Skip to main content
Gianelli & Morris attorneys Alex Gianelli, Joshua S. Davis, Robert S. Gianelli and Loring Rose

Protecting insuredrights since 1979

We fight insurance companies that refuse to pay.

Insurance companies don’t always play fair. Our insurance claim attorneys help policyholders fight denied, delayed, or underpaid insurance claims and recover what they’re owed.

Free Consultation

California Aetna Denial Lawyer

Free Consultation

Under California law, you can challenge a denied Aetna health claim through the plan's internal grievance or appeal and through a state Independent Medical Review. If your coverage isn't governed by ERISA, you may also be able to bring a bad-faith lawsuit. For a plan regulated by the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC), the IMR application is ordinarily due within six months of the plan's written grievance response (Cal. Health & Saf. Code § 1374.30), and the DMHC can accept later applications for good cause. Self-funded private-employer plans follow federal ERISA rules instead; insured employer plans keep the state review path, though ERISA limits lawsuit remedies.

Robert S. Gianelli is a partner at Gianelli & Morris. His practice focuses on insurance bad faith litigation and class actions for policyholders in health, life, disability, and property insurance disputes, and this page reflects that work. He received the California Lawyer Attorney of the Year (CLAY) Award for Arce v. Kaiser, a class action over autism treatment. He has also twice been a Consumer Attorney of the Year finalist. Our firm has spent 40+ years serving California policyholders and holds an AV Preeminent® rating. This page explains how California law treats an Aetna denial, from the first letter to a possible lawsuit. For the wider picture, see our Los Angeles health insurance denial lawyer overview.

Aetna said no. Here's where you stand. Aetna may have denied, delayed, or reduced treatment that you or your doctor requested. The regulator behind your plan decides which deadlines and remedies apply, and several of those deadlines can run at the same time. Our class actions have compelled health plans such as Kaiser to comply with California coverage law, and we have recovered hundreds of millions of dollars. On bad-faith claims, our fees are a percentage of any award we recover. Call 213-489-1600 for a free consultation to discuss your legal options, and bring your denial letter.

Key Takeaways

  • Your Aetna plan's regulator determines your appeal route and your remedies. The possibilities are the DMHC under the Knox-Keene Act, the California Department of Insurance under the Insurance Code, or federal ERISA for private-employer plans.
  • A DMHC-regulated plan must resolve a grievance within 30 days, or 72 hours when the grievance is expedited. After that, you can ordinarily apply for a no-cost IMR within six months of the plan's written response.
  • Under Cal. Health & Saf. Code § 1367.01, only a licensed physician or competent licensed health care professional may deny care as not medically necessary. The denial must be in writing and must state the criteria used and the clinical reasons.
  • California courts generally apply a two-year period (Code Civ. Proc. § 339(1)) to bad-faith tort claims and a four-year period (§ 337(a)) to claims on the written policy. The period commonly runs from the insurer's unequivocal denial, and a policy clause can shorten or shift it.
  • Private-employer ERISA plans allow no bad-faith tort claim. Recovery there is generally limited to the benefit plus potential interest, attorney fees, and equitable relief. Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases.

What a Wrongful Aetna Denial Can Cost You in California

A wrongful Aetna denial in California costs you in two ways. There is the medical cost of delayed care, and there is the legal cost of letting a review or filing deadline pass. Under California law, the grievance, Independent Medical Review, and lawsuit deadlines are separate clocks, and missing one can close a path that would otherwise have been open. The DMHC can accept a late IMR application for good cause, but you shouldn't count on that discretion.

The medical cost of waiting

A denial letter can stand between you and a scheduled surgery, a refill your doctor considers medically necessary, or a referral to a specialist. Some people pay out of pocket and hope to be reimbursed later. Others put off care entirely. Both choices carry risk.

Delay can be as harmful as an outright "no." In LaRue v. Health Net of California, Inc. et al., a Los Angeles Superior Court case, the jury returned a $7.2 million verdict over a failure to provide a timely surgical referral. That case did not involve Aetna. It does show that California juries have treated delay in authorizing care as a serious matter.

