Skip to main content
Gianelli & Morris attorneys Alex Gianelli, Joshua S. Davis, Robert S. Gianelli and Loring Rose

Protecting insuredrights since 1979

We fight insurance companies that refuse to pay.

Insurance companies don’t always play fair. Our insurance claim attorneys help policyholders fight denied, delayed, or underpaid insurance claims and recover what they’re owed.

Free Consultation

California Cigna Denial Lawyer

Free Consultation

Under California law, the way you challenge a Cigna health insurance denial depends on the type of plan you have. Knox-Keene plans use a grievance followed by DMHC Independent Medical Review, and Department of Insurance policies have their own review process. Bad-faith claims are generally subject to a two-year period under Code of Civil Procedure § 339(1), commonly measured from an unequivocal denial, but policy clauses and tolling can change that period. Private employer plans usually fall under federal ERISA instead.

Robert S. Gianelli is a Gianelli & Morris partner and a recipient of the California Lawyer Attorney of the Year (CLAY) Award. His practice centers on insurance bad faith litigation and class actions for policyholders in health, life, disability, and property disputes. This page reflects how he and our team evaluate a Cigna denial. We look at which rules govern it, which deadlines are already running, and whether the decision holds up. Our firm has 40+ years serving California policyholders and holds an AV Preeminent® rating. For the wider context, see our guide to California health insurance denial claims.

We have represented California policyholders since 1979 in disputes against insurers including Kaiser, Blue Shield, United, Anthem, and Cigna. Our health-plan results include a $7.2 million jury verdict in a Los Angeles County case over a delayed surgical referral. For bad-faith claims, you pay no attorney fee unless we recover. Call 213-489-1600 for a free consultation about your Cigna denial.

Key Takeaways

  • For Cigna plans licensed under California's Knox-Keene Act, the plan must resolve a grievance within 30 days, or within 72 hours when the case qualifies for expedited review.
  • An application for DMHC Independent Medical Review is ordinarily due within six months of the plan's written response to your grievance (Health & Safety Code § 1374.30). The DMHC can accept a later application for good cause.
  • Under Health & Safety Code § 1367.01, only a licensed physician or a competent licensed health care professional may deny care as not medically necessary. The denial must be in writing and must state the criteria used and the clinical reasons.
  • Insurance Code § 790.03 sets claims-handling standards that the Department of Insurance enforces, but it creates no private lawsuit (Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund). Your lawsuit is a common-law bad-faith claim.
  • Private-employer group plans are generally governed by ERISA, which does not allow bad-faith tort or punitive damages. Government and church plans are exempt and generally retain California bad-faith remedies against the insurer.

Who Reviews Your Cigna Denial at Gianelli & Morris?

Your denial is reviewed by a firm that represents policyholders only. We don't take insurance companies as clients, and we don't run a general personal injury practice with insurance work on the side. Every case we take is a dispute between a California policyholder and an insurer or health plan.

A practice built on policyholder cases

Robert S. Gianelli's recognition comes from health-plan litigation. His CLAY Award arose from Arce v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, a class action challenging the denial of autism treatment. He has twice been named a Consumer Attorney of the Year Finalist. He also received the Consumer Attorneys of California "Street Fighter of the Year" Award. His notable cases include the $7.2 million jury verdict in LaRue v. Health Net of California, Inc. for failure to provide a timely surgical referral. You can read more on Robert S. Gianelli's attorney profile. You can also confirm any California lawyer's license status through the State Bar of California.

Experience with Cigna and other major California health plans

Our firm's work against Cigna includes litigation over lipedema surgery coverage in Aklaghi v. Cigna, which was part of broader work on lipedema coverage involving several insurers. One attorney on our team defended insurance companies in multi-million-dollar coverage disputes at a national firm before joining Gianelli & Morris. That experience helps us read a claim file the way the other side does.

Firm-wide, we have recovered hundreds of millions of dollars. That figure describes the firm's history across many cases. It is not a prediction for yours.

What Does It Cost to Challenge a Cigna Denial?

