Angeles insurance attorney at Gianelli & Morris, represents patients when health plans refuse or delay the care their doctors order. Working with co-counsel, he obtained a $7.2 million jury verdict against a medical group that failed to provide a timely surgical referral. Our firm brings 40+ years serving California policyholders to every surgery denial we review. This page explains how California law treats surgery denials, which review path fits your coverage, and when a denial turns into a legal claim.

Why talk to us about a surgery denial? We have represented policyholders against insurers exclusively since 1979, including class actions over reconstructive surgery coverage at Kaiser and prosthetic-limb coverage at United Health Group. For insurance bad faith cases, we work on a contingency fee basis, so our fee is a percentage of any award we recover. Call 213-489-1600 for a Free Consultation to Discuss Your Legal Options.

Key Takeaways

  • Under California's utilization review law, only a licensed physician or competent licensed health care professional may deny or modify a surgery request for medical-necessity reasons, and the written denial must state the criteria used and the clinical reasons.
  • For DMHC-regulated health plans, you generally file a grievance first; the plan must resolve it within 30 days, or within 72 hours when expedited review applies.
  • A DMHC Independent Medical Review application is ordinarily due within six months of the plan's written response to your grievance, and the DMHC can accept later applications for good cause.
  • California courts generally apply a two-year period to bad-faith tort claims and a four-year period to claims on the written policy, commonly running from an unequivocal denial, though policy terms, accrual, and tolling can change the calculation.
  • Private employer group plans governed by ERISA don't allow a California bad-faith tort claim, and Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases.

What Is at Stake When Your Insurer Denies a Surgery?

A surgery denial is more than a billing problem. Under California law, it can delay care your doctor considers necessary, leave you with an unexpected bill, and start deadlines that run whether or not you're watching them. The denial letter you received is both the start of your appeal rights and, often, the first piece of evidence in any later legal claim.

If your coverage is through the Los Angeles area's HMOs or a private health insurance policy, the same core question applies. Who reviewed the request, what criteria did they use, and did they actually look at your medical records?

The medical cost of waiting

Some surgeries can wait a few weeks without much change. Others can't. A postponed spinal decompression, a delayed reconstruction after cancer treatment, or a referral that never reaches a surgeon can mean months of pain or a condition that becomes harder to treat.

California's utilization review law recognizes that timing matters. Under § 1367.01, a health plan must decide a routine prospective request within five business days of receiving the information reasonably necessary to make the decision. When the patient faces an imminent and serious threat to health, the decision must come within 72 hours.

The financial exposure

Some patients go ahead with surgery and pay out of pocket while the dispute continues. That choice can protect your health, but it shifts the financial risk to you until the plan pays.

Does an IMR win pay you back? If an Independent Medical Review finds the surgery medically necessary and the DMHC adopts that decision, a DMHC-regulated plan must reimburse the provider or enrollee for services already rendered, or authorize services not yet rendered, within five working days under Cal. Health & Safety Code § 1374.34. But the IMR decision doesn't compensate you for pain, a worsening condition, or lost income caused by the delay. Those harms belong to a separate question: whether the insurer breached its duty of good faith.

Deadlines that start with the denial

Several clocks can run at once: the grievance process, the IMR window, the policy's own suit-limitation clause, and the statutes of limitations for a lawsuit. Missing one doesn't always close every door. It can, however, narrow your options.

Many of these windows are long enough to build a careful record if the work starts early. The deadline section below lays out each one with its caveats, and a free case review can help you sort out which clock matters first in your situation.

How We Evaluate a Surgery Denial: Gate, Record, Remedy

Gate, Record, Remedy is the six-step sequence we use to evaluate a California surgery denial for a policyholder. It answers three questions in order: which legal rules govern your coverage, what the denial file shows, and which remedy fits the facts. The steps don't predict a result. They're designed so that no deadline, review right, or legal theory gets overlooked.

Step 1: Identify the governing path

Who sponsors and regulates your coverage shapes everything that follows. HMOs and most managed-care plans fall under the Knox-Keene Act and the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC). Health insurance policies regulated by the California Department of Insurance (CDI) follow the Insurance Code. A private employer-sponsored group plan generally points toward ERISA, the federal benefits law.

Your Evidence of Coverage is the contract document a health plan gives members. It describes covered benefits, exclusions, and how the plan defines medical necessity. We start with it, along with your policy, enrollment records, any employer plan documents, and your insurance ID card.

