Skip to main content
Gianelli & Morris attorneys Alex Gianelli, Joshua S. Davis, Robert S. Gianelli and Loring Rose

Protecting insuredrights since 1979

We fight insurance companies that refuse to pay.

Insurance companies don’t always play fair. Our insurance claim attorneys help policyholders fight denied, delayed, or underpaid insurance claims and recover what they’re owed.

Free Consultation

California Medical Necessity Insurance Denial Lawyer

Free Consultation

Under California law, a health plan that refuses care as "not medically necessary" must put the denial in writing, have a licensed physician or competent licensed health professional make it, and state the criteria and clinical reasons (Health & Safety Code § 1367.01). For DMHC-regulated plans, a no-cost Independent Medical Review is generally available after the plan's grievance process. Employer-sponsored ERISA plans follow different federal rules.

Your health plan says a surgery, medication, therapy, or device isn't medically necessary. Two questions follow: is that decision right, and what can you do about it? This guide draws on the practice of Robert S. Gianelli, a Gianelli & Morris partner known for insurance bad faith litigation and class actions on behalf of policyholders. He received the California Lawyer Attorney of the Year (CLAY) Award for his work on Arce v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, a class action over denied autism treatments. Our Los Angeles firm brings 40+ years serving California policyholders to every denial we review.

We've been serving since 1979, and we focus on insurance disputes rather than general personal injury work. Our results include LaRue v. Health Net of California, a $7.2 million jury verdict in Los Angeles Superior Court for failure to provide a timely surgical referral. We handle insurance bad faith cases on contingency, so there's no fee unless we recover. Review windows and filing periods can run at the same time, so call 213-489-1600 for a free consultation.

Key Takeaways

  • For DMHC-regulated plans, the plan must resolve a grievance within 30 days, or 72 hours when expedited. An Independent Medical Review application is ordinarily due within six months of the plan's written response, and the DMHC can accept later applications for good cause (H&S Code § 1374.30).
  • California Insurance Code § 790.03 sets claims-handling standards the Department of Insurance enforces. It creates no private lawsuit (Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund (1988) 46 Cal.3d 287). The lawsuit itself is a common-law bad-faith claim.
  • California courts generally apply a two-year period (CCP § 339(1)) to bad-faith tort claims and a four-year period (CCP § 337(a)) to claims on the written policy, commonly running from the insurer's unequivocal denial. Accrual, tolling, and the policy's own suit clause can shorten or shift those periods.
  • Private-employer group plans are generally governed by ERISA, which preempts bad-faith tort, punitive, and emotional-distress damages. Government and church plans are exempt from ERISA and generally retain California bad-faith remedies against the insurer.
  • Punitive damages in a California bad-faith case require clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice (Civil Code § 3294).

What Does a "Not Medically Necessary" Denial Actually Put at Risk?

In California, a medical necessity denial can delay treatment, shift the cost of care onto you, and start legal deadlines running, all from a single letter. Under California law, several clocks can start from the same denial: the plan's grievance timeline, the six-month window ordinarily allowed for Independent Medical Review, and the limitations periods courts apply to lawsuits. None of them waits for you to feel ready.

The medical cost of waiting

A denial of prior authorization leaves you with three bad choices. Pay for the care yourself, wait while you appeal, or go without. For progressive conditions, waiting has a price of its own.

California juries have recognized that delay itself can cause harm. In LaRue v. Health Net of California, Inc. et al. (L.A. Super. Ct. No. BC566095), a jury returned a $7.2 million verdict against defendants for failing to provide a timely surgical referral. That verdict doesn't predict any other case. But it shows how seriously a jury can view a health plan's delay.

The financial and paperwork cost

Families facing a denial often end up juggling medical bills, grievance forms, and phone calls with customer service lines, all while managing an illness. Missing one step can matter. A grievance filed late, an IMR application that misses its window, or a lawsuit filed after a policy's suit deadline can each narrow your options.

What "medical necessity" really means

Medical necessity is the standard a health plan uses to decide whether requested care is appropriate and needed to diagnose or treat your condition, judged against your plan contract and the clinical criteria the plan adopts. For most care, the controlling definition is in your Evidence of Coverage or policy, not in a general dictionary. Mental health and substance use disorder treatment is different: for DMHC-regulated plans, Health & Safety Code § 1374.72(a)(3) defines medically necessary treatment in the statute itself.

That's why the wording matters. Plans often apply internal guidelines when making these calls, and you can read more about what a medical policy is and how insurers use one.

Here's a hypothetical that shows how this plays out. A Los Angeles patient's orthopedic surgeon requests spinal surgery after months of failed conservative care. The plan denies it, citing a guideline requirement for a longer course of physical therapy. The surgeon's records already document that therapy. Whether the reviewer actually read those records is exactly the kind of question that shapes both an appeal and any later claim.

If this sounds familiar, a short conversation with our team can help sort out which deadlines apply to your denial.

Gate, Record, Remedy: How We Evaluate a California Medical Necessity Denial

Gate, Record, Remedy is the six-step sequence we use to evaluate a California health insurance denial for a policyholder. It identifies which legal regime governs your coverage, keeps every running deadline in view, tests the denial against California's utilization-review and claims-handling standards, and then weighs administrative review against litigation. It's a framework for analysis, not a promise of any result.

Step 1: Identify the governing path

Who sponsors and regulates your coverage shapes everything that follows. A private employer-sponsored group plan generally points toward federal ERISA law, which courts have held preempts state bad-faith tort claims. HMOs and most managed-care plans fall under the Knox-Keene Act (H&S Code § 1340 et seq.) and the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC). Health insurance policies regulated by the California Department of Insurance (CDI) follow the Insurance Code instead.

Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases. If your coverage is ERISA-governed, we'll explain why a different path applies. If the regime is unclear, we resolve that question before taking any other step.

Documents we look at: your Evidence of Coverage or policy, enrollment and premium records, any employer plan documents, and your insurance ID card.

Step 2: Lock down the clock

Several deadlines can run at once. The DMHC IMR window, the two-year and four-year limitation periods courts commonly apply, and any suit clause in a CDI-regulated policy can all be in play. We read the policy's own clause and identify every denial date that may trigger a period.

If a deadline is approaching, preserving the claim comes before refining strategy. An ongoing or equivocal denial raises its own questions about when a period started, and counsel has to resolve them individually.

Step 3: Take the denial letter apart

For Knox-Keene plans, only a licensed physician or competent licensed health care professional may deny care as not medically necessary. The denial must be written and must give the criteria used and the clinical reasons (H&S Code § 1367.01). CDI-regulated insurers face parallel utilization-review rules (Ins. Code § 10123.135) and must state every basis for a denial (10 Cal. Code Regs. § 2695.7).

Gaps matter here. A non-clinician reviewer, missing criteria, boilerplate reasoning, or a late decision can strengthen both an administrative appeal and a later claim of unreasonable handling. A denial that's facially complete shifts the focus to the medical merits.

Step 4: Choose the review route

For DMHC plans, a grievance comes first, followed by a no-cost DMHC Independent Medical Review. Experimental or investigational denials for life-threatening or seriously debilitating conditions have their own external review (H&S Code § 1370.4). CDI policies have a separate IMR (Ins. Code § 10169).

We look at whether expedited review fits your condition and build any IMR submission around your treating physician's evidence. We also decide early whether the matter may warrant litigation alongside or after review.

Step 5: Test the insurer's investigation

California's genuine-dispute defense protects an insurer only when its position rests on a reasonable, good-faith investigation (Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co. (2007) 42 Cal.4th 713). A one-sided review, or one that ignored the treating physician, can support a tort claim. A documented, reasoned medical disagreement may point toward a contract claim or administrative relief instead.

We also check for an arbitration provision early, because it affects where the claim can be heard.

Step 6: Match the remedy and the scale

The final step compares three approaches: an individual appeal, an individual lawsuit, or a broader challenge to a practice. Where a denial reflects a uniform policy, such as a blanket exclusion or misapplied criteria, our class action background makes it worth asking whether other members face the same practice.