Cost shouldn't keep you from getting answers. At Gianelli & Morris, we take insurance bad faith cases on a contingency fee basis, which means our fees are taken as a percentage of any award we recover. In practical terms, for a Cigna bad faith claim, you pay no attorney fee unless we recover money for you.

Not every Cigna dispute is a bad-faith lawsuit. Some matters call only for help with an internal appeal or an Independent Medical Review. Others may be better suited to a different kind of counsel. For matters outside a bad-faith claim, we explain fee arrangements during the no-cost consultation, before you commit to anything.

Ask us how case expenses are handled, too. Attorney fees and litigation costs are separate items, and you should understand both before you decide how to proceed. Our "Free Consultation to Discuss Your Legal Options" is the place to raise those questions.

What's at Stake When Cigna Denies Your Claim?

A Cigna denial isn't only a paperwork problem. It can decide whether you get surgery this month, whether a prescription gets filled, or whether a hospital bill goes to collections. The legal stakes are real as well: administrative review windows and lawsuit deadlines can begin running from the dates printed on your denial and grievance letters.

Care delayed while the bills keep coming

When a plan refuses prior authorization, many people end up postponing treatment. Others pay out of pocket and hope to be reimbursed later. Both options carry costs. Delay can affect your health, and paying yourself shifts the financial risk onto you while the dispute continues. LaRue shows how serious this can be: that case centered on a failure to provide a timely surgical referral, and a Los Angeles jury returned a $7.2 million verdict.

Deadlines that run in the background

Several deadlines can run at the same time. An Independent Medical Review application is ordinarily due within six months of the plan's written grievance response. Bad-faith tort claims generally carry a two-year limitations period. Many policies also include their own suit-limitation clause. None of these deadlines will appear on a calendar unless you put them there.

Missteps that are hard to undo

Common missteps include treating an appeal as an informal phone conversation, skipping expedited review when your condition is urgent, and assuming an employer plan follows California rules. Each one can narrow your options. A denial that seems final is often only the first decision in a process with several more steps.

How We Evaluate a Cigna Denial: Gate, Record, Remedy

We evaluate a new Cigna denial in a set order. First we determine which legal path governs the plan (the gate). Then we build and test the record. Finally, we match the remedy to the facts. The six steps below describe how we analyze a case. They are not a promise about any result, and every deadline still needs an individual calculation by counsel.

Step 1: Identify the governing path

Who sponsors the coverage, and who regulates it, shapes everything that follows. A Cigna plan licensed as a health care service plan under the Knox-Keene Act (Health & Safety Code § 1340 et seq.) falls under the Department of Managed Health Care. A Cigna insurance policy regulated by the California Department of Insurance follows the Insurance Code. A plan sponsored by a private employer generally points to ERISA. If the coverage is ERISA-governed, we screen the matter out and explain why a different path applies, because Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases. If it isn't clear which regime applies, we answer that question before taking any other step.

Step 2: Lock down the clock

Next, we identify every date that might start a deadline: the denial letter, the grievance decision, any later letters, and the date proof of loss was due. We read the policy's suit-limitation clause. If a deadline is close, protecting the claim comes before refining strategy. A denial that is equivocal or still open raises its own question about when the clock started, and counsel has to resolve that question for your specific facts.

Step 3: Take the denial letter apart

California sets content and timing rules for denials. For health plans, Health & Safety Code § 1367.01 requires that a clinician make any medical-necessity denial, that the denial be in writing, and that it state the criteria and clinical reasons. Routine requests must be decided within five business days and urgent requests within 72 hours. Insurers regulated by the Department of Insurance follow parallel rules under Insurance Code § 10123.135. Regulation 2695.7 also requires those insurers to state every basis for a denial. Gaps strengthen your appeal and any later claim. Examples include a non-clinician reviewer, missing criteria, boilerplate reasoning, or a late decision. Our article on what happens when an insurer fails to explain a denial covers this issue in more depth.

Step 4: Choose the review route

For DMHC plans, you file a grievance first. If Cigna upholds the denial, or if 30 days pass (72 hours for expedited cases), you can request a no-cost Independent Medical Review. Denials of experimental treatment for life-threatening or seriously debilitating conditions qualify for a separate external review under Health & Safety Code § 1370.4. Department of Insurance policies have their own IMR under Insurance Code § 10169. We build the submission around the treating physician's evidence, and we decide early whether litigation should run alongside administrative review or follow it.

Step 5: Test Cigna's investigation

Here the question shifts from whether the denial was wrong to whether it was unreasonable. A one-sided review or ignored medical evidence supports a tort claim. A documented, reasoned medical disagreement may instead point toward a contract claim or administrative relief. We also check for an arbitration provision at this stage, because it can determine where the case is heard.

Step 6: Match the remedy and the scale

Finally, we compare three approaches: an individual appeal, an individual lawsuit, or a challenge to a broader practice. The comparison weighs the strength of the evidence, your medical urgency, and whether the same denial appears to affect other members. When a denial reflects a uniform rule, such as a blanket exclusion or misapplied criteria, the firm's class action experience makes it worth asking whether others are affected in the same way.

If Cigna has already sent you a written grievance decision, your six-month Independent Medical Review window may have started. Call 213-489-1600 to talk through your dates and options with our team.

Is Your Cigna Plan Governed by California Law or by ERISA?

The answer depends on who sponsors your coverage, not on whose name appears on the card. Under federal law, ERISA generally preempts state bad-faith claims for private-employer benefit plans (29 U.S.C. § 1144; Pilot Life Ins. Co. v. Dedeaux), although government and church plans are exempt and generally keep California remedies. Many people carry a Cigna card through work, which makes this the first question to answer.

ERISA preemption is the rule that federal benefits law displaces state laws as they relate to a private employer's benefit plan. In practice, it can remove the California bad-faith tort claim entirely. Laws that regulate insurance are a recognized exception, which is one reason the analysis depends on the specific plan.

Is Your Cigna Plan Governed by California Law or by ERISA?
Plan typeRegulator or governing lawFirst review stepKey timingRemedies generally available
Cigna plan licensed as a Knox-Keene health care service planDepartment of Managed Health Care (Knox-Keene Act, Health & Safety Code § 1340 et seq.)Grievance with the plan, then DMHC Independent Medical ReviewPlan resolves grievance within 30 days (72 hours expedited); IMR application ordinarily due within six months of the plan's written grievance responseCommon-law bad-faith claim, including Brandt fees and potential punitive damages under Civil Code § 3294
Cigna policy regulated by the Department of InsuranceCalifornia Department of Insurance (Insurance Code)Internal appeal and Department of Insurance IMR (Insurance Code § 10169)Pay, or contest or deny in writing, within 30 calendar days of receipt (Insurance Code § 10123.13); suit clause under Insurance Code § 10350.11Common-law bad-faith claim, including Brandt fees and potential punitive damages under Civil Code § 3294
Private-employer group planFederal ERISA (29 U.S.C. § 1001 et seq.)Plan's internal appeal, with 180 days to file (29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1)Urgent-care claims 72 hours; pre-service 30 days; post-service up to 60 daysGenerally the benefit plus potential interest, attorney fees under § 1132(g), and equitable relief under § 1132(a)(3); no bad-faith tort, punitive, or emotional-distress damages
Government or church planExempt from ERISA; state law appliesDepends on whether the coverage is a Knox-Keene plan or an insurance policyFollows the DMHC or Department of Insurance timing that governs the coverageGenerally retains California bad-faith remedies against the insurer; plan structure and the defendant can matter

Government and church plans keep more options

Teachers, police officers, firefighters, other public employees, and religious workers often receive coverage through government or church plans. Those plans are exempt from ERISA, so members generally retain California bad-faith remedies against the insurer. Our article on how public employee insurance denials are different explains why.

Why we screen out employer plans

We tell you plainly when ERISA governs your plan, and we explain why your remedies differ. ERISA recovery isn't nothing. A court can award the benefit, potential interest, attorney fees, and appropriate equitable relief. But because Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases, we'll explain the difference so you can find the right kind of help without losing time.

Why Does Cigna Deny Health Claims, and What Must the Denial Include?

Health plans, Cigna among them, deny claims on a familiar set of grounds: lack of medical necessity, experimental or investigational status, missing prior authorization, network rules, and coverage exclusions. Under California law, the ground matters less than whether the denial meets the procedural rules that apply to it, starting with Health & Safety Code § 1367.01 for health plans. The sections below cover the most common grounds.

Medical necessity denials

Utilization review is the process a plan uses to decide whether requested care is medically necessary before or after it is delivered. In California, only a licensed physician or competent licensed health professional can deny care on that basis. The denial must identify the criteria or guidelines used. If your letter cites an internal coverage policy or clinical guideline, ask for a copy. That document often shows exactly where the reviewer's reasoning diverges from your doctor's.

Experimental or investigational denials

Plans sometimes label newer surgeries, devices, or drugs as investigational. For enrollees with a life-threatening or seriously debilitating condition who meet the statute's criteria, Health & Safety Code § 1370.4 requires an external, independent review of that decision. The firm's lipedema surgery litigation, including the case against Cigna, involved coverage disputes over procedures of this kind. Our article on fighting a health plan's "investigational" denial goes deeper on this issue.

Prior authorization, referral, and network disputes

Some denials turn on process rather than medicine. Common examples include a missing authorization, a referral that never issued, or an out-of-network provider. Delays in these steps can do as much harm as an outright refusal, as LaRue illustrates. Ask whether the plan met its own decision deadlines and whether any in-network option was actually available to you.

Rescission of coverage

Rescission means a plan cancels your coverage retroactively, as though it never existed, usually by claiming misstatements on an application. Rescission is a serious step, and California restricts it. If Cigna rescinded your coverage after you filed claims, read our article on bad faith rescission of a health insurance policy.

What about Cigna denial rates and automated review?

We don't publish a Cigna "denial rate" or a "success rate against Cigna" on this page. We are not aware of a verified, like-for-like figure that would let you compare carriers fairly, and printing a number we can't support wouldn't help you. Concerns about automated or bulk claim review come up often. If you suspect no clinician actually looked at your file, § 1367.01 gives you a concrete test: who made the decision, and on what criteria? Our article asking whether AI handled your insurance claim explains what to request.

What Language in Your Cigna Policy Should You Check First?

Your Evidence of Coverage or policy is the contract Cigna must follow. Several clauses can decide your case before anyone argues the medical merits, so read them first.

  • Definition of "medically necessary." Compare the plan's definition with the reasons in your denial letter. A mismatch matters.
  • Definition of "experimental" or "investigational." Check whether the definition turns on FDA status, published studies, or the plan's own review.
  • Prior authorization and referral provisions. Note who was responsible for obtaining approval, whether that was you, your doctor, or a medical group.
  • Network terms. Look for exceptions that allow out-of-network care when no adequate in-network provider is available.
  • Suit-limitation clause. This sets a contractual deadline for filing a lawsuit. For Department of Insurance policies, Insurance Code § 10350.11 governs its minimum terms.
  • Arbitration provision. This may require private arbitration instead of a court trial.
  • Discretionary-authority language. Wording that grants an administrator "discretion" to interpret the plan often signals an ERISA plan, which changes the analysis.

If you can't find your plan documents, request them in writing from Cigna or your plan sponsor. Keep the request and any response. A pattern of missing or late documents can become part of the record.

How Long Do You Have to Appeal or Sue After a Cigna Denial?

There isn't one deadline. There are several. California courts generally apply the two-year period of Code of Civil Procedure § 339(1) to bad-faith tort claims and the four-year period of § 337(a) to claims on the written policy, but accrual, tolling, and contractual clauses in the policy can shorten or shift either one. The period commonly runs from the insurer's unequivocal denial, meaning a clear, final refusal rather than a request for more information or a decision that is still under review. You can read the statutes themselves in the California Codes.

How Long Do You Have to Appeal or Sue After a Cigna Denial?
DeadlineApplies toSourceWhat can change it
Grievance resolved within 30 days (72 hours expedited)Knox-Keene (DMHC) plansHealth & Safety Code §§ 1368, 1368.01Expedited handling applies when health faces an imminent and serious threat
IMR application ordinarily within six months of the plan's written grievance responseKnox-Keene (DMHC) plansHealth & Safety Code § 1374.30DMHC can accept later applications for good cause
Pay, or contest or deny in writing, within 30 calendar days of receiptDepartment of Insurance policiesInsurance Code § 10123.13A contested or denied claim requires written notice with the specific reasons
No suit before 60 days after written proof of loss, nor after three years from when proof is requiredDepartment of Insurance policiesInsurance Code § 10350.11The policy's own clause controls and can be more generous
Two years for bad-faith tort claimsNon-ERISA coverageCode Civ. Proc. § 339(1); Love v. Fire Ins. Exchange (1990)Accrual date, tolling, and contractual limitations provisions
Four years for breach of the written policyNon-ERISA coverageCode Civ. Proc. § 337(a)Accrual date, tolling, and contractual limitations provisions
180 days to file the internal appealPrivate-employer (ERISA) plans29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1Plan terms; we screen these matters and do not handle them

The policy clause can work for you

Contract language doesn't always cut against the policyholder. In Blue Shield of Cal. Life & Health Ins. Co. v. Superior Court (Kawakita), a published 2011 decision, the insurer's own policy clause gave the insured three years to sue for tortious breach of the implied covenant. That is why we read the clause itself instead of assuming the general rule applies.

Don't confuse the DMHC and ERISA clocks

The 30-day and 72-hour figures above apply to state-regulated DMHC plans. ERISA group health plans also follow a federal schedule (29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1): a first decision is due within 72 hours on an urgent-care claim, 15 days on a pre-service claim, and 30 days on a post-service claim, and the plan can extend the last two once by up to 15 days. Mixing up the two schedules is an easy way to miss a deadline. Because these periods depend on your policy and facts, have an attorney review your dates promptly.

What Can You Recover in a Cigna Bad Faith Case?

Recovery depends on which law governs your plan. For non-ERISA coverage, a California bad-faith claim can include the withheld benefits, Brandt fees, damages for emotional distress where the evidence supports them, and punitive damages only on clear and convincing proof under Civil Code § 3294. ERISA plans are far more limited.

The duty behind every claim

The implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing is a duty that the law reads into every insurance policy, requiring the insurer to deal fairly with its own insured. Under Gruenberg v. Aetna Ins. Co. (1973), an insurer that unreasonably withholds benefits can be liable in tort, not only for breach of contract. Insurance Code § 790.03 describes unfair claims practices, but under Moradi-Shalal it gives you no separate lawsuit. Its standards still serve as evidence of reasonable claims handling. Our article on California Insurance Code 790.03 explains how that works.

When a "genuine dispute" isn't a defense

The genuine dispute doctrine protects an insurer that denies a claim based on a reasonable, good-faith disagreement. It applies only when the insurer actually investigated. In Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co. (2007), the California Supreme Court held that a jury could find bad faith where the insurer reached its medical conclusion without a fair investigation and disregarded the treating physician's evidence.

Brandt fees and punitive damages

Brandt fees are the attorney fees you reasonably incur to recover policy benefits an insurer tortiously withheld. Under Brandt v. Superior Court (1985), they are recoverable as damages. Fees for pursuing the bad-faith claim itself are not. Punitive damages are never assumed. They require clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice.

Brandt fees and punitive damages
Type of recoveryNon-ERISA California bad-faith claimPrivate-employer ERISA plan
Withheld policy benefitsRecoverableRecoverable under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(1)(B)
Attorney feesBrandt fees for recovering withheld benefitsCourt may award fees under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(g)
Emotional distress damagesMay be recoverable in tort, depending on the evidenceNot available
Punitive damagesOnly on clear and convincing evidence (Civil Code § 3294)Not available
Broader reliefClass-wide claims where a uniform practice affects many membersAppropriate equitable relief under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(3)

For a deeper look at damages categories, see our overview of remedies for bad faith insurance practices.

Verified Results Against Major California Health Plans

The results below are verified firm cases involving California health plans. None of them is a Cigna verdict, and none predicts the outcome of your matter. They show the kinds of denials we have litigated: delayed referrals, reconstructive surgery, prosthetics, autism treatment, and mental-health care.