If the coverage is ERISA-governed, we explain why a different legal path applies and screen the matter out. If the regulator is unclear, we resolve that question before taking any substantive step, because the answer changes the deadlines and the remedies.

Step 2: Lock down the clock

Next, we read the policy's suit-limitation clause and identify every denial date that might trigger a deadline. If any period is approaching, preserving the claim takes priority over refining strategy. A denial that seems equivocal, or a claim that's still bouncing between reviewers, is treated as an open question that counsel has to resolve rather than assume.

Step 3: Take the denial letter apart

The denial letter often tells you more than the insurer intended. Under § 1367.01, a health plan's medical-necessity denial must come from a licensed physician or competent licensed health care professional, in writing, with the criteria or guidelines used and the clinical reasons. CDI-regulated insurers face parallel utilization review rules under the Insurance Code.

Gaps matter. A non-clinician reviewer, missing criteria, boilerplate reasoning, or a late decision can strengthen both the administrative appeal and any later claim that the insurer handled the matter unreasonably. Our article on failing to explain a denial covers why these defects carry weight. A denial that's facially complete shifts the focus to the medical merits.

Step 4: Choose the review route

For DMHC plans, the usual path is a grievance followed by Independent Medical Review. CDI policies have their own IMR. Denials of experimental or investigational treatment for life-threatening or seriously debilitating conditions have a separate external review under California law.

We use expedited review when the patient's condition is urgent. The submission is built around the treating physician's letter of medical necessity, the medical records, peer-reviewed literature, and any state coverage mandate that applies. We also decide early whether the matter warrants litigation alongside or after administrative review.

Step 5: Test the insurer's investigation

Every insurance policy in California carries an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing (Gruenberg v. Aetna Ins. Co. (1973) 9 Cal.3d 566). We request the claim file, reviewer notes, internal guidelines applied, and the communications log. A one-sided review or ignored medical evidence can support a tort claim. A documented, reasoned medical disagreement may point instead toward a contract claim or administrative relief.

We also check for an arbitration provision at this stage, because it affects where a claim can be heard. And we assess early whether the record would persuade a jury.

Step 6: Match the remedy and the scale

The final step compares three approaches: an individual appeal, an individual lawsuit, or a broader practice challenge. We weigh the strength of the evidence, the patient's medical urgency, and whether the same denial pattern repeats across members. Where a denial reflects a uniform rule, such as a blanket exclusion or misapplied criteria, our class action history makes it worth asking whether others face the same practice.

Key insight: The same file serves two purposes. A grievance and IMR submission that documents what the plan knew, and when, is also the foundation of any later bad-faith claim, so we treat the appeal as evidence-building rather than paperwork.

If you'd like to see how these six steps apply to your denial letter, call 213-489-1600 to talk with our team.

What Does "Not Medically Necessary" Mean for a Surgery Denial in California?

In California, "not medically necessary" means the plan has concluded that the requested surgery doesn't meet its definition of appropriate care for your condition. For most surgical care, the plan contract's definition is the starting point, but California law supplies its own definition for mental health and substance use disorder treatment in DMHC-regulated plans and its own coverage rule for reconstructive surgery. The Knox-Keene Act's stated purposes include keeping the medical professional as the determiner of the patient's health needs.

Medical necessity is the standard a health plan uses to decide whether a treatment is appropriate and covered for a particular patient. It's usually tied to clinical guidelines, the patient's diagnosis, and whether less invasive options have been tried.

Can a nurse or claims processor deny your surgery? Not for medical-necessity reasons under a DMHC-regulated plan. California's utilization review law reserves that decision for a licensed physician or a competent licensed health care professional acting within the scope of their license. Administrative staff can handle paperwork, but they can't make the clinical call.

"Cosmetic, not reconstructive"

This is one of the most contested surgery denials. California's reconstructive surgery law requires health plans to cover surgery that corrects or repairs abnormal structures caused by congenital defects, developmental abnormalities, trauma, infection, tumors, or disease, either to improve function or to create a normal appearance to the extent possible. The statute has limits, so the medical records need to show which category the surgery falls into.

Our guide to insurance denials of reconstructive surgery covers the "too cosmetic" argument in more depth. For patients who've lost a large amount of weight, see our page on coverage denials for excess skin surgery, the issue at the center of the firm's Gallimore v. Kaiser class action.

