Skip to main content
Gianelli & Morris attorneys Alex Gianelli, Joshua S. Davis, Robert S. Gianelli and Loring Rose

Protecting insuredrights since 1979

We fight insurance companies that refuse to pay.

Insurance companies don’t always play fair. Our insurance claim attorneys help policyholders fight denied, delayed, or underpaid insurance claims and recover what they’re owed.

Free Consultation

California Principal Disability Denial Lawyer

Free Consultation

If Principal denied or cut off your long-term disability benefits, the first question under California law is what kind of coverage you hold. Individual and other non-ERISA disability policies are governed by California insurance law, and Cal. Ins. Code § 10110.6 voids clauses giving the insurer discretionary authority over a California resident's claim. Private employer plans usually fall under federal ERISA instead.

Gianelli & Morris has spent 40+ years serving California policyholders. Robert S. Gianelli, a partner at the firm, has represented policyholders in insurance disputes involving health, life, disability, and property coverage. This page explains what happens after a Principal Financial disability claim is denied. It covers how to tell whether California law applies, what your policy promised, how the insurer's investigation is judged, and which deadlines matter. It also explains why an individual disability income policy can lead to a very different case than an employer plan.

Robert Gianelli is a Los Angeles insurance bad faith lawyer who takes on insurers that deny or end the benefits California policyholders paid for. He received the California Lawyer Attorney of the Year (CLAY) Award and has represented policyholders in class actions including Arce v. Kaiser, over autism treatment coverage. At Gianelli & Morris, we take insurance bad faith cases on a contingency fee basis, which means our fees are taken as a percentage of any award we recover. Call 213-489-1600 for a Free Consultation to Discuss Your Legal Options.

Key Takeaways

  • Gianelli & Morris evaluates individual and other qualifying non-ERISA disability disputes. We do not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases.
  • Under California law, a policy clause reserving discretionary authority to the insurer in a disability policy covering a California resident is void (Cal. Ins. Code § 10110.6).
  • California courts generally apply a two-year period to bad faith claims and a four-year period to claims on the written policy, but a disability policy's own "Legal Actions" clause and the facts of accrual and tolling can shorten or shift those dates.
  • Insurance Code § 790.03 creates no private right to sue. It sets claims-handling standards the Insurance Commissioner enforces, and the lawsuit itself is a common-law bad faith claim.
  • Punitive damages in a bad faith case require clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice. ERISA plans generally do not allow punitive or emotional-distress damages at all.

Los Angeles Policyholders: Your Policy Type Decides the Path

Under California law, the type of Principal disability coverage you hold controls the rules, remedies, deadlines, and whether our firm can take your case. Individual disability income policies, and plans sponsored by government or church employers, generally remain subject to California insