Skip to main content
Gianelli & Morris attorneys Alex Gianelli, Joshua S. Davis, Robert S. Gianelli and Loring Rose

Protecting insuredrights since 1979

We fight insurance companies that refuse to pay.

Insurance companies don’t always play fair. Our insurance claim attorneys help policyholders fight denied, delayed, or underpaid insurance claims and recover what they’re owed.

Free Consultation

California Insurance Bad Faith Lawyer

Free Consultation

California law reads an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing into every insurance policy. An insurer that unreasonably denies, delays, or underpays its own policyholder's claim can owe tort damages beyond the unpaid benefits (Gruenberg v. Aetna Ins. Co. (1973) 9 Cal.3d 566). Bad faith tort claims generally carry a two-year deadline, commonly measured from the insurer's unequivocal denial, though policy terms and ERISA can change the rules.

Robert S. Gianelli is a Los Angeles partner at Gianelli & Morris who takes on health, life, disability, and long-term care insurers when they refuse to pay what their policies promise. He received the California Lawyer Attorney of the Year (CLAY) Award for Arce v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, a class action challenging denied autism treatment. Our firm brings 40+ years serving California policyholders to this work, and we don't take personal injury cases on the side.

If an insurer has denied your claim, the letter in your hand may have already started a deadline. At Gianelli & Morris, we take insurance bad faith cases on a contingency fee basis, which means our fees are taken as a percentage of any award we recover. We represent policyholders across California from our Los Angeles office. We have recovered hundreds of millions of dollars. Call 213-489-1600 for a free consultation to discuss your legal options.

Key Takeaways

  • California courts generally apply a two-year period (Code Civ. Proc. § 339(1)) to bad faith tort claims and a four-year period (§ 337(a)) to claims on the written policy. Policy clauses, accrual, and tolling can shorten or shift both.
  • Insurance Code § 790.03 sets claims-handling standards that the Insurance Commissioner enforces, but it gives policyholders no private right to sue. The lawsuit itself is a common-law bad faith claim.
  • Private-employer plans governed by ERISA generally limit recovery to the benefit plus potential interest, attorney fees, and equitable relief. Government and church plans generally retain California bad faith remedies against the insurer.
  • For DMHC-regulated health plans, an Independent Medical Review application ordinarily must be filed within six months of the plan's written response to your grievance, and the DMHC can accept later applications for good cause.
  • Punitive damages in a California bad faith case require clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice (Civil Code § 3294).

What Does Insurance Bad Faith Mean Under California Law?

Under California law, insurance bad faith is an insurer's unreasonable failure to honor its own policyholder's claim, and it's treated as a tort rather than only a broken contract. Under Gruenberg v. Aetna Ins. Co. (1973) 9 Cal.3d 566, an insurer that unreasonably withholds policy benefits from its insured can be liable in tort for breaching the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. The main limit is scope: the rule governs first-party claims, and employer plans governed by ERISA follow a federal remedies scheme instead.

The implied covenant and first-party claims

The implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing is a promise the law places inside every insurance contract, whether or not the policy mentions it. In plain terms, the insurer can't act in a way that unfairly deprives you of the benefits you paid for. The California Supreme Court explained in Gruenberg that this duty is imposed by law, not only by the policy's wording.

A first-party claim is a claim you make under your own policy for benefits owed to you or your beneficiaries. Think of a health plan paying for surgery, a disability insurer paying monthly benefits, or a life insurer paying a death benefit to a surviving spouse.

Third-party bad faith is a separate category. It concerns how an insurer defends or settles a lawsuit filed against its insured, and it carries different elements. This page focuses on first-party disputes, which is where our practice concentrates.

What separates bad faith from an honest disagreement

Not every denial is bad faith. An insurer may lawfully deny a claim that truly falls outside the policy. The real question is whether the insurer earned the decision it made.

Two California Supreme Court decisions frame that question. In Egan v. Mutual of Omaha (1979) 24 Cal.3d 809, the court held that an insurer may not deny a claim without thoroughly investigating its basis. There, the insurer declined its insured's offer of a medical examination before denying disability benefits. The court affirmed the compensatory damages and reversed the punitive award, a detail that often gets lost when the case is summarized.

The genuine dispute doctrine is an insurer's defense that a reasonable disagreement over coverage or claim value can't amount to bad faith. In Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co. (2007) 42 Cal.4th 713, the court held that this defense protects only positions grounded in a reasonable, good-faith investigation. A jury may find bad faith where an insurer reached its medical conclusion without a fair investigation and disregarded the treating physician's evidence. Our guide to the elements of a bad faith insurance claim walks through what a policyholder must show.

Where Insurance Code § 790.03 fits

Cal. Ins. Code § 790.03 lists unfair claims settlement practices in subdivision (h), including misrepresenting policy provisions and failing to explain why a claim was denied. But the statute creates no private right of action. Under Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund Ins. Cos. (1988) 46 Cal.3d 287, enforcement rests with the Insurance Commissioner, and policyholders sue through common-law bad faith instead.