"Experimental or investigational"

Newer procedures often get this label even after they've gained acceptance in clinical practice. Artificial disc replacement and lipedema surgery are two examples the firm has written about, in our articles on artificial disc replacement insurance denials and lipedema surgery coverage denials. Patients with a life-threatening or seriously debilitating condition who meet the statutory criteria can request a separate external, independent review of an experimental-treatment denial under California law.

"Conservative treatment not completed"

Many surgical criteria require a patient to try physical therapy, medication, or injections first. That's not unreasonable on its face. The dispute usually turns on whether the patient already tried those options and whether the reviewer looked at the records showing it.

Hypothetical example: A Los Angeles patient with a herniated disc completes months of physical therapy and two injections, documented in her orthopedic chart. The plan denies a microdiscectomy because "conservative care was not attempted." If the reviewer never requested or read the therapy notes, that gap becomes central to the grievance, and it may also matter to a later bad-faith analysis.

Prior authorization and referral delays

Prior authorization is a plan's advance approval of a service before it's provided. Many surgeries require it, and denials sometimes come from missing paperwork rather than a medical judgment. A procedural denial can often be fixed by resubmitting, but it still triggers the clock.

Delay can be its own harm. In LaRue v. Accountable Health Care, IPA, a jury returned a $7.2 million verdict against a contracted medical group for failing to provide a timely surgical referral. Our article on how HMOs delay access to care explains how referral bottlenecks happen.

One more scenario deserves mention. If your surgeon leaves the plan's network mid-course, Cal. Health & Safety Code § 1373.96 lets an enrollee request completion of covered services with a terminated or nonparticipating provider, subject to the statute's conditions.

Which Rules Apply: HMO, Insurance Policy, Employer Plan, or Medi-Cal?

Under California law, the review path and the available remedies for a denied surgery depend on who regulates your coverage. An insured employer HMO keeps DMHC grievance and Independent Medical Review rights even though ERISA governs lawsuit remedies; only self-funded employer plans fall outside the DMHC entirely. The table below compares the main categories.

Which Rules Apply: HMO, Insurance Policy, Employer Plan, or Medi-Cal?
Coverage typeRegulatorInternal reviewExternal reviewLawsuit remedies
Individual HMO or managed-care planDMHC (Knox-Keene Act)Plan grievance; resolved within 30 days, or 72 hours expeditedDMHC Independent Medical Review under H&S Code § 1374.30California bad-faith tort and breach of contract claims
HMO or managed-care plan offered through a private employerDMHC, plus federal ERISA claim rulesPlan grievance; federal ERISA claims procedures also applyDMHC Independent Medical Review remains availableERISA remedies; no bad-faith tort or punitive damages
Individual health insurance policyCalifornia Department of InsuranceInsurer review under Insurance Code utilization review rulesCDI Independent Medical Review under Ins. Code § 10169California bad-faith tort and breach of contract claims
Self-funded private employer planFederal ERISA rules onlyFederal ERISA claims procedureFederal external review process, not DMHCERISA remedies; no bad-faith tort or punitive damages
Government or church employer planExempt from ERISADepends on whether the plan is an HMO or insured policyDMHC or CDI review if the coverage is state-regulatedGenerally retains California bad-faith remedies against the insurer
Medi-Cal managed care planDHCS, and DMHC for Knox-Keene plansPlan appeal within 60 days of the Notice of ActionState fair hearing; IMR also possible for Knox-Keene plans, with sequencing to confirmDifferent remedy framework from private coverage

If your coverage comes from a private employer

ERISA's preemption provision, 29 U.S.C. § 1144, supersedes state laws that relate to employee benefit plans, with a savings clause for laws that regulate insurance. ERISA preemption means federal law displaces certain state-law claims. For private employer group plans, that generally rules out a California bad-faith tort, punitive damages, and emotional-distress damages.

ERISA recovery is generally limited to the benefit owed plus potential interest, attorney fees in the court's discretion under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(g), and appropriate equitable relief under § 1132(a)(3). A benefits suit under § 1132(a)(1)(B) can be filed in state or federal court. Group health plans must give claimants at least 180 days after a denial to file an internal appeal.

Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases. If your plan is ERISA-governed, we can explain why it follows a different path so you can decide your next step.

Public employees and religious workers

Teachers, police officers, firefighters, public employees, and religious workers often have government or church plans that are exempt from ERISA. Those plans generally retain California bad-faith remedies against the insurer, though plan structure and the defendant can matter. Our article on how public employee insurance denials are different covers this group in more detail.