Here's what that means for you. A denial in March can start several clocks at once:

  • The plan's internal grievance or appeal process
  • The six-month IMR window, which ordinarily runs from the plan's written grievance response
  • A contractual suit-limitation clause in the policy
  • The statute of limitations for any lawsuit

Consider a hypothetical. A Los Angeles member's Aetna HMO plan denies a requested procedure. The member waits seven months to file anything because the treating physician was "working on it." By then the IMR window has ordinarily closed. The member can ask the DMHC to accept the application for good cause, but approval is discretionary. None of this happens because the member did something wrong. It happens because nobody tracked the dates.

How We Evaluate an Aetna Denial: Gate, Record, Remedy

Gate, Record, Remedy is the six-step sequence we use to evaluate a California health insurance denial. The sequence decides which legal regime governs your Aetna coverage before any substantive step, because that answer controls every deadline and remedy that follows. It is a framework for analysis, not a promise of any result. Every limitation period needs an individual calculation based on your policy and facts.

1. Identify the governing path

Who sponsors and regulates the coverage shapes everything else. HMOs and most managed-care plans fall under the Knox-Keene Act and the DMHC. Health insurance policies regulated by the California Department of Insurance (CDI) follow the Insurance Code. A private-employer group plan generally points to ERISA. Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases, so if your plan falls there, we'll explain why a different path applies. When the regime is unclear, we settle that question first. The documents that answer it are the evidence of coverage or policy, enrollment and premium records, any employer plan documents, and your ID card.

2. Lock down the clock

We read the policy's suit clause and identify every denial date that might trigger a limitation period. If a period is approaching, preserving the claim takes priority over refining strategy. An equivocal or ongoing denial is an open question that counsel must resolve, not a reason to wait.

3. Take the denial letter apart

We test the letter against California's utilization-review rules. Was the reviewer a licensed clinician? Does the letter state the criteria? Did the decision arrive on time? Gaps such as a non-clinician reviewer, missing criteria, boilerplate reasons, or a late decision can strengthen both the administrative appeal and any later claim that the insurer acted unreasonably. If the letter is complete on its face, the focus shifts to the medical merits.

4. Choose the review route

For DMHC plans, a grievance comes first, followed by IMR. Experimental-treatment denials for life-threatening or seriously debilitating conditions have their own external review. CDI policies have a separate IMR. When your condition is urgent, we push for expedited handling. We also decide early whether litigation should run alongside administrative review or follow it.

5. Test the insurer's investigation

California law requires a thorough, fair, and objective investigation. We look for signs that the reviewer ignored your treating physician or conducted a one-sided review. We also check early for an arbitration provision, because it affects where the claim can be heard. Part of this step is asking whether the record would persuade a jury.

6. Match the remedy and the scale

There are three broad options: an individual appeal, an individual lawsuit, or a challenge to a broader practice. The right choice depends on the strength of the evidence, your medical urgency, and whether the same denial pattern affects other members. Our class work on reconstructive surgery, prosthetics, and autism treatment is why we always ask whether a single denial reflects a uniform policy.

Ready to have someone read your denial letter with you? If your Aetna denial involves a pending surgery or medication, or a grievance clock that has already started, call Gianelli & Morris at 213-489-1600. The consultation is free, and we'll talk through which path your plan falls under.

Which California Rules Apply to Your Aetna Plan?

Under California law, the rules for your Aetna denial depend on the type of coverage you have, not on the brand name on the card. Aetna-branded coverage can be a DMHC-regulated health care service plan, a CDI-regulated insurance policy, or a private-employer plan governed by federal ERISA, and each follows a different appeal route with different remedies. Government and church plans are exempt from ERISA and generally keep California's state-law remedies.

Your evidence of coverage is the document that spells out what your plan covers, what it excludes, and how to appeal. Together with your denial letter and ID card, it often identifies the plan entity that made the decision. When it doesn't, sorting that out is the first job.

Which California Rules Apply to Your Aetna Plan?
Coverage typeGoverning law and regulatorInternal reviewExternal reviewLawsuit remedies
HMO or managed-care plan (health care service plan)Knox-Keene Act (Cal. Health & Saf. Code § 1340 et seq.); DMHCGrievance; plan resolves within 30 days, or 72 hours if expeditedDMHC Independent Medical Review at no cost, ordinarily within six months of the written grievance response (§ 1374.30)California bad-faith tort and breach-of-contract claims if the plan is not ERISA-governed
Health insurance policy regulated by the Department of InsuranceCal. Insurance Code; CDIInsurer review under utilization-review rules (Ins. Code § 10123.135)CDI Independent Medical Review (Ins. Code § 10169)Bad-faith and contract claims, subject to the policy suit clause (Ins. Code § 10350.11)
Private-employer group planERISA (29 U.S.C. § 1001 et seq.); federal law180 days to file the internal appeal; urgent claims decided in 72 hours, pre-service in 15 days, post-service in 30 days, with one extension of up to 15 days allowed on the last two (29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1)Depends on whether the plan is insured or self-fundedFederal claim for benefits; generally benefit plus potential interest, attorney fees (§ 1132(g)), and equitable relief (§ 1132(a)(3)). Gianelli & Morris does not handle these cases
Government or church employer planExempt from ERISA; DMHC or CDI depending on plan typeDMHC grievance or CDI review depending on plan typeDMHC or CDI Independent Medical Review depending on plan typeGenerally retains California bad-faith remedies against the insurer

Plans regulated by the DMHC

The Knox-Keene Act is California's law governing health care service plans, which include HMOs and most managed-care plans. One of its stated purposes, under Health & Safety Code § 1342(a), is keeping the professional as the determiner of the patient's health needs. That purpose matters when a reviewer overrides your doctor. Our explainer on what the Department of Managed Health Care does covers the agency's role in more depth.

Policies regulated by the CDI

Some health coverage is sold as an insurance policy rather than as a health care service plan. These policies follow the Insurance Code. They carry parallel utilization-review rules, a separate IMR, and the Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations.

Employer plans and ERISA

ERISA preemption is the federal rule that state laws relating to a private employer's benefit plan generally give way to federal law. Under Pilot Life Ins. Co. v. Dedeaux (1987), state bad-faith claims were held preempted for ERISA plans, though later Supreme Court decisions narrowed that reasoning.

Is every Aetna plan I get through work an ERISA plan? No. ERISA generally covers plans sponsored by private employers. Plans for public employees and church employers are exempt, and so is coverage you bought on your own. Read more about how public employee insurance denials are different, including the issues facing California firefighters with insurance denials.

Medicare and Medi-Cal coverage

If your Aetna coverage is a Medicare plan, federal Medicare appeal rules apply, and those differ from everything above. A Medi-Cal managed-care plan follows its own sequence. You first appeal to the plan within 60 days of the Notice of Action, and the plan decides within 30 days (72 hours if expedited). Only after the plan upholds the denial does the state fair hearing window open: 120 days from the plan's Notice of Appeal Resolution, not from the original denial. You can go directly to a hearing only through deemed exhaustion, for example when the plan doesn't decide the appeal on time.

What Should an Aetna Denial Letter Contain Under California Law?

Under Cal. Health & Saf. Code § 1367.01, a California health plan's medical-necessity denial must be in writing and must include a clear explanation, the criteria or guidelines used, and the clinical reasons. Only a licensed physician or competent licensed health care professional may deny or modify a request as not medically necessary. CDI-regulated insurers follow parallel rules under Ins. Code § 10123.135. A denial that complies on its face can still be wrong on the medical merits.

Who can deny care, and how fast

Utilization review is the process a plan uses to decide whether requested care is medically necessary before, during, or after you receive it. Under § 1367.01, routine prospective decisions must be made within five business days of receiving the reasonably necessary information. Urgent decisions must be made within 72 hours.

For CDI-regulated health policies, Insurance Code § 10123.13 requires the insurer to pay a claim, or notify you in writing that it is contesting or denying the claim and why, within 30 calendar days of receiving it. A first-party denial must be in writing and must state every basis for it, with the factual and legal grounds.

What to check in your letter

Pull out your letter and look for these items:

  1. The reviewer's identity and professional license
  2. The specific criteria or guideline the plan applied
  3. Clinical reasons that address your records, not generic language
  4. The date of the decision compared with the date of the request
  5. Appeal rights and deadlines

A letter missing these elements raises its own questions. Our articles on failing to explain a denial and on why proper claim denial notices matter cover the consequences.

Common denial reasons worth testing

Medical necessity is the most familiar ground, but it's not the only one. Letters also cite experimental or investigational status, missing prior authorization, out-of-network providers, and emergency care that the plan later decides wasn't an emergency. Each reason calls for different evidence. A prior authorization denial may turn on what the provider's office actually submitted. An emergency-room denial may turn on what your symptoms looked like when you arrived, not on the final diagnosis. Our page on emergency room claim denials addresses that issue, and we've written separately about fighting an "investigational" denial.

How Do Aetna Grievances and Independent Medical Review Work?

For a DMHC-regulated Aetna plan in California, you file a grievance with the plan first. The plan must resolve it within 30 days, or within 72 hours when there's an imminent and serious threat to your health (Health & Saf. Code §§ 1368, 1368.01). If the plan upholds the denial, or doesn't resolve the grievance in 30 days (three days if expedited), you can apply to the DMHC for Independent Medical Review at no cost (§ 1374.30). These timeframes come from California law and apply to DMHC-regulated plans. Employer plans governed by ERISA also follow a federal claims schedule.

The grievance stage

A grievance is your written disagreement with the plan's decision, submitted through the plan's own process. Treat it as the foundation of your record, not as a formality. What you submit here often frames what the independent reviewer sees later. Our guide to the California health insurance grievance system explains what state law requires plans to provide.

Independent Medical Review

Independent Medical Review (IMR) is a state program in which independent medical experts, not the plan, decide whether denied, modified, or delayed care is medically necessary. You ordinarily must apply within six months of the plan's written response to your grievance. The DMHC can accept later applications for good cause. CDI-regulated policies have their own IMR under Ins. Code § 10169.

Experimental and investigational denials

Under Health & Saf. Code § 1370.4, plans must provide an external, independent review of experimental or investigational therapy decisions. This applies to enrollees with a life-threatening or seriously debilitating condition who meet the statute's criteria. If your doctor recommends a newer treatment, this route may apply.

Building the submission

But there's a catch. The reviewer decides on the record in front of them. A strong submission usually includes:

  • A letter of medical necessity from your treating physician that addresses the plan's stated criteria point by point
  • Relevant medical records and test results
  • Peer-reviewed literature supporting the treatment
  • Any California coverage mandate that applies to the service

Our sample appeal letter for a health insurance denial shows how to structure that argument, and the four steps to appeal a denied health insurance claim put it in sequence.

When Does an Aetna Denial Become Insurance Bad Faith?

Under California law, every insurance policy carries an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. An insurer that unreasonably withholds policy benefits from its own insured can be liable in tort, not just for breach of contract. That rule comes from Gruenberg v. Aetna Ins. Co. (1973) 9 Cal.3d 566. The main limit is the genuine-dispute defense, which protects an insurer whose position rests on a reasonable, good-faith investigation. ERISA plans are excluded because federal law preempts the tort.

The Aetna case that started it all

The name is not a coincidence. Gruenberg is the California Supreme Court decision that established first-party bad faith, and the insurer in it was Aetna Insurance Company. The case didn't involve a health claim. What it established is the principle that the duty of good faith is imposed by law, not just by the policy's terms. Our summary of Gruenberg v. Aetna traces how that case shaped California law.

The genuine-dispute defense

The genuine dispute doctrine is the rule that an insurer isn't liable for bad faith simply because it disagreed with you, as long as its position was reasonable and based on a fair investigation. Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co. (2007) 42 Cal.4th 713 set the boundary. There, the court held that a jury could find bad faith where the insurer reached a medical conclusion without fairly investigating and disregarded the treating physician's evidence.

That holding matters for health denials. A plan reviewer who never addressed your doctor's findings may not be protected by the defense.

Where Insurance Code § 790.03 fits

Insurance Code § 790.03 lists unfair claims settlement practices, such as failing to investigate promptly. Policyholders can't sue under it directly. Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund (1988) 46 Cal.3d 287 held that the statute creates no private right of action, and enforcement rests with the Insurance Commissioner. Its standards remain evidence of what reasonable claims handling looks like, and the lawsuit itself is the common-law bad-faith claim. More detail is available on California Insurance Code 790.03 and bad faith.

Rescission and cancellation

Bad faith isn't limited to claim denials. Rescinding a policy after a claim, which treats the coverage as if it never existed, raises its own issues. Our article on bad faith rescission of a health insurance policy addresses them.

What Damages Can You Recover After a Wrongful Aetna Denial?

In a non-ERISA California bad-faith case, damages can include the withheld benefits and the attorney fees reasonably incurred to recover those benefits. Other losses caused by the denial may also be recoverable. Punitive damages require clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice under Cal. Civ. Code § 3294, and they are never assumed. For private-employer ERISA plans, the remedies are much narrower.