That doesn't make § 790.03 irrelevant. Its standards remain evidence of what reasonable claims handling looks like, so we compare a claim file against them. Our page on Insurance Code 790.03 and bad faith covers the full list. And because a vague denial letter is one of the most frequent problems we review, we've also written about failing to explain a denial.

Bad faith isn't limited to flat refusals, either. Unreasonable delays and underpayments can raise the same questions, which we discuss in our article on delays in insurance payments as potential bad faith.

What's at Stake When a California Insurer Refuses to Pay?

In California, a denied claim usually causes financial harm long before any lawsuit, and several review deadlines start running whether or not you've hired a lawyer. A Medi-Cal managed-care member must first appeal to the plan within 60 days of the Notice of Action, and a DMHC Independent Medical Review application is ordinarily due within six months of the plan's written grievance response. Each path has exceptions, such as deemed exhaustion for Medi-Cal and good cause for late IMR applications, but neither should be counted on.

The bills don't pause for the appeal

A denial rarely arrives at a convenient moment. A patient whose surgery was denied may pay out of pocket or postpone care. A disability claimant's monthly check stops while rent and a mortgage keep coming due. A family waits on a life insurance death benefit after a funeral. A long-term care policyholder's facility charges keep growing.

Consider a hypothetical. A Pasadena teacher's disability benefits stop after an insurer's paper review concludes she can return to work, even though her treating neurologist says otherwise. She drains savings, falls behind on payments, and loses sleep over it. Under Gruenberg, harm like that can be part of a tort claim, not just the unpaid monthly amount. Documenting the financial and personal fallout as it happens is what later allows those losses to be measured.

Review windows close on their own schedule

Several clocks may apply at once, depending on how you're covered:

  • Medi-Cal aid paid pending: must be requested within 10 days of the notice, or before the effective date of the action.
  • Medi-Cal plan appeal: within 60 days of the plan's Notice of Action. The state fair hearing window (120 days) runs from the plan's Notice of Appeal Resolution, not from the original denial.
  • ERISA internal appeal: group health and disability plans must allow at least 180 days after you receive the denial; other ERISA plans, such as life insurance, must allow at least 60 days.
  • DMHC Independent Medical Review: ordinarily within six months of the plan's written response to your grievance, with good-cause exceptions.
  • Lawsuit deadlines: generally two years for bad faith tort claims and four years on the written policy, subject to policy clauses and tolling.

The record you build now shapes what a court sees later

What goes into the claim file during the appeal often becomes the evidence that decides the case. In an ERISA dispute, the strategy centers on the federal claims-review record. In a California bad faith case, Wilson makes the treating physician's evidence, and whether the insurer engaged with it, a central issue.

Some insurers respond to a large claim by reviewing the original application for misstatements. Rescission, meaning cancellation of the policy back to its start date, raises its own rules, which we cover in our article on bad faith rescission of health insurance.

Not sure which of these clocks applies to you? Bring the denial letter and your policy or plan booklet to a free case review. We'll go through which deadlines may already be running and what each one means for your options.

Statute of Limitations: How Long Do You Have to Sue an Insurer in California?

California courts generally apply the two-year period of Code Civ. Proc. § 339(1) to bad faith tort claims, following Love v. Fire Ins. Exchange (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 1136. Claims for breach of the written policy generally fall under the four-year period of Code Civ. Proc. § 337(a), and both periods commonly run from the insurer's unequivocal denial. Policy suit-limitation clauses, accrual rules, and tolling can shorten or shift either period, so treat these as general rules, not a calculation for your claim.

An unequivocal denial is a clear, final refusal to pay, as opposed to a request for more records or a decision the insurer says is still under review. Pinning down that date is often the first thing an attorney does with a new file.

Statute of Limitations: How Long Do You Have to Sue an Insurer in California?
Claim or review typeGeneral time limitAuthorityWhat can change it
Bad faith tort (breach of implied covenant)2 years, commonly from the unequivocal denialCode Civ. Proc. § 339(1); Love v. Fire Ins. Exchange (1990)Accrual, tolling, and policy suit-limitation clauses
Breach of the written insurance policy4 years, commonly from the unequivocal denialCode Civ. Proc. § 337(a)Contractual limitation provisions in the policy
Disability and CDI-regulated health policiesNo suit before 60 days after written proof of loss, nor after 3 years from when proof of loss is requiredIns. Code § 10350.11The policy's own wording, which in one published case gave 3 years for a tort claim
DMHC Independent Medical Review applicationOrdinarily 6 months from the plan's written grievance responseHealth & Safety Code § 1374.30DMHC may accept a later application for good cause
Court review of a Medi-Cal fair hearing decision1 year after notice of the final decisionWelf. & Inst. Code § 10962; petition under Code Civ. Proc. § 1094.5This petition is the exclusive way to challenge the hearing decision

Policy clauses that move the deadline

Many policies contain a "legal actions" or "suit against us" clause. Read it closely. Under Ins. Code § 10350.11, a disability policy (which in California includes health insurance regulated by the Department of Insurance) must say no action may be brought before 60 days after written proof of loss, nor after three years from when proof of loss is required.

That clause can cut both ways. In Blue Shield of Cal. Life & Health Ins. Co. v. Superior Court (Kawakita), a published 2011 Court of Appeal decision, the insurer's own policy language gave the insured three years to sue for tortious breach of the implied covenant. Other policies may be written differently. Our article on the statute of limitations for a bad faith claim goes into accrual and tolling in more depth.

Three steps to take this week

If you've received a denial, these three steps protect your options without committing you to anything:

  1. Record the dates. Write down when you received each denial, partial payment, or request for information. Keep envelopes, emails, and portal screenshots.
  2. Ask for the documents in writing. Request complete copies of your policy, Evidence of Coverage, or plan document, and any reports the insurer relied on.
  3. Identify how you're covered. Coverage through a private employer, a government or church employer, an individual purchase, or Medi-Cal determines which appeal clock and which remedies apply.

But there's a catch. Filing an internal appeal doesn't automatically pause the lawsuit deadline in every situation, so the safest course is prompt legal review.

The Claim-File Accountability Framework: How We Build a California Bad Faith Case

Gianelli & Morris, led by partner Robert S. Gianelli, evaluates first-party bad faith claims through a six-step sequence built around one question: did the insurer actually earn the decision it made? The steps protect the deadline, rebuild the claims record, test the insurer's justification, value the harm, and choose the path most likely to hold the insurer accountable. The framework applies to first-party health, life, disability, long-term care, and commercial claims; third-party disputes over an insurer's defense of a lawsuit involve different elements and fall outside it.

Step 1: Protect the deadline and identify the governing law

We start with the calendar and the policy. California courts generally apply a two-year period to bad faith tort claims and a four-year period to claims on the written policy, and the policy may carry its own suit-limitation clause. The threshold question is whether coverage comes through an ERISA employer plan, because ERISA preemption reshapes both the available claims and the remedies.

A discretionary clause is policy language reserving to the insurer the authority to interpret the policy and decide eligibility. Under Cal. Ins. Code § 10110.6, a discretionary clause in a policy providing or funding life or disability insurance for a California resident is void, which can matter to how a denial is reviewed.

  • Documents: the complete policy or plan document, denial and final-decision letters, and employer benefits enrollment materials.
  • Decision point: If ERISA governs, the strategy moves to the federal claims-review record and benefits remedies. If the policy is individual or otherwise outside ERISA, state tort remedies stay in play. A near deadline moves filing ahead of further investigation.

Step 2: Rebuild what the insurer actually did

Next, we reconstruct the claim from the insurer's side. Under Egan, an insurer may not deny a claim without thoroughly investigating its basis. California's Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 10, § 2695.7) require a thorough, fair, and objective investigation, prohibit demands for information not reasonably required, and require written first-party denials stating every basis with its factual and legal grounds.

We compare the claim file against those duties and against the response timelines covered later on this page. Section 790.03(h) practices, such as misrepresenting policy provisions, serve as a benchmark only.

  • Documents: the claim file and adjuster notes, all correspondence with the insurer, and proof-of-claim submissions with dates.
  • Decision point: Missed timelines, unexplained denials, ignored offers of examination, or requests for unneeded information strengthen an unreasonable-conduct theory. A file showing a careful process shifts the focus to whether the insurer's conclusion itself was reasonable.

Step 3: Test whether the "genuine dispute" is genuine

Insurers often argue that a reasonable disagreement defeats bad faith. Wilson holds that the defense protects only positions grounded in a reasonable, good-faith investigation. So we put the insurer's reviewers and medical-necessity criteria side by side with the treating providers' records.

That emphasis reflects the firm's experience with medical-necessity criteria and its health-denial matters. In one such matter, Anthem Blue Cross rejected treatment a specialist prescribed for a painful, debilitating disease as not medically necessary, and we obtained a favorable result for our client. Our article on how to prove insurance bad faith covers the kinds of evidence that matter at this stage.

  • Documents: treating physician records and letters, the insurer's peer-review or utilization reports, and the clinical guidelines cited in the denial.
  • Decision point: If the insurer's reviewers never engaged with the treating evidence, the defense weakens and tort claims gain strength. If the record shows a real clinical disagreement, the case may center on contract benefits and policy interpretation.

Step 4: Measure the full harm, not just the unpaid claim

Under Gruenberg, tort recovery can reach beyond policy benefits to consequential losses, including emotional distress. Under Brandt v. Superior Court (1985) 37 Cal.3d 813, attorney fees reasonably incurred to recover withheld benefits are recoverable as damages, while fees for pursuing the bad faith claim itself are not. Punitive damages under Civil Code § 3294 require clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice.

  • Documents: out-of-pocket costs and financial records, medical or personal records showing impact, and internal insurer guidelines produced in discovery.
  • Decision point: Documented financial fallout and distress support tort damages. Evidence that the denial reflected deliberate policy rather than error supports a punitive claim. Under ERISA plans, the analysis narrows to benefits and federal remedies.

Step 5: Choose the path (individual case, arbitration, or class)

Some health plans route disputes to arbitration. This is an issue that can significantly affect how a health insurance bad faith dispute proceeds. Under Code Civ. Proc. § 1281.91, a party can challenge a proposed neutral arbitrator by serving notice of disqualification within 15 calendar days of the arbitrator's disclosure, and one court-appointed arbitrator may be disqualified without cause.

Under Zhang v. Superior Court (2013) 57 Cal.4th 364, an insured may also bring an Unfair Competition Law claim (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200) against its own insurer when the conduct is independently actionable. Where a denial rule affects many members, the firm's class action record, including Escalante v. Blue Shield and Gallimore v. Kaiser, informs whether a class approach can change the practice itself.

  • Documents: arbitration or dispute-resolution provisions, arbitrator disclosure statements, and evidence of similar denials to other members.
  • Decision point: A unique dispute points to an individual tort action. An enforceable arbitration clause shifts effort to the forum and the selection of the arbitrator. A uniform denial rule supports evaluating class or UCL relief.

Step 6: Build the case a jury can follow

Bad faith turns on what the insurer knew and why it acted. So the evidence has to be organized into a clear timeline of the insurer's choices, supported by depositions of the adjusters and reviewers who made them. This matters most for punitive damages, where the clear-and-convincing standard leaves little room for a muddled presentation.

Robert S. Gianelli has taken a health-coverage case to verdict. In LaRue v. Accountable Health Care, IPA, he obtained a $7,225,000 jury verdict against Health Net's contracted medical group for failing to provide a timely surgical referral.

  • Documents: deposition transcripts of adjusters and reviewers, and a chronology of claim-handling decisions.
  • Decision point: Strong internal documents and witness testimony support pressing toward trial and punitive damages. Gaps in proof favor focusing on benefits and compensatory damages, or resolving the case.

Want to see how these six steps apply to your own denial? Call Gianelli & Morris at 213-489-1600. Bring the denial letter and whatever policy documents you have, and we'll start with Step 1: which law governs and which deadline is closest.

How Long Does a California Insurer Have to Decide Your Claim?

California sets different decision deadlines depending on the type of insurance. For health insurance policies regulated by the California Department of Insurance, Insurance Code § 10123.13 requires the insurer to pay a claim, or notify you in writing that it's contested or denied with the specific reasons, within 30 calendar days of receiving it. The broader 40-day accept-or-deny rule of the Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations applies to life, long-term care, property, and other non-health first-party claims, not to those health policies.

A recent change is easy to miss. AB 3275 replaced the former "30 working days" in § 10123.13 with 30 calendar days, effective January 1, 2026. Older articles online still quote the prior rule.

How Long Does a California Insurer Have to Decide Your Claim?
Claim typeDecision deadlineAuthorityKey qualification
CDI-regulated health insurance claim30 calendar days from receiptIns. Code § 10123.13A contest or denial must be in writing with the specific reasons
Disability income claim30 calendar days after receiving all needed informationIns. Code § 10111.2Without written notice of what's still needed, 10% interest runs from day 31
Life, long-term care, property, and other first-party claims40 calendar days after proof of claim to accept or denyCal. Code Regs., tit. 10, § 2695.7(b)Insurer must give written notice if it needs more time
DMHC-regulated health plan grievance30 days; 72 hours if expeditedKnox-Keene Act (Health & Safety Code § 1340 et seq.)Applies to state-regulated (DMHC) plans
ERISA group health plan, first decisionUrgent 72 hours; pre-service 15 days; post-service 30 days29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(f)(2)Pre- and post-service periods may each be extended once by up to 15 days
ERISA group health plan, decision on appealUrgent 72 hours; pre-service 30 days; post-service 60 days29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(i)(2)Insured employer plans must also meet California deadlines

Why missed deadlines matter

A blown deadline doesn't automatically prove bad faith. But under the framework's Step 2, missed timelines and unexplained denials strengthen an unreasonable-conduct theory, because they show the insurer didn't follow the rules that govern its own process. A file full of unanswered letters reads very differently to a jury than a file showing timely, reasoned decisions.

Insured employer plans follow two sets of rules

The federal ERISA claims regulation sets minimum procedures for every ERISA plan, insured or self-funded. Its paragraph (k) keeps state insurance law in force unless it prevents applying the federal rule. As a result, an insured employer plan must meet both the federal schedule and California's deadlines. Only self-funded plans follow the federal schedule alone.

Here's what that means for you. If your employer buys coverage from Blue Shield, Anthem, or another carrier, the insurer can't hide behind the longer of two deadlines. Both apply.

What Damages Can You Recover in a California Bad Faith Lawsuit?

In a California bad faith case outside ERISA, recoverable damages can include the unpaid policy benefits, consequential losses such as emotional distress (Gruenberg), Brandt fees for recovering the withheld benefits, and punitive damages on clear and convincing proof. The major exception is a private-employer plan governed by ERISA, where recovery is generally limited to the benefit plus potential interest, attorney fees under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(g), and appropriate equitable relief under § 1132(a)(3). Government and church plans are exempt from ERISA and generally retain California bad faith remedies against the insurer.

Benefits and consequential losses

The starting point is the money the policy promised. From there, tort damages can reach losses caused by the withholding: medical debt, lost savings, damaged credit, and the emotional distress of fighting an insurer while sick or grieving. These categories need proof, which is why we ask clients to keep records from the start. Our article on the types of damages for insurance bad faith breaks down each category.

Brandt fees

Brandt fees are attorney fees a policyholder reasonably incurs to force payment of benefits the insurer tortiously withheld. The California Supreme Court allowed them as damages in Brandt v. Superior Court (1985) 37 Cal.3d 813, a disability benefits case. The limit is precise: fees spent pursuing the bad faith claim itself aren't recoverable under Brandt.

Punitive damages

Civil Code § 3294 permits punitive damages in a tort action only on clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice. That's a higher standard than the usual civil burden. Evidence that a denial reflected a deliberate company rule, rather than one adjuster's mistake, is the kind of proof that can support it.

Punitive damages
Damage categoryIndividual or non-ERISA policyPrivate-employer ERISA planGovernment or church plan
Unpaid policy benefitsRecoverableRecoverable under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(1)(B)Generally recoverable
Emotional distress and consequential lossesRecoverable in tort (Gruenberg)Not availableGenerally retained under California law
Attorney feesBrandt fees for recovering withheld benefits onlyIn the court's discretion under § 1132(g)Brandt fees generally available
Punitive damagesAvailable on clear and convincing evidence (Civ. Code § 3294)Not availableGenerally retained, subject to § 3294's standard
Interest and equitable reliefDepends on the claim and policyPotential interest; equitable relief under § 1132(a)(3)Depends on the claim and policy

Plan structure and the identity of the defendant can change these answers. A government employee whose health coverage comes from an insurer generally keeps state remedies against that insurer, but a self-insured public plan may raise different questions.

Does ERISA Change Your Bad Faith Case If Coverage Comes Through Work?

Yes. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1144, ERISA supersedes state laws that relate to employee benefit plans, so a private-employer plan generally loses California's bad faith tort, punitive damages, and emotional-distress damages. The insurance savings clause keeps some state insurance regulation in force, and government and church plans fall outside ERISA altogether.

ERISA preemption is the rule that federal benefits law displaces state law claims tied to an employer plan. In practice, it changes what you can recover more than whether you can challenge the denial. Our comparison of ERISA claims and bad faith insurance cases goes deeper.

Insured plans versus self-funded plans

This distinction matters more than most employees realize. An insured employer plan that is a Knox-Keene health care service plan, which includes every Kaiser HMO and other HMO or managed-care coverage offered through a private employer, is regulated by the DMHC. Its members keep Knox-Keene grievance rights and DMHC Independent Medical Review, even though ERISA governs lawsuit remedies.

Self-funded employer plans, where the employer pays claims from its own funds and often hires an insurer only to administer them, fall outside the DMHC. Your plan document or summary plan description usually says which type you have. ERISA changes the remedies available in a lawsuit; it doesn't strip insured-plan members of the DMHC review path.

Government and church plans

Teachers, police officers, firefighters, other public employees, and many religious workers have coverage through plans that ERISA exempts. Those policyholders generally retain California bad faith remedies against the insurer. We've written about how public employee insurance denials are different for readers in that position.

Where ERISA benefit claims are heard

A suit to recover benefits under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(1)(B) can be filed in state or federal court, because § 1132(e)(1) gives them concurrent jurisdiction over that claim. Federal claims procedures under 29 U.S.C. § 1133 also require written notice of the specific reasons for a denial and a reasonable opportunity for a full and fair review. The U.S. Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration oversees those rules.

For life and disability coverage, recall Ins. Code § 10110.6. A discretionary clause in a policy providing or funding life or disability insurance for a California resident is void, even when the policy sits inside an employer plan.

Health Insurance, HMO, and Medi-Cal Denials: Which Review Path Comes First?

In California, the review path for a health denial depends on who regulates your coverage. HMO and other managed-care plans answer to the California Department of Managed Health Care under the Knox-Keene Act (Health & Safety Code § 1340 et seq.), while many PPO-style health insurance policies answer to the California Department of Insurance. Medi-Cal managed-care members have their own appeal and state fair hearing sequence, and the order of steps can matter.

DMHC plans and Knox-Keene grievances

For a DMHC-regulated plan, the usual first step is a grievance with the plan. The plan must resolve it within 30 days, or within 72 hours when the matter is urgent. Our article on the health insurance grievance system in California explains what plans must provide.

Your Evidence of Coverage is the document that spells out what a health plan covers, what it excludes, and how it defines terms like medical necessity. For most care, the EOC supplies the controlling definition. Mental health and substance use disorder care is the exception: Health & Safety Code § 1374.72(a)(3) defines medically necessary treatment for those conditions in the statute itself. Our page on what an Evidence of Coverage is shows where to find the key sections.

Independent Medical Review

Independent Medical Review (IMR) is a DMHC process in which outside physicians decide whether a denied service is medically necessary, experimental, or investigational. Under Health & Safety Code § 1374.30, a medical-necessity IMR generally requires that you first file a grievance with the plan (with exceptions when the plan doesn't resolve it in time or the case is urgent). The application ordinarily must be filed within six months of the plan's written response, and the DMHC can accept later applications for good cause.

When the DMHC adopts an IMR decision finding a service medically necessary, the plan must promptly implement it, reimbursing services already rendered or authorizing services not yet rendered within five working days (Health & Safety Code § 1374.34(a)). What IMR doesn't do is compensate pain, worsening health, or other harm from the delay. That's a bad faith and tort question. Readers with individual or other non-ERISA coverage can also review our article on fighting a medical necessity denial with a non-ERISA policy.

CDI-regulated health insurance policies

If your health coverage is an insurance policy regulated by the Department of Insurance rather than a DMHC plan, complaints and review requests go through the Department of Insurance consumer help process. The 30-calendar-day claim deadline of § 10123.13 applies to these policies.

Medi-Cal managed-care appeals

Medi-Cal follows a set order. A Medi-Cal managed-care member must first appeal to the plan within 60 days of the Notice of Action; only after the plan upholds the denial does the 120-day state fair hearing window open, measured from the plan's Notice of Appeal Resolution. The plan decides the appeal within 30 days, or 72 hours when expedited.

Going straight to a hearing is allowed only through deemed exhaustion: when the plan never sent a proper notice, didn't decide the appeal on time, or sent a defective resolution notice. County eligibility actions are different and go directly to a fair hearing on a 90-day clock. To keep benefits in place during the dispute, aid paid pending must be requested within 10 days of the notice or before its effective date.

Medi-Cal members in a Knox-Keene plan aren't excluded from IMR, but reviews for Medi-Cal enrollees follow Medi-Cal program rules, so confirm the sequencing with the fair hearing before filing. For Blue Shield Promise members and members of other Los Angeles County Medi-Cal plans alike, the plan named on your notice is where the appeal starts. Fee arrangements for Medi-Cal administrative appeals differ from bad faith cases, and we explain them at the free consultation.

Life, Disability, Long-Term Care, and Annuity Disputes in California

California applies the same core bad faith principles to life, disability, long-term care, and annuity products, but each line of coverage has its own pressure points. For life and long-term care claims, the Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations generally give the insurer 40 calendar days after proof of claim to accept or deny, while disability income claims follow Ins. Code § 10111.2's 30-day rule. Coverage through a private employer brings ERISA into play for any of these products.

Life insurance denials

Life insurance disputes often turn on the application. Insurers sometimes review the original answers after a death and argue misrepresentation within the policy's contestability period. Our article on the life insurance contestability period in California explains how that window works.

If the life policy is part of a private-employer plan, ERISA applies. Those plans must allow at least 60 days to file an internal appeal, a shorter floor than the 180 days required for group health and disability plans.

Long-term disability

Egan itself was a disability case, and its rule still frames these disputes: no denial without a thorough investigation. Common flashpoints include paper reviews that never examine the claimant, surveillance taken out of context, and "own occupation" versus "any occupation" definitions. Under § 10110.6, a discretionary clause in a disability policy for a California resident is void. Under § 10111.2, a disability income insurer that neither pays within 30 calendar days after receiving everything it needs nor sends a written list of what's missing owes 10% interest from day 31.

Long-term care insurance

Long-term care policies pay when the insured can't manage daily activities or has cognitive impairment. Insurance Code § 10232.8 sets the triggers. For policies not intended to be federally tax-qualified that provide home care benefits, eligibility must be at least as permissive as impairment in two of seven activities of daily living or impairment of cognitive ability. Tax-qualified contracts use two of six activities of daily living or cognitive impairment.

The same section requires certification by a licensed health care practitioner independent of the insurer, limits any certification requirement to no longer than 90 days, and in limited circumstances provides for a second assessment. Denials that ignore an independent certification deserve close review.

Annuities and broker issues

Annuity disputes usually involve sales practices rather than claim denials. Stephens v. American Equity was a class action over deceptive annuity sales practices affecting seniors. Agent-versus-broker duties are a question that comes up when a policyholder learns too late that coverage was never placed as promised. Commercial policyholders face many of the same investigation and timing rules, with the 40-day accept-or-deny regulation generally applying to non-health first-party commercial claims.

Proven Results: Verified Gianelli & Morris Cases Against California Insurers

Gianelli & Morris has recovered hundreds of millions of dollars for policyholders since opening in 1979, through individual trials and class actions that forced changes in how insurers handle claims. The results below come from the firm's published case record; each case turned on its own facts, and none predicts the outcome of another. Our attorneys hold an AV Preeminent® rating, and Robert S. Gianelli is a two-time Consumer Attorney of the Year Finalist.