The limits of this framework: It doesn't apply to ERISA-governed plans except to screen them. Deadlines depend on your specific policy and facts. Past results describe our experience and don't predict the outcome of any future matter.

Want to know where your denial falls in this sequence? Call 213-489-1600 and bring your denial letter to the conversation.

Who Regulates Your Health Plan, and Why Does It Decide Your Options?

In California, the agency and law governing your health coverage determine which appeal route you take, which deadlines apply, and whether you can sue for bad faith. A Knox-Keene plan goes through the DMHC, a CDI-regulated policy goes through the Insurance Code, and a private-employer group plan is generally governed by ERISA, with one major exception: government and church plans are exempt from ERISA.

Many people don't know which category they're in. The ID card might say "Blue Shield" or "Anthem," but that name alone doesn't tell you whether the product is a DMHC-licensed plan or a CDI-regulated policy, or whether your employer's plan is ERISA-governed.

Who Regulates Your Health Plan, and Why Does It Decide Your Options?
Coverage TypeRegulator or Governing LawKey RulesReview RouteBad-Faith Tort Claim
HMO or most managed-care plansDMHC under the Knox-Keene ActH&S Code §§ 1340 et seq., 1367.01Plan grievance, then DMHC Independent Medical Review (§ 1374.30)Generally available if the plan is not ERISA-governed
Health insurance policy regulated by the Department of InsuranceCalifornia Department of InsuranceIns. Code § 10123.135; 10 Cal. Code Regs. § 2695.7Insurer review, then CDI Independent Medical Review (Ins. Code § 10169)Generally available if the policy is not ERISA-governed
Private-employer group planFederal ERISA29 U.S.C. §§ 1132, 1144; 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1Internal plan appeal filed within 180 daysGenerally preempted; Gianelli & Morris does not handle these cases
Government or church planExempt from ERISACalifornia law generally appliesDepends on whether the plan is DMHC-licensed or CDI-regulatedGenerally retained against the insurer, depending on plan structure
Medi-Cal managed care planMedi-Cal administrative appeals systemW&I Code §§ 10950–10951; 42 C.F.R. §§ 438.402, 438.408Plan appeal within 60 days of the Notice of Action, then state fair hearing within 120 days of the Notice of Appeal ResolutionSeparate administrative remedy system

Why ERISA changes the analysis

ERISA preemption is the federal rule that displaces state laws "relating to" employee benefit plans, except laws that regulate insurance (29 U.S.C. § 1144). For private-employer plans, the U.S. Supreme Court held in Pilot Life Ins. Co. v. Dedeaux (1987) 481 U.S. 41 that state bad-faith claims are preempted. Later decisions narrowed parts of that reasoning, but the practical result for most employer plans remains a federal claim for benefits.

Public employees and religious workers

Teachers, police officers, firefighters, other public employees, and religious workers often have government or church plans that fall outside ERISA. These members generally retain California bad-faith remedies against the insurer, though plan structure and the identity of the defendant can matter. We explain more in our page on how public employee insurance denials are different.

What Must a Medical Necessity Denial Letter Contain Under California Law?

California requires a Knox-Keene health plan's medical necessity denial to be written, made by a licensed physician or competent licensed health care professional, and to include a clear and concise explanation, the criteria or guidelines used, and the clinical reasons (H&S Code § 1367.01). A letter that's missing any of those elements is more than a formality problem: it can strengthen your grievance and becomes part of the record if the denial is later challenged as unreasonable. CDI-regulated insurers follow parallel rules under Ins. Code § 10123.135.

Utilization review is the process a health plan uses to decide whether requested care meets its medical necessity standards before, during, or after treatment. It's the step where most medical necessity denials originate.

Who is allowed to deny care?

Only a qualified clinician. Under § 1367.01, a request can't be denied or modified for medical necessity reasons by a non-clinical staffer. You can read the full text of these provisions through the California Codes site maintained by the Legislature.

When we review a denial, the reviewer's identity and credentials are among the first things we check. A specialist reviewing a request outside their field, or a letter that names no reviewer at all, raises questions worth pursuing.

How fast must a plan decide?

For Knox-Keene plans, routine prospective utilization-review decisions must be made within five business days of receiving the information reasonably necessary to decide, and urgent ones within 72 hours (H&S Code § 1367.01). The clock depends on when the plan has that information, so a plan that keeps requesting records can affect the timeline.

For CDI-regulated health insurers, Insurance Code § 10123.13 requires the insurer to pay a claim, or notify you in writing that it is contesting or denying it and give the specific reasons, within 30 calendar days of receiving it.

What a vague denial letter tells you

A denial that just says "not medically necessary" with no criteria and no clinical reasoning doesn't meet the standard California sets. We've written about why failing to explain a denial can matter legally.

But a complete-looking letter isn't the end of the story either. Key insight: The criteria a plan cites deserve as much scrutiny as the conclusion. A plan can quote a guideline accurately and still apply it to facts it didn't review, or rely on criteria that lag behind current medical evidence. We discussed one example in our analysis of how medical necessity criteria were used in Harvoni denials.

What to gather now

  • Every denial and appeal letter, with dates
  • The criteria or guideline the plan cited
  • Your Evidence of Coverage or policy
  • Records of every call, including dates and names
  • Your treating physician's notes supporting the request

How Do Grievances and Independent Medical Review Work in California?

For a DMHC-regulated plan, you file a grievance with the plan first, and the plan must resolve it within 30 days, or within 72 hours when expedited for a serious threat to your health. If the plan upholds the denial, or hasn't resolved your grievance within 30 days (three days in expedited cases), you can apply to the DMHC for Independent Medical Review at no cost, ordinarily within six months of the plan's written response (H&S Code § 1374.30). The DMHC can accept a later application for good cause, so a missed window doesn't automatically end that path.

A grievance is a formal written complaint to your health plan asking it to reconsider a decision. For DMHC plans, it's generally the step that has to come before IMR. Our guide to the California health insurance grievance system explains the plan's obligations in more detail.

Independent Medical Review (IMR) is an external review in which independent physicians, not employed by your plan, evaluate whether a denied, modified, or delayed service is medically necessary. If IMR finds in your favor, the plan must comply.

Building the strongest IMR record

IMR reviewers decide based on what's in front of them. A short form with a one-line complaint gives them little to work with.

A stronger submission usually includes:

  • A detailed letter of medical necessity from your treating physician explaining why the requested care fits your condition
  • The medical records documenting prior treatments and their results
  • Peer-reviewed literature supporting the treatment, when available
  • A clear response to each reason in the plan's denial

If you're preparing that first written appeal, our article on writing an appeal letter for a health insurance denial walks through the structure. You can also learn more about the DMHC's role in health insurance denials.

Experimental and investigational denials

When a plan calls a treatment experimental or investigational, a separate rule may apply. California requires health plans to provide an external, independent review of those decisions for enrollees with a life-threatening or seriously debilitating condition who meet the statute's criteria (H&S Code § 1370.4).

CDI-regulated policies

If your coverage is a CDI-regulated health insurance policy rather than a Knox-Keene plan, a separate IMR runs through the Department of Insurance under Ins. Code § 10169. The statute and Department rules govern how and when to apply.

If you're a Medi-Cal managed care member

Medi-Cal follows its own order. You must first appeal to the plan within 60 days of the Notice of Action, and the plan decides within 30 days (72 hours if expedited). Only after the plan upholds the denial does the state fair hearing window open: 120 days from the plan's Notice of Appeal Resolution, not from the original denial (W&I Code § 10951(b)). Going directly to a hearing is allowed only through deemed exhaustion, such as when no notice was sent, the appeal wasn't decided on time, or the resolution notice was defective. To keep aid paid pending, you must request it within 10 days of the notice or before the effective date.

How do IMR outcomes break down across the state? The DMHC publishes data, and we've written about DMHC Independent Medical Review data and what it means for patients.

When Does a Medical Necessity Denial Become Insurance Bad Faith?

Under California law, every insurance policy carries an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, and an insurer that unreasonably withholds policy benefits from its own insured can be liable in tort (Gruenberg v. Aetna Ins. Co. (1973) 9 Cal.3d 566). A denial is not bad faith simply because it was wrong; the question is whether it was unreasonable, and an insurer's position is protected only if it rests on a reasonable, good-faith investigation. ERISA-governed employer plans are the main exception, because federal preemption generally bars the bad-faith tort.

The implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing is a duty the law places on every insurer, separate from the written terms of the policy. It requires the insurer not to frustrate your right to receive the benefits you paid for.

The genuine dispute doctrine

The genuine dispute doctrine is a defense that shields an insurer from bad-faith liability when it had a reasonable, good-faith basis to dispute coverage. California's Supreme Court limited that defense in Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co. (2007) 42 Cal.4th 713. A jury could find bad faith where the insurer reached its medical conclusion without fairly investigating and disregarded the treating physician's evidence.

That's directly relevant to medical necessity cases. These denials often turn on a clash between your doctor's judgment and a plan reviewer's reading of a guideline.

What Insurance Code § 790.03 does and doesn't do

California's Unfair Claims Settlement Practices statute, Insurance Code § 790.03, lists claims-handling conduct the Department of Insurance treats as unfair. It creates no private right of action (Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund Ins. Cos. (1988) 46 Cal.3d 287). You can't sue "under" § 790.03, but its standards remain relevant evidence of what reasonable claims handling looks like in a common-law bad-faith case. Learn more about California Insurance Code 790.03 and bad faith.

Facts that can point toward bad faith

Not every denial supports a lawsuit. These features deserve a closer look:

  • The reviewer never addressed the treating physician's records or reasoning
  • The denial rests on criteria applied to facts the plan didn't review
  • The letter gives no clinical reasons, contrary to H&S Code § 1367.01
  • Decisions missed the time limits set by California law
  • The plan sought information not reasonably required to decide the claim (10 Cal. Code Regs. § 2695.7)

One documented example: we've written about overcoming an Anthem "lack of medical necessity" denial involving a debilitating disease.

Contract claim versus tort claim

A contract claim seeks the benefits the policy promised. A tort claim for bad faith goes further and can open the door to additional damages. If the plan's decision reflects a documented, reasoned medical disagreement, a contract claim or administrative relief may fit better. And if it reflects a one-sided review, the tort claim deserves serious evaluation.

How Long Do You Have to Act on a Medical Necessity Denial in California?

California has no single deadline for a medical necessity denial. Courts generally apply a two-year period to bad-faith tort claims (CCP § 339(1); Love v. Fire Ins. Exchange (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 1136) and a four-year period to claims on the written policy (CCP § 337(a)), commonly running from the insurer's unequivocal denial. Accrual, tolling, and contractual limitations provisions in the policy can shorten or shift those periods, which is why prompt attorney review matters.

An unequivocal denial is a clear, final refusal of a claim, as opposed to a request for more information or an ongoing review. Because periods commonly run from that point, figuring out when it happened can be one of the harder questions in a case.

How Long Do You Have to Act on a Medical Necessity Denial in California?
DeadlineTime PeriodAuthorityImportant Limits
DMHC plan grievance decision30 days; 72 hours if expeditedH&S Code §§ 1368, 1368.01Applies only to DMHC-regulated (Knox-Keene) plans
DMHC Independent Medical Review applicationOrdinarily within six months of the plan's written grievance responseH&S Code § 1374.30DMHC can accept later applications for good cause
CDI insurer claim decisionPay, or contest or deny in writing, within 30 calendar days of receiptIns. Code § 10123.13A contested or denied claim requires written notice with the specific reasons
Suit clause in CDI-regulated health policyNo suit before 60 days after written proof of loss, nor after three years from when proof of loss is requiredIns. Code § 10350.11The policy's own wording controls and must be read
Bad-faith tort claimTwo years, commonly from the unequivocal denialCCP § 339(1); Love v. Fire Ins. ExchangeAccrual, tolling, and policy clauses can shift it
Breach of the written policyFour years, commonly from the unequivocal denialCCP § 337(a)Policy suit clauses can shorten it
ERISA internal appeal180 days to file; decisions in 72 hours (urgent), 30 days (pre-service), up to 60 days (post-service)29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA cases