Brandt fees

Brandt fees are attorney fees you reasonably incur to force an insurer to pay benefits it tortiously withheld, and California treats them as damages. They come from Brandt v. Superior Court (1985) 37 Cal.3d 813, which arose from a denial of disability benefits. Fees for pursuing the bad-faith claim itself are not recoverable as Brandt fees.

Brandt fees
RemedyNon-ERISA coverage (individual, DMHC/CDI, government, or church plans)Private-employer ERISA plan
Unpaid or withheld benefitsRecoverable through contract and tort claimsRecoverable under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(1)(B)
Attorney feesBrandt fees for recovering withheld benefits; not for the bad-faith claim itselfCourt may award fees under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(g)
Emotional distress damagesMay be available in a bad-faith tort claimNot available
Punitive damagesOnly on clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice (Civ. Code § 3294)Not available
Other reliefInterest and other losses caused by the denial, depending on the factsPotential interest and appropriate equitable relief under § 1132(a)(3)

Why the ERISA line matters so much

The table shows the practical difference. Under ERISA, you generally can't recover for the stress of fighting your plan or seek punitive damages, however the claim was handled. Government and church plans are exempt from ERISA, and they generally retain California bad-faith remedies against the insurer, although plan structure and the identity of the defendant can matter. Our overview of remedies for bad faith insurance practices goes further.

How Long Do You Have to Challenge an Aetna Denial in California?

California courts generally apply the two-year period of Code Civ. Proc. § 339(1) to bad-faith tort claims (Love v. Fire Ins. Exchange (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 1136) and the four-year period of § 337(a) to claims on the written policy. These periods commonly run from the insurer's unequivocal denial, but accrual, tolling, and contractual limitation clauses in the policy can shorten or shift them. There's no single universal deadline, which is why prompt review by an attorney matters.

An unequivocal denial is a clear, final refusal to pay. An "under review" letter or a request for more records doesn't count. Whether a particular letter qualifies is often a contested question, so don't assume your clock hasn't started.

How Long Do You Have to Challenge an Aetna Denial in California?
DeadlineApplies toSourceWhat can change it
Routine authorization decision: 5 business days; urgent: 72 hoursDMHC-regulated plansHealth & Saf. Code § 1367.01Clock starts when the plan receives reasonably necessary information
Grievance resolved within 30 days; 72 hours if expeditedDMHC-regulated plansHealth & Saf. Code §§ 1368, 1368.01Expedited review requires an imminent and serious threat to health
IMR application ordinarily within six months of the written grievance responseDMHC-regulated plansHealth & Saf. Code § 1374.30DMHC may accept later applications for good cause
Claim paid, or contested or denied in writing, within 30 calendar days of receiptCDI-regulated health policiesInsurance Code § 10123.13A contested or denied claim requires written notice with the specific reasons
No suit before 60 days after written proof of loss, nor after three years from when proof is requiredCDI-regulated health policiesIns. Code § 10350.11The exact wording of the policy's own clause
Bad-faith tort: commonly two years; written policy: commonly four yearsNon-ERISA coverageCode Civ. Proc. §§ 339(1), 337(a)Accrual date, tolling, and contractual limitation provisions
Internal appeal filed within 180 daysPrivate-employer ERISA plans29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1Plan terms and claim type

Policy language can work in your favor too. In Blue Shield of Cal. Life & Health Ins. Co. v. Superior Court (Kawakita) (2011), a published decision, the insurer's own policy clause gave the insured three years to sue for tortious breach of the implied covenant. That's why we read the clause itself rather than relying on the general rule.

Health Insurance Results That Shaped California Coverage

Gianelli & Morris's health insurance results come from class actions and individual trials against California health plans. These cases did not involve Aetna, and past results do not predict the outcome of any future matter. We include them because they show the kinds of coverage practices our firm has challenged and the courts where those challenges were decided.