Medi-Cal members

Medi-Cal managed care follows its own sequence. The member must first appeal to the plan within 60 days of the Notice of Action. The plan decides within 30 days, or 72 hours expedited, and the state fair hearing window of 120 days runs from the plan's Notice of Appeal Resolution, not from the original denial. Aid paid pending must be requested within 10 days of the notice or before its effective date. For Medi-Cal matters, we explain fee arrangements at the free consultation.

How Does Independent Medical Review Work for a Denied Surgery?

Independent Medical Review is a no-cost review by outside medical experts, run by the DMHC for health plans and by the CDI for insurance policies. For a medical-necessity surgery denial by a DMHC-regulated plan, you ordinarily must file a grievance first, and the IMR application is ordinarily due within six months of the plan's written response, with DMHC discretion to accept later applications for good cause.

Independent Medical Review (IMR) is an outside review by physicians who don't work for your plan. They decide whether the denied service is medically necessary for your condition, and the plan must follow a decision in your favor.

The grievance comes first

Every Knox-Keene plan must maintain a DMHC-approved grievance process and tell members how to use it under Cal. Health & Safety Code § 1368. The plan must resolve a standard grievance within 30 days, or within 72 hours when expedited. If the plan upholds the denial, or 30 days pass without a resolution (three days for an expedited case), you can move to IMR. Our page on the California health insurance grievance system walks through the plan side.

Filing the IMR application

The application window under Cal. Health & Safety Code § 1374.30 runs from the qualifying events in the statute, not from the original denial. You can find the Independent Medical Review application on the DMHC's website. Under Cal. Health & Safety Code § 1374.31, cases involving an imminent and serious threat to health receive expedited handling, and the DMHC may waive the grievance prerequisite in extraordinary and compelling cases.

For CDI-regulated policies, Cal. Ins. Code § 10169 establishes a parallel IMR system. The Department of Insurance consumer help page explains how policyholders request it.

What makes an IMR submission stronger

Reviewers decide on the record in front of them. A letter from the treating surgeon that addresses the plan's specific criteria, point by point, usually carries more weight than a general statement that surgery is needed. Peer-reviewed literature, imaging reports, and documentation of failed conservative treatment fill in the rest. Our article on writing a health insurance appeal letter offers a starting structure, and our explainer on the role of the DMHC in health insurance denials covers the agency's broader authority.

The limit most people don't expect

IMR is fast, free, and binding on the plan. But it answers only one question: was the service medically necessary? It doesn't award damages for the delay, the pain, or the costs that followed. That's why we treat IMR as one tool among several rather than the finish line.

When Does a Surgery Denial Become Insurance Bad Faith in California?

A surgery denial becomes insurance bad faith under California law when the insurer unreasonably withholds benefits owed under the policy, breaching the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing recognized in Gruenberg v. Aetna. An honest medical disagreement isn't bad faith, but the "genuine dispute" defense protects an insurer only when its position rests on a reasonable, good-faith investigation. That limit doesn't apply to ERISA-governed private employer plans, which don't allow the tort claim at all.

The genuine dispute doctrine

The genuine dispute doctrine is a defense that lets an insurer avoid bad-faith liability when it had a reasonable, good-faith basis for disputing coverage. In Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co. (2007) 42 Cal.4th 713, the California Supreme Court held that a jury could find bad faith where the insurer reached its medical conclusion without fairly investigating and disregarded the treating physician's evidence.

For surgery denials, that holding matters. A reviewer who never looked at the surgeon's notes, or who applied criteria that didn't fit the patient's condition, is a different situation from a reviewer who engaged with the records and reached a reasoned contrary view.

What Insurance Code § 790.03 does and doesn't do

Can you sue under Insurance Code § 790.03? No. Cal. Ins. Code § 790.03 lists unfair claims settlement practices, but Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund Ins. Cos. (1988) 46 Cal.3d 287 held that it creates no private right of action. The Insurance Commissioner enforces it. The statute's standards still serve as evidence of what reasonable claims handling looks like, and the lawsuit itself is the common-law bad-faith claim. See our page on California Insurance Code 790.03 and bad faith.

For CDI-regulated health policies, Cal. Ins. Code § 10123.13 requires the insurer to pay a claim, or notify the claimant in writing that it's contested or denied with specific reasons, within 30 calendar days of receiving it. That rule applies to claims for care already provided.

What damages can be recovered?

In a non-ERISA bad-faith case, damages may include the withheld benefits and related economic losses. Brandt fees are attorney fees a policyholder reasonably incurs to recover benefits the insurer tortiously withheld, recoverable as damages under Brandt v. Superior Court (1985) 37 Cal.3d 813. Fees for pursuing the bad-faith claim itself aren't covered.

Punitive damages require clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice under California's punitive damages statute. They're never assumed. Our page on remedies for bad faith insurance practices covers each category. For ERISA plans, the limits described in the previous section apply instead.

Arbitration clauses

Some health plan contracts require binding arbitration of disputes. If your plan proposes a neutral arbitrator, Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 1281.91 sets a 15-calendar-day window to serve notice of disqualification after the arbitrator's disclosure, or after a failure to disclose. Starting January 1, 2027, AB 1770 (Lindalee's Law) will give the California Attorney General oversight of health plans whose contracts require binding arbitration. It doesn't eliminate arbitration.

How Long Do You Have to Challenge a Surgery Denial in California?

California has no single deadline for a surgery denial. Courts generally apply the two-year period of Code Civ. Proc. § 339(1) to bad-faith tort claims and the four-year period of § 337(a) to claims on the written policy, commonly running from the insurer's unequivocal denial, but policy suit clauses, accrual, and tolling can shorten or shift those periods. Administrative deadlines run separately.

An unequivocal denial is a clear and final refusal of the claim by the insurer. Whether a particular letter qualifies is often disputed, which is one reason deadlines need individual calculation by counsel.

How Long Do You Have to Challenge a Surgery Denial in California?
DeadlineApplies toGeneral ruleKey caveat
Utilization review decisionDMHC health plans (H&S Code § 1367.01)Five business days for routine requests; 72 hours for urgent requestsClock starts when the plan has the information reasonably necessary to decide
Grievance resolutionDMHC health plans (H&S Code § 1368)30 days; 72 hours when expeditedScoped to state-regulated plans, not self-funded ERISA plans
IMR applicationDMHC health plans (H&S Code § 1374.30)Ordinarily within six months of the plan's written grievance responseDMHC can accept later applications for good cause
Claim payment or denialCDI health insurance policies (Ins. Code § 10123.13)30 calendar days after the insurer receives the claimApplies to claims for care already provided
Policy suit clauseCDI disability and health policies (Ins. Code § 10350.11)No suit before 60 days after written proof of loss, none after three years from when proof of loss is requiredThe policy's own clause can differ and must be read
Bad-faith tort claimNon-ERISA coverage (CCP § 339(1))Generally two yearsCommonly runs from unequivocal denial; accrual and tolling can shift it
Breach of written policyNon-ERISA coverage (CCP § 337(a))Generally four yearsContractual limitation provisions can shorten it

The citations behind those periods are Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 339, Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 337, and Cal. Ins. Code § 10350.11. In one published decision, Blue Shield of Cal. Life & Health Ins. Co. v. Superior Court (Kawakita), the insurer's own policy clause gave the insured three years to sue for breach of the implied covenant.

The practical point is simple. Gather every denial letter, note the date you received each one, and have the policy clause reviewed while all options are still open.

Surgery and Treatment Coverage Results From Our Case History

Gianelli & Morris has challenged surgery and treatment coverage practices at several major California health plans. We have recovered Hundreds of Millions of Dollars, and the results below come from the firm's verified case record; past results don't predict the outcome of any future matter.

Surgery and Treatment Coverage Results From Our Case History
CaseCoverage issueResultWhat it shows
Gallimore v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc. (Alameda County Superior Court)Excess skin surgery after major weight loss under California's reconstructive surgery lawClass action trial judgment; estimated benefits to Kaiser members exceeding $150 millionA uniform denial rule can be challenged on behalf of thousands of members
LaRue v. Accountable Health Care, IPAFailure to provide a timely surgical referral$7.2 million jury verdict against a contracted medical groupDelay in getting a patient to a surgeon can support a damages claim
Trujillo v. United Health GroupCoverage of prosthetic limbs for amputeesClass action over prosthetic-limb coverageDevice and equipment exclusions can be tested as a practice
Arce v. Kaiser Foundation Health PlanDenial of autism treatmentClass action that formed the basis of Robert Gianelli's CLAY AwardTreatment denials affecting a whole diagnosis group can be challenged together
Dion v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc.Residential mental health treatment coverageClass action on residential treatment coverageLevel-of-care denials can raise practice-wide questions

Robert S. Gianelli tried LaRue with co-counsel. He received the California Lawyer Attorney of the Year Award, was twice named a Consumer Attorney of the Year finalist, and he shares the Consumer Attorneys of California Street Fighter of the Year honor with a firm colleague. You can read more on Robert Gianelli's attorney profile.

The firm has also written about related surgery and device coverage disputes, including microprocessor prosthesis insurance denials. Several of our attorneys hold the AV Preeminent® rating, and the firm's broader trial work includes litigators experienced in state and federal court.

Los Angeles Courts and State Agencies That Decide Surgery Coverage Disputes

Civil insurance lawsuits arising in Los Angeles County are filed in the Los Angeles County Superior Court. An individual health insurance bad-faith case is ordinarily an unlimited civil case, and the case notice and assigned department control where it's heard. A separate "complex" designation under the California Rules of Court applies only in particular circumstances; it isn't the default for an individual coverage case.

The California Courts website explains statewide civil procedure and forms. Your own case notice will tell you which department and judge are assigned.

When an insurer moves the case to federal court

An insurer sued by a California resident can remove a case to federal court on diversity grounds only if the insurer is both incorporated and headquartered outside California, and the amount in controversy exceeds $75,000. Many large health plans operating in Los Angeles County are California entities, so this question depends on the specific defendant.

The agencies involved before any lawsuit

Most surgery disputes pass through a state agency first. The DMHC regulates HMOs and managed-care plans, runs the IMR program, and takes enforcement action against plans. The CDI regulates health insurance policies and runs its own IMR. The California Department of Health Care Services oversees Medi-Cal and its state fair hearing system.

Each agency has different forms, deadlines, and standards. Knowing which one has authority over your plan is the first practical step, and it's the question Step 1 of our evaluation is built to answer.

Arbitration instead of court

If your plan contract requires binding arbitration, your claim may be heard by an arbitrator rather than a Superior Court judge or jury. The rules for selecting and disqualifying arbitrators, discussed above, apply from the start, so the arbitration clause should be reviewed early.

What Does It Cost, and What Should You Bring to Your Case Review?

Cost is a fair question, and it shouldn't be a mystery. At Gianelli & Morris, we take insurance bad faith cases on a contingency fee basis, which means our fees are taken as a percentage of any award we recover. For administrative matters such as Medi-Cal appeals or an IMR handled on its own, we explain fee arrangements at the free consultation. Litigation expenses are a separate topic, and we'll walk through how they're handled when we discuss representation.

What the consultation covers

The first conversation focuses on three things: what kind of coverage you have, which deadlines may already be running, and whether your denial looks like a medical disagreement, a procedural problem, or something more. If your coverage is an ERISA-governed private employer plan, we'll tell you that up front and explain why it follows a different path.

Documents worth gathering

You don't need everything to start. But the more of these you have, the more useful the conversation will be:

  • Every denial, grievance, and appeal letter, with the date you received each one
  • Your Evidence of Coverage or policy, including any arbitration and suit-limitation clauses
  • Your insurance ID card and enrollment or premium records
  • Any employer plan documents if coverage comes through work
  • The surgeon's recommendation and any letter of medical necessity
  • Medical records showing prior conservative treatment, imaging, and diagnoses
  • Bills and receipts if you paid for surgery yourself
  • Notes of phone calls with the plan, including dates and names

Why our focus matters for surgery denials

We represent policyholders against insurers and nothing else. That single focus, held since 1979, means our work centers on denial letters, utilization review criteria, IMR records, and claim files. For a deeper look at the broader practice, visit our Los Angeles health insurance denial lawyer page.

The information on this page is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Contact a qualified attorney to discuss your specific situation.

Talk With a Los Angeles Surgery Denial Attorney Before Your Review Window Closes

If your health plan denied surgery and you've received its written grievance response, the six-month IMR window under California law may already be running, and policy suit clauses can shorten lawsuit deadlines. We'll review your coverage type, your denial letters, and the dates that matter. Gianelli & Morris serves patients throughout Los Angeles County and California. Call 213-489-1600 to schedule a free case review.

Frequently Asked Questions

My insurer says my surgery isn't medically necessary. Can I fight that?

Yes. In California, you can usually challenge a medical-necessity denial through the plan's grievance process and then through Independent Medical Review, which is run by the DMHC for health plans and by the Department of Insurance for insurance policies. The denial must come from a licensed physician or competent licensed health professional and must state the criteria and clinical reasons. If your plan is a self-funded private employer plan, federal ERISA procedures apply instead of DMHC review.

How much does a surgery insurance denial lawyer cost in California?

At Gianelli & Morris, insurance bad faith cases are handled on a contingency fee basis, meaning our fee is a percentage of any award we recover, with fees taken as a percentage of any recovery. For administrative matters, such as a Medi-Cal appeal or an IMR handled on its own, we explain fee arrangements during the free consultation. How litigation expenses are handled is discussed separately before you decide on representation.

How long do I have to file a lawsuit over a denied surgery in California?

California courts generally apply a two-year period to bad-faith tort claims under Code Civ. Proc. § 339(1) and a four-year period to breach of the written policy under § 337(a), commonly measured from the insurer's unequivocal denial. Your policy may contain a suit-limitation clause that changes the timing, and accrual and tolling rules can shift it as well. Because these factors vary, an attorney should calculate the deadline for your specific denial.

What is my surgery denial case worth?

Under California law, a non-ERISA bad-faith case may include the withheld benefits, related economic losses, attorney fees spent recovering those benefits, and, with clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice, punitive damages. No one can give an honest number without the medical records, the claim file, and the denial history. For private employer ERISA plans, recovery is generally limited to the benefit plus potential interest, attorney fees, and appropriate equitable relief.

Should I accept a partial approval or settlement offer from my insurer?

Not before you understand what you'd be giving up. In California, a partial approval or settlement may include a release that ends any later bad-faith claim, and some partial approvals cover a different procedure than the one your surgeon recommended. An offer doesn't by itself prove the claim was underpaid, but it should be compared against the policy terms, the medical records, and your out-of-pocket costs before you sign anything.

What if my surgeon didn't get prior authorization first?

Under California law, a missing prior authorization often produces a procedural denial rather than a medical judgment, and it can sometimes be corrected by resubmitting the request with complete records. The exception is emergency care, which follows separate reimbursement rules for health plans. If the surgery already happened, the plan's written explanation and the reason authorization wasn't obtained both matter to the next step.

How long does it take to resolve a surgery denial?

In California, the administrative steps have defined timelines: a DMHC plan must resolve a grievance within 30 days, or 72 hours when expedited, and IMR decisions follow their own statutory schedule. A lawsuit takes longer and depends on the court's calendar, the amount of discovery, whether the insurer moves to federal court, and whether an arbitration clause applies. We explain the factors affecting your timing rather than guessing at a number of months.

Do I need a lawyer, or can I appeal on my own?

Many California patients file their own grievance and IMR application, and the DMHC process is designed to be usable without a lawyer. A lawyer becomes more useful when the denial involves delay that caused harm, repeated refusals, a reviewer who ignored the treating physician, or a deadline you're unsure about. Those facts can raise bad-faith questions that IMR doesn't address.

Will my case go to trial?

Some California bad-faith cases go to trial, and many resolve earlier through settlement, a favorable IMR decision, or a coverage reversal. The answer depends on the evidence in the claim file, the insurer's position, and whether an arbitration clause sends the dispute to an arbitrator instead of a jury. We assess early whether the record would persuade a jury, because that affects every strategic decision that follows.

Can I have the surgery while my appeal or case is pending?

Yes. In California, nothing prevents you from going ahead with surgery and paying for it while the dispute continues, though it shifts the financial risk to you until the plan pays. If an IMR later finds the surgery medically necessary, a DMHC-regulated plan must reimburse services already rendered within five working days of the adopted decision. That reimbursement doesn't compensate harm from the delay, which is a separate legal question.

My coverage comes through my employer. Can you help?

It depends on the plan. Private employer group plans are generally governed by ERISA, and Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases, though members of insured employer HMOs in California still keep DMHC grievance and IMR rights. Government and church plans, such as those for teachers, firefighters, and religious workers, are exempt from ERISA and generally retain California bad-faith remedies.

My plan is Medi-Cal. Does the same process apply?

Not exactly. In California, a Medi-Cal managed care member must first appeal to the plan within 60 days of the Notice of Action, and the state fair hearing window of 120 days runs from the plan's Notice of Appeal Resolution rather than the original denial. Medi-Cal members in a Knox-Keene plan aren't excluded from IMR, but the sequence with the fair hearing should be confirmed for your situation.