Proven Results: Verified Gianelli & Morris Cases Against California Insurers
CaseCoverage or productIssueVerified result
LaRue v. Accountable Health Care, IPAHealth Net ACA plan member; claim against Health Net's contracted medical groupFailure to provide a timely surgical referral$7,225,000 jury verdict
Gallimore v. KaiserKaiser health planCompliance with California reconstructive surgery lawClass action; estimated benefits to members exceeding $150 million
Stephens v. American EquityAnnuities sold to seniorsDeceptive annuity sales$47 million settlement for a class of 7,700 seniors
Escalante v. Blue Shield of CaliforniaBlue Shield health coverageArtificial lumbar disc replacement denied as "investigational"Part of the firm's work reshaping insurer coverage standards for this procedure
Arce v. Kaiser Foundation Health PlanKaiser health planDenial of autism treatmentClass action that was the basis of Robert Gianelli's CLAY Award
Trujillo v. United HealthcareUnited Healthcare coverageDenial of prosthetic limbsClass action over prosthetic-limb coverage for amputees
Anthem Blue Cross memberAnthem Blue Cross health coverageSpecialist-prescribed treatment denied as not medically necessaryDenial overcome; favorable result for the client

The Gallimore figure is the estimated value of benefits to Kaiser members, not money paid to the firm or its clients. The firm's health-denial litigation includes many matters beyond those listed above.

When a class action makes sense

A class action fits when one denial rule affects many members the same way. Escalante is the clearest example on this list: the dispute wasn't about one patient's chart but about a blanket "investigational" label, and the settlement changed the practice. Class certification and abstention defenses are two hurdles that decide whether a class case can proceed.

Under Zhang, the Unfair Competition Law can add a path for injunctive relief when the insurer's conduct is independently actionable. Not every policyholder needs a class case, though. Most disputes are individual, and the decision rests on whether the evidence shows a uniform rule or a one-off judgment. You can read more about Robert S. Gianelli's background on his attorney profile.

Litigating Bad Faith Cases in Los Angeles: Courts, Removal, and Arbitration

In Los Angeles County, an individual insurance bad faith lawsuit is ordinarily filed in the Superior Court as an unlimited civil case. An individual health or disability bad faith case is ordinarily not a "complex" case, which is a separate designation under California Rules of Court, rule 3.400. Some cases end up in federal court or arbitration instead, depending on the insurer, the plan, and the contract.

Los Angeles County Superior Court

An unlimited civil case in California is a civil lawsuit seeking more than the limited-civil threshold, which brings full discovery and the right to a jury. Most bad faith cases belong in this category because the damages claimed exceed that threshold.

The Superior Court has locations across the county, and assignments can change. Always check your case notice and the department assigned to your case rather than assuming where hearings will happen. The California Courts website also offers general self-help information on civil procedure.

Federal court and removal

An insurer sued in state court sometimes moves the case to federal court. For a California policyholder, an insurer can remove on diversity grounds only if it is both incorporated and headquartered outside California, and more than $75,000 must be in controversy under the federal diversity statute. Cases in the downtown federal courts proceed in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, which also hears many ERISA benefit claims.

Arbitration clauses in health plans

Some health plans require binding arbitration. That doesn't end a claim, but it changes the forum and makes arbitrator selection important. The 15-day window under Code Civ. Proc. § 1281.91 to disqualify a proposed neutral arbitrator is short, so the arbitrator's disclosure needs prompt review.

Oversight is also changing. Under AB 1770 (Lindalee's Law), starting January 1, 2027, the Attorney General will oversee health care service plans whose contracts require binding arbitration, including the authority to require reports, to ensure compliance with California's arbitration-disclosure and arbitration-administration rules. The law doesn't eliminate arbitration, and it doesn't narrow the DMHC's authority.

The Contingency Fee Model: What Does a Bad Faith Lawyer in Los Angeles Cost?

At Gianelli & Morris, insurance bad faith cases are handled on contingency: our fees come as a percentage of any award we recover, so you pay no attorney fee unless we recover. The first conversation is a free consultation to discuss your legal options, and we explain how case expenses are handled before you decide anything. Fee arrangements for other matters, such as Medi-Cal administrative appeals, are discussed separately at that consultation.

What you can bring to the consultation

You don't need a complete file to call. But these documents make the first conversation far more useful:

  • Every denial, partial payment, or rescission letter, with the dates you received them
  • Your policy, Evidence of Coverage, or summary plan description
  • Correspondence with the insurer, including emails and portal messages
  • Letters or records from your treating physicians
  • Employer benefits enrollment materials, if coverage comes through work
  • Receipts, bills, and records of money you've spent because the claim wasn't paid

What the first conversation covers

We'll listen to what happened, look at what you have, and work through the questions from Step 1 of our framework: which law governs your coverage, which deadline is closest, and whether ERISA limits the remedies. From there, we'll explain the options as we see them, including internal appeals, regulatory review, and litigation. You decide whether to move forward.