Health Insurance Results That Shaped California Coverage
CaseCourtCoverage issueResult
Gallimore v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc.Alameda County Superior Court, No. RG12-616206California reconstructive surgery law; excess skin removal after major weight lossClass action trial judgment; benefits to Kaiser members estimated to exceed $150 million (an estimated benefit value, not money recovered)
LaRue v. Accountable Health Care IPALos Angeles Superior Court, No. BC566095Failure to provide a timely surgical referral$7.2 million jury verdict
Arce v. Kaiser Foundation Health PlanCalifornia courtsDenial of autism treatmentsClass action that formed the basis of Robert Gianelli's CLAY Award
Trujillo v. United HealthcareCalifornia courtsCoverage for prosthetic limbsClass action for amputees denied prosthetic coverage
Dion v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc.California courtsResidential mental health treatmentCoverage case concerning residential treatment for severe mental illness

Why does a class history matter on an individual Aetna page? Because a denial that stems from a blanket exclusion or misapplied criteria may affect other members too. Gallimore started with individual requests for surgery that the plan treated the same way. Our page on coverage denials for excess skin surgery explains the issue behind that case, and you can read about Robert S. Gianelli's CLAY Award for Arce.

Key insight: A single denial letter rarely shows whether a plan applies the same criteria to every member. The answer usually comes from the plan's internal guidelines, which is one reason we ask early whether a challenge to the broader practice makes sense.

Los Angeles Courts and Agencies That Handle Aetna Denial Disputes

Aetna denial disputes in Los Angeles move through two state agencies and, if litigation follows, the Los Angeles County Superior Court. Civil insurance cases filed in the Superior Court's downtown Los Angeles district are commonly heard at the Stanley Mosk Courthouse, 111 N. Hill St., but your case notice and assigned department control where your matter is actually heard. Some cases end up in other venues depending on the parties and claims involved.

The administrative agencies

The Department of Managed Health Care runs the grievance oversight and IMR program for Knox-Keene plans. The California Department of Insurance oversees CDI-regulated policies and enforces the Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations. Which agency you deal with depends on the plan-type question covered above. Our article on the role of the DMHC in health insurance denials explains how that agency's decisions can affect a later lawsuit.

The courthouse

A bad-faith lawsuit is a civil case. LaRue v. Accountable Health Care IPA was tried in Los Angeles Superior Court, which is where many Los Angeles policyholders' claims would be filed. General information about court procedures is available from California Courts.

What affects timing

We don't publish average case durations, because the honest answer depends on the case. Timing depends on:

  • Whether administrative review has finished
  • Whether an arbitration clause applies
  • How much of the claim file and internal guidelines the insurer produces in discovery
  • Whether the case proceeds individually or as a class
  • The court's calendar in the assigned department

Medical urgency can change the order of steps. When care can't wait, expedited review comes first.

What Happens When You Contact Gianelli & Morris About an Aetna Denial?

When you contact Gianelli & Morris, you get a free consultation to discuss your legal options. At Gianelli & Morris, we take insurance bad faith cases on a contingency fee basis, which means our fees are taken as a percentage of any award we recover. For other matter types, such as a Medi-Cal administrative appeal, we'll explain how fees would work during the consultation.

Who you'll be working with

Robert S. Gianelli's work for health insurance policyholders includes Arce v. Kaiser and the $7.2 million LaRue verdict. He also received the Consumer Attorneys of California 'Street Fighter of the Year' Award. His attorney profile lists more of his cases. Our firm also has attorneys whose trial and class-action work spans other kinds of insurance disputes, and that depth is available if your matter grows beyond a single claim. You can confirm any California lawyer's license through the State Bar of California.

What to bring

You'll get more out of the consultation if you gather:

  • Every denial, modification, or delay letter, with dates
  • Your evidence of coverage or policy, and your ID card
  • Grievance and appeal filings, plus any responses
  • Your physician's notes or letter of medical necessity
  • Bills and proof of out-of-pocket payments
  • Employer plan documents, if the coverage came through work

Missing something? Come anyway. Sorting out which documents exist is part of the first conversation.

The information on this page is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is unique, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Contact a qualified attorney to discuss your specific situation.

Your IMR window ordinarily closes six months after the plan's written grievance response, and lawsuit periods can start running at the first unequivocal denial. If Aetna has said no to care you need, call Gianelli & Morris at 213-489-1600 for a free consultation. We represent policyholders in Los Angeles County and throughout California, and we've been doing this work since 1979.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does an Aetna denial lawyer cost in California?

At Gianelli & Morris, insurance bad faith cases are handled on a contingency fee basis, which means our fees are taken as a percentage of any award we recover. If there's no recovery on a bad-faith claim, you don't owe attorney fees. For other matters, such as administrative appeals, we explain fee arrangements during the free consultation. You can also ask how case expenses are handled before you decide anything.