Verified Results Against Major California Health Plans
CaseCoverage issueCase typeResult or significance
LaRue v. Health Net of California, Inc. et al. (L.A. Super. Ct. No. BC566095)Failure to provide a timely surgical referralIndividual jury trial$7.2 million jury verdict
Gallimore v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc. (Alameda County Super. Ct. No. RG12-616206)Excess skin surgery under California's reconstructive surgery lawClass action trialJudgment for Kaiser members; estimated benefits exceeding $150 million
Arce v. Kaiser Foundation Health PlanDenial of autism treatmentClass actionBasis of Robert S. Gianelli's CLAY Award
Trujillo v. United HealthcareCoverage for prosthetic limbsClass actionChallenged prosthetic-limb coverage denials for amputees
Dion v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc.Residential mental-health treatmentClass actionAddressed residential treatment coverage for members

The Gallimore figure is the estimated value of benefits to Kaiser members, not money paid to the firm or its clients. Related reading: our article on coverage denials for excess skin surgery.

Where Are Cigna Disputes Decided in Los Angeles County?

Most Cigna disputes begin with a state agency rather than a courtroom. For Knox-Keene plans, the Department of Managed Health Care runs Independent Medical Review; for insured policies, the California Department of Insurance handles review and enforces claims-handling standards. Litigation comes later, if it is needed.

State agencies come first

The DMHC accepts IMR applications at no cost to you and can order a plan to cover care. Our article on the role of the DMHC in health insurance denials walks through that process. The Department of Insurance enforces the Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations and Insurance Code § 790.03 against insurers it regulates.

Los Angeles County Superior Court

When a non-ERISA bad-faith case is filed in downtown Los Angeles, civil insurance litigation is generally heard at the Stanley Mosk Courthouse of the Los Angeles County Superior Court. Your summons and case assignment notice control the courthouse and department, so rely on those documents. The California Courts website offers general information on civil procedure and local court resources. LaRue was tried to verdict in Los Angeles County Superior Court, and Gallimore was tried in Alameda County. Our work is statewide.

Federal court and arbitration

ERISA claims belong to federal benefits law, which is one more reason to identify the plan type early. Some policies also contain arbitration provisions that move a dispute out of court entirely. We check for both at the outset, because they determine where your case can be heard and which rules apply.

What Should You Bring When You Talk With Us About a Cigna Denial?

Good preparation makes the first conversation more useful. The documents that matter most are the denial letter, every appeal or grievance letter with its date, and your plan documents. Bring what you have. Missing items can be requested later.

  • Your Cigna ID card and Evidence of Coverage or policy
  • Every denial, grievance, and appeal letter, including envelopes or emails showing dates
  • Any coverage policy or clinical guideline Cigna cited
  • Your treating doctor's notes or a letter of medical necessity, if you have one
  • Employer plan documents, if the coverage came through work
  • Bills, receipts, and records of what you paid out of pocket
  • A log of calls with Cigna, including names, dates, and what you were told

What happens in the first conversation

We'll ask what happened and when, determine which legal path likely applies, and flag any deadline that looks close. We'll explain your realistic options, including when a self-filed grievance or IMR may be the right first step and when litigation is worth discussing. We'll also explain fees. If your plan is ERISA-governed, we'll tell you that directly and explain why.

For practical help with an appeal, see our guides to the health insurance grievance system in California and writing an appeal letter for a health insurance denial.

The information on this page is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Please consult a qualified attorney about your specific situation.

Talk With a California Cigna Denial Lawyer About Your Next Step

Your Cigna denial letter, your grievance decision, and your policy's suit clause each carry dates that matter. The six-month IMR window and the two-year period commonly applied to bad-faith claims don't wait for you to feel ready. Gianelli & Morris has represented California policyholders since 1979, from our Los Angeles office, in cases across the state. For Cigna bad faith claims, our fee comes only from a recovery. Call 213-489-1600 to schedule a no-cost consultation and find out which deadlines apply to you.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to hire a lawyer for a Cigna denial in California?

For insurance bad faith claims, Gianelli & Morris works on a contingency fee basis, so our fee is a percentage of any award we recover and you owe no attorney fee if there is no recovery. Other matters, such as help with an administrative appeal alone, may involve different terms. We explain those arrangements, and how case expenses work, at the free consultation.

If you'd like to talk through your situation, you can reach us at 213-489-1600.

How long do I have to sue Cigna for bad faith in California?

California courts generally apply a two-year period under Code of Civil Procedure § 339(1) to bad-faith tort claims and a four-year period under § 337(a) to claims on the written policy, commonly running from the insurer's unequivocal denial. Accrual, tolling, and any contractual limitations clause in your policy can shorten or shift those periods. Because the correct date depends on your documents, have an attorney review your dates promptly.

My Cigna plan is through my employer. Can you help?

If a private employer sponsors the plan, federal ERISA generally governs it. ERISA bars bad-faith tort, punitive, and emotional-distress damages, and recovery is generally limited to the benefit plus potential interest, attorney fees, and equitable relief. Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed cases, but we can help you identify whether your plan is one. Government and church plans are exempt from ERISA and generally retain California bad-faith remedies.

What is my Cigna bad faith case worth?

Under California law, value depends on the benefits withheld, the attorney fees spent recovering them (Brandt fees), any emotional distress the evidence supports, and, only on clear and convincing proof, punitive damages under Civil Code § 3294. No average figure would be accurate for your situation. ERISA plans are far more limited, so the plan type is the first factor that affects value.

Should I accept a partial payment or settlement offer from Cigna?

Not before you understand what you would be giving up. In California, a settlement usually comes with a release, and a release can end both your benefit claim and any bad-faith claim. An offer alone doesn't prove underpayment, but it is worth reviewing with counsel before you sign anything.

Does it matter if I didn't get prior authorization or saw an out-of-network doctor?

It can, but it isn't automatically the end of the claim. California rules require plans to meet their own decision deadlines and to state their reasons clearly, and network terms sometimes allow out-of-network care when no adequate in-network option exists. The answer depends on who was responsible for the authorization and what your Evidence of Coverage says.

How long does a Cigna denial case take?

Timing varies with the path. For DMHC plans, the grievance must be resolved within 30 days, or 72 hours if expedited, before Independent Medical Review. A lawsuit depends on the court's schedule, the volume of records, motions, any arbitration clause, and whether the case is individual or class-wide. We can't responsibly give a fixed timeline, but we explain which factors apply to your case.

Do I need a lawyer to appeal a Cigna denial?

Not always. In California, you can file a grievance and a DMHC Independent Medical Review yourself, and IMR costs you nothing. A lawyer becomes more useful when the denial involves serious harm, when deadlines are tight, when the record shows an unfair investigation, or when the plan type is unclear. Counsel can also help build the medical record behind an IMR.

Will my Cigna case go to trial?

Possibly, though many disputes resolve through administrative review or settlement first. In Los Angeles County, a non-ERISA bad-faith case filed in court can proceed to a jury trial in the Superior Court, as LaRue did. An arbitration clause in the policy may instead send the dispute to private arbitration.

How do I get treatment while my Cigna dispute is pending?

If your condition is urgent, ask for expedited review. California health plans must decide urgent requests within 72 hours under Health & Safety Code § 1367.01, and DMHC grievances can be expedited when health faces an imminent and serious threat. Talk with your treating doctor about the medical urgency, and keep every receipt if you pay out of pocket.

Can I sue Cigna under Insurance Code § 790.03?

No. Under Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund (1988), § 790.03 creates no private right of action, and enforcement rests with the Insurance Commissioner. You can still bring a common-law bad-faith claim, and the statute's standards remain useful evidence of what reasonable claims handling looks like.

What if Cigna canceled my coverage after I filed claims?

A retroactive cancellation, called rescission, is a serious step that California restricts. Whether it was proper depends on what your application said and how the insurer investigated. If your coverage was rescinded after claims were filed, keep every application, letter, and premium record, and have the rescission reviewed promptly.