A policy clause can give more time, too

Suit clauses don't always cut against you. In Blue Shield of Cal. Life & Health Ins. Co. v. Superior Court (Kawakita), a published 2011 Court of Appeal decision, the insurer's own policy clause gave the insured three years to sue for tortious breach of the implied covenant.

Don't blend the clocks

The 30-day and 72-hour grievance timelines apply to DMHC-regulated plans. ERISA plans follow federal claims rules with different timeframes. Mixing them up is a common source of confusion, and we sort it out at the start of every review.

What Can You Recover, and How Does ERISA Change the Answer?

In a California bad-faith case outside ERISA, recoverable damages may include the withheld benefits, tort damages caused by the insurer's unreasonable conduct, and attorney fees reasonably incurred to recover benefits tortiously withheld (Brandt v. Superior Court (1985) 37 Cal.3d 813). Private-employer ERISA plans are different: bad-faith tort, punitive, and emotional-distress damages are preempted, and recovery is generally limited to the benefit plus potential interest, attorney fees under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(g), and appropriate equitable relief under § 1132(a)(3). Government and church plans generally retain California remedies.

Brandt fees are the attorney fees an insured reasonably incurs to compel payment of benefits the insurer tortiously withheld, which California treats as recoverable damages. Fees spent pursuing the bad-faith claim itself are not recoverable under that rule.

What Can You Recover, and How Does ERISA Change the Answer?
RemedyNon-ERISA Coverage (Individual, DMHC, CDI, Government, or Church Plan)Private-Employer ERISA Plan
Withheld benefitsRecoverable through a claim on the policyRecoverable through a claim for benefits under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(1)(B)
Bad-faith tort damages, including emotional distressMay be available when benefits were unreasonably withheld (Gruenberg)Generally preempted
Attorney feesBrandt fees for recovering tortiously withheld benefitsCourt may award fees under § 1132(g)
Punitive damagesOnly on clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice (Civil Code § 3294)Not available
Interest and equitable reliefEvaluated based on the specific claimPotential interest and appropriate equitable relief under § 1132(a)(3)
Whether Gianelli & Morris handles itYes, we evaluate these mattersNo, we do not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases

Punitive damages are never assumed

California Civil Code § 3294 sets a high bar. Punitive damages in a bad-faith tort case require clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice. Many valid bad-faith claims never reach that level, and an honest evaluation says so.

What your case is worth depends on the record

We don't use averages or ranges to value a medical necessity case, because the numbers depend on the cost of the denied care, the harm caused by delay, the evidence about the insurer's investigation, and the governing law. Our overview of remedies for bad faith insurance practices explains the categories in more depth.

Verified Results in California Health Coverage Cases

Gianelli & Morris has litigated individual and class cases challenging health plan coverage decisions in California courts, and the firm has recovered hundreds of millions of dollars for policyholders. These past results describe our experience; they don't predict or guarantee the outcome of any future matter.

Verified Results in California Health Coverage Cases
CaseCoverage IssueMatter TypeWhat the Case Involved
Gallimore v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc. (Alameda County Superior Court)Excess skin surgery under California's reconstructive surgery lawClass action trialJudgment for Kaiser members, with estimated benefits exceeding $150 million
LaRue v. Health Net of California, Inc. et al. (L.A. Super. Ct. No. BC566095)Failure to provide a timely surgical referralIndividual jury trial$7.2 million jury verdict
Arce v. Kaiser Foundation Health PlanDenial of autism treatmentsClass actionBasis of Robert S. Gianelli's CLAY Award
Trujillo v. United HealthcareCoverage of prosthetic limbs for amputeesClass actionChallenge to prosthetic-limb coverage denials
Dion v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc.Residential mental health treatmentClass actionCoverage of residential mental health treatment

Why class cases matter for a single denial

Gallimore is a useful example. The estimated benefits there, exceeding $150 million, describe the value of care made available to Kaiser members, not money paid to a single person. It began with denials of excess skin surgery after major weight loss, which we discuss in our page on coverage denials for excess skin surgery.