How long do I have to sue Aetna over a denied claim in California?

California courts generally apply a two-year period to bad-faith tort claims (Code Civ. Proc. § 339(1)) and a four-year period to claims for breach of the written policy (§ 337(a)), commonly running from the insurer's unequivocal denial. Accrual, tolling, and contractual limitation clauses in your policy can shorten or shift those dates. ERISA plans follow different federal rules. Have an attorney calculate your specific deadline rather than relying on the general rule.

How long do I have to request Independent Medical Review after an Aetna denial?

For a DMHC-regulated plan, you ordinarily must apply within six months of the plan's written response to your grievance under Health & Saf. Code § 1374.30. The DMHC can accept later applications for good cause, but that's discretionary. If the plan doesn't resolve your grievance within 30 days (three days if expedited), you can apply without waiting for its decision.

What is my Aetna denial case worth?

No one can honestly put a number on it before reviewing the facts. In a non-ERISA California case, value can depend on the withheld benefits, Brandt fees, other losses caused by the denial, and whether there is clear and convincing evidence supporting punitive damages under Civ. Code § 3294. For private-employer ERISA plans, recovery is generally limited to the benefit plus potential interest, attorney fees, and equitable relief.

My Aetna coverage comes through my job. Can you still help?

It depends on the employer. Plans sponsored by private employers are generally governed by ERISA, and Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases. Plans for government employers, such as cities, school districts, and fire departments, and plans for church employers are exempt from ERISA. Those plans generally keep California bad-faith remedies against the insurer, so they may fall within the cases we evaluate.

Should I accept Aetna's offer to approve part of the treatment?

Not before you understand what you'd be giving up. In California, a partial approval or modification of requested care is itself a decision you can grieve and take to Independent Medical Review on a DMHC plan. Accepting a lesser treatment may affect your medical options and the record of what was actually denied. Talk to your treating physician, and consider getting legal advice before agreeing.

What if I made a mistake, like not getting prior authorization first?

A missed prior authorization doesn't automatically end the matter in California. The questions include what the provider's office submitted, whether the care was an emergency, and whether the plan handled the claim reasonably under its own rules and state utilization-review law. Insurers must still investigate fairly. Bring your records so the actual sequence of events can be reviewed.

Do I need a lawyer to appeal an Aetna denial?

You aren't required to have one. Many people file grievances and IMR applications on their own, and the DMHC's IMR process costs nothing. A lawyer can help when the stakes are high, when deadlines overlap, or when the denial may reflect unreasonable claims handling that supports a bad-faith claim under California law. Early advice can also keep the administrative record usable if litigation follows.

How long does an Aetna denial case take?

It varies with the path, and we don't quote averages. A DMHC grievance must be resolved within 30 days (72 hours if expedited), but a California bad-faith lawsuit takes longer. How much longer depends on discovery, any arbitration clause, whether the case is individual or class-wide, and the court's calendar. Urgent medical needs can be pushed through expedited review first.

Will my Aetna case go to trial?

Not necessarily. Some disputes resolve at the grievance or IMR stage, and lawsuits can resolve before trial. When a California case does go to trial, a jury decides whether the insurer acted unreasonably. That's why we assess early whether the record would persuade a jury. Under Wilson v. 21st Century, ignoring the treating physician's evidence is the kind of fact that can support a bad-faith finding.

How do I pay for treatment while I'm fighting Aetna's denial?

Options depend on your situation. Some people pay out of pocket and seek reimbursement, some work out arrangements with providers, and some ask for expedited review so the coverage decision comes faster. Keep every receipt. In a non-ERISA California case, out-of-pocket costs caused by a wrongful denial may become part of your damages.

Is Gruenberg v. Aetna the same Aetna that denied my claim?

Gruenberg v. Aetna Ins. Co. (1973) is the California Supreme Court case that established first-party insurance bad faith, and it involved an insurer named Aetna Insurance Company. It wasn't a health insurance case. Its importance is the rule it created: every California insurance policy carries an implied covenant of good faith, and unreasonably withholding benefits can create tort liability.

Can I sue Aetna under Insurance Code 790.03?

No. Under Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund (1988), Insurance Code § 790.03 creates no private right of action, and enforcement belongs to the Insurance Commissioner. You can still bring a common-law bad-faith claim, and the unfair-practice standards in § 790.03 remain relevant evidence of what reasonable claims handling looks like.