We won't tell you what your case is worth on the first call. That answer depends on evidence most clients don't have yet, especially the insurer's claim file. What we can tell you is what to preserve, what to request, and which dates to protect. Readers who want to understand the full process first can start with our overview of how an insurance bad faith claim works in California.

The information on this page is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Please consult a qualified attorney about your specific situation.

If your insurer has denied, delayed, or underpaid a claim, the two-year period that commonly applies to bad faith tort claims, and the six-month IMR window for DMHC plans, may already be running. Gianelli & Morris has represented California policyholders against insurers since 1979, and we offer a free consultation to discuss your legal options from our Los Angeles office. Call 213-489-1600 to schedule yours, and bring the denial letter with you.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to hire a California insurance bad faith lawyer?

Gianelli & Morris takes insurance bad faith cases on a contingency fee basis, which means our fees are taken as a percentage of any award we recover. The first meeting is a free consultation, where we also explain how case expenses are handled. Other matter types, such as Medi-Cal administrative appeals, may involve different arrangements, which we explain at that consultation. To schedule, call 213-489-1600.

How long do I have to file a bad faith lawsuit in California?

California courts generally apply a two-year period under Code Civ. Proc. § 339(1) to bad faith tort claims and a four-year period under § 337(a) to claims on the written policy. Both commonly run from the insurer's unequivocal denial. Your policy's suit-limitation clause, accrual rules, and tolling can shorten or shift those dates, and ERISA plans follow their own terms, so prompt attorney review is the safest course.

What is my bad faith case worth?

No honest answer is possible without the evidence, especially the insurer's claim file. Value depends on the unpaid benefits, documented consequential losses such as emotional distress, Brandt fees for recovering withheld benefits, and whether clear and convincing evidence supports punitive damages under Civil Code § 3294. If your plan is a private-employer ERISA plan, recovery is generally limited to benefits plus potential interest, fees, and equitable relief.

Should I accept the insurer's first offer or a partial payment?

Read any settlement paperwork carefully before signing, because some offers come with a release that ends your right to pursue further claims. An offer by itself doesn't prove the insurer acted in bad faith, and it doesn't prove the amount is fair either. Having an attorney review the release language and the policy terms before you sign protects your options.

What if I made a mistake on my application or claim form?

An insurer may raise application errors as a reason to deny or rescind coverage, especially after a large claim. Under California law, the insurer still has a duty to investigate fairly before denying, as Egan v. Mutual of Omaha held. Whether a misstatement justifies the insurer's action depends on the policy, the facts, and the insurer's process, so the claim file matters.

How long does a bad faith case take?

Timing depends on factors such as whether internal appeals or an IMR must come first, whether the insurer removes the case to federal court, whether an arbitration clause applies, and how much discovery the insurer's internal documents require. ERISA cases follow a different track centered on the claims-review record. We'll talk through the factors that apply to your situation rather than guess at a number.

Do I need a lawyer, or can I appeal on my own?

You can file internal appeals, DMHC grievances, and IMR applications on your own, and many people do. A lawyer can strengthen the record you build during that appeal, which can matter later, especially under ERISA. If the denial caused losses beyond the unpaid benefits, a bad faith claim requires litigation, and representation becomes far more important.

What if my insurer says my policy was cancelled or rescinded?

Rescission cancels a policy back to its start date, and California law places limits on when health insurers can do that. Insurers sometimes rescind after reviewing an application in response to an expensive claim. Bring the rescission letter and your original application to a lawyer quickly, because limitation periods and appeal deadlines can run from that notice.

Will my bad faith case go to trial?

Most civil cases resolve before trial, but some don't, and an insurer's settlement decisions often depend on how ready the policyholder is to try the case. Robert S. Gianelli and co-counsel obtained a $7,225,000 jury verdict in LaRue v. Accountable Health Care, IPA. We prepare cases with trial in mind, which means organizing the evidence into a timeline of the insurer's decisions from the start.

How do I pay for treatment while my case is pending?

Options depend on your coverage. DMHC plan members can request an expedited grievance (72 hours) and, when eligible, an IMR; if the DMHC finds the service medically necessary, the plan must authorize or reimburse it within five working days. Medi-Cal members can request aid paid pending within 10 days of the notice to keep benefits in place during an appeal.

Can I sue my insurer for violating Insurance Code § 790.03?

No. Under Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund (1988), § 790.03 creates no private right of action, and the Insurance Commissioner enforces it. You can still sue for common-law bad faith, and the statute's standards serve as evidence of what reasonable claims handling requires. You may also report the conduct to the Department of Insurance.

My health plan says I agreed to arbitration. Can I still bring a claim?

An arbitration clause changes where the claim is heard, not whether you have one. California law lets you challenge a proposed neutral arbitrator by serving notice within 15 calendar days of the arbitrator's disclosure under Code Civ. Proc. § 1281.91. Starting January 1, 2027, the Attorney General will also oversee health plans that require binding arbitration, though that law doesn't eliminate arbitration.