That's the reason Step 6 of our framework asks whether your denial reflects a uniform practice. Sometimes one person's denial is part of something larger.

Litigating Medical Necessity Cases in Los Angeles County Superior Court

When a non-ERISA medical necessity dispute becomes a lawsuit in Los Angeles County, it's typically filed in the Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles. Civil insurance litigation in downtown Los Angeles is venued at the Stanley Mosk Courthouse, 111 N. Hill St., but the courthouse and department hearing your case are set by your case notice and assignment, not by general rules. Always check your filed paperwork for the assigned courtroom.

What local experience means here

Our firm has tried a health coverage case to verdict before a Los Angeles jury. LaRue v. Health Net of California, Inc. et al., Case No. BC566095, was litigated in Los Angeles Superior Court and produced a $7.2 million jury verdict for failure to provide a timely surgical referral. Delays in referrals and authorizations are a recurring issue in managed care, and we've written about how HMOs delay access to care.

Statewide court rules, forms, and self-help information are available from California Courts, the Judicial Council's public site.

Arbitration can change the forum

Some health plan contracts contain arbitration provisions. Whether one applies and whether it's enforceable can determine whether your case is heard by a jury in Los Angeles County or by an arbitrator. We review that question early because it affects strategy from the start.

The agencies involved

Two state agencies often appear in Los Angeles medical necessity disputes before any lawsuit. The Department of Managed Health Care runs the grievance oversight and IMR process for Knox-Keene plans. The California Department of Insurance oversees CDI-regulated health policies and enforces the claims-handling standards of Insurance Code § 790.03. Knowing which agency has jurisdiction over your plan avoids filing in the wrong place.

What Does a Medical Necessity Denial Attorney Cost in California?

At Gianelli & Morris, we take insurance bad faith cases on a contingency fee basis, which means our fees are taken as a percentage of any award we recover. For a bad-faith claim, that means you don't pay attorney fees unless we recover for you. Fee arrangements for other matters, such as administrative appeals or Independent Medical Review, are explained during your free consultation rather than assumed.

Contingency fees cover attorney fees. Case expenses are a separate subject, and we'll explain how they're handled before you sign anything. Ask us directly. You deserve a clear answer.

What happens at your consultation

We offer a Free Consultation to Discuss Your Legal Options. In that conversation, we discuss what the plan denied, which regulator governs your coverage, and which deadlines may already be running. If your coverage is an ERISA-governed employer plan, we'll tell you so and explain why the path is different.

Our team includes lawyers who have served as class counsel in coverage cases against major health insurers, which shapes how we look at whether a denial reflects a broader practice. Gianelli & Morris holds an AV Preeminent® rating, and Robert S. Gianelli is a two-time Consumer Attorney of the Year Finalist and a recipient of the Consumer Attorneys of California "Street Fighter of the Year" Award.

What to bring

  • Every denial, grievance, and appeal letter, with dates
  • Your Evidence of Coverage or full policy
  • Premium and enrollment records
  • Any employer plan documents
  • Your treating physician's notes or letter of medical necessity
  • A log of calls with the plan

You can verify any California attorney's license through the State Bar of California. For broader background on our health insurance work, visit our main page as a Los Angeles health insurance denial lawyer.

The information on this page is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Contact a qualified attorney to discuss your specific situation.

Talk With a California Medical Necessity Denial Lawyer Today

A medical necessity denial starts real deadlines. The DMHC Independent Medical Review window is ordinarily six months from the plan's written grievance response. The two-year period courts commonly apply to bad-faith tort claims can begin with the insurer's unequivocal denial, and your policy's own clause may change the math.

Gianelli & Morris has represented California policyholders against health plans and insurers since 1979, from our Los Angeles office to clients across the state. Call 213-489-1600 for a no-cost case review, and bring your denial letter so we can start with the facts.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does a medical necessity denial lawyer cost in California?

For insurance bad faith claims, Gianelli & Morris works on contingency, meaning our fees are a percentage of any award we recover, so you pay no attorney fees unless we recover. Case expenses are discussed separately before you sign. For administrative matters like a grievance or Independent Medical Review, we explain fee arrangements during your free consultation rather than assume one applies.

To set up a complimentary case evaluation, call 213-489-1600.

How long do I have to sue over a medical necessity denial in California?

California courts generally apply a two-year period to bad-faith tort claims under CCP § 339(1) and a four-year period to claims on the written policy under CCP § 337(a), commonly running from the insurer's unequivocal denial. Accrual, tolling, and suit-limitation clauses in your policy can shorten or shift those periods. An attorney should calculate your deadline from your actual documents.

Is Independent Medical Review really free?

Yes, for DMHC-regulated plans. California's Health & Safety Code § 1374.30 provides that no fee may be charged to the enrollee for Independent Medical Review. The application is ordinarily due within six months of the plan's written grievance response, though the DMHC can accept later applications for good cause.

What is my medical necessity denial case worth?

It depends on the cost of the denied care, any harm caused by delay, the evidence about how the insurer investigated, and whether your plan is governed by ERISA. Outside ERISA, California law may allow tort damages, Brandt fees, and in rare cases punitive damages on clear and convincing evidence under Civil Code § 3294. We don't assign averages to these cases because the record drives the value.

My plan offered to approve part of the treatment. Should I accept?

Not before you understand what you're giving up. A partial approval, or modification, is still a utilization-review decision under California law, and it must meet the same written-explanation requirements as a full denial under H&S Code § 1367.01. You can usually grieve a modification, and accepting care doesn't automatically waive a challenge, but any settlement document you sign may.

What if I didn't get prior authorization before treatment?

A missed prior authorization doesn't automatically end your options, but it changes the analysis. For a DMHC-regulated plan, you can still file a grievance and, if it's upheld, generally seek Independent Medical Review on whether the care was medically necessary. Emergency care has separate rules, and the specific facts matter.

How long does a medical necessity case take?

An administrative path can move quickly by legal standards: DMHC plans must resolve grievances within 30 days, or 72 hours when expedited. A lawsuit takes longer and depends on discovery, any arbitration provision, the court's calendar, and whether the case resolves before trial. We don't promise a timeline because too many factors affect it.

Do I need a lawyer for a medical necessity denial?

Not always. Many people file grievances and Independent Medical Review applications on their own, and California designed IMR to be accessible. A lawyer can help when deadlines overlap, when the denial may reflect bad faith, when significant costs or harm are involved, or when you're unsure which regulator governs your plan.

My insurance is through my employer. Can you help?

It depends on the type of plan. Private-employer group plans are generally governed by ERISA, and Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases. Government and church plans, including many plans for teachers, police officers, firefighters, and religious workers, are exempt from ERISA and generally retain California bad-faith remedies against the insurer.

Can I sue my insurer under Insurance Code § 790.03?

No. California's Supreme Court held in Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund (1988) that § 790.03 creates no private right of action, and the Department of Insurance enforces it. But you keep common-law remedies, including a bad-faith claim, and § 790.03's standards remain evidence of what reasonable claims handling looks like.

Will my case go to trial?

Most cases don't need to be decided by a jury, but some are. Whether yours goes to trial depends on the evidence, the insurer's position, any arbitration provision in your plan, and your goals. We prepare each case with the possibility of trial in mind, and our firm has taken a health coverage case to a jury verdict in Los Angeles Superior Court.

How do I pay for treatment while my case is pending?

Options depend on your situation. Some patients request expedited review when their condition is urgent, since DMHC plans must resolve expedited grievances within 72 hours. Others pay out of pocket and seek reimbursement, or work with their providers on billing. Keep every receipt, because withheld benefits and related costs may be part of any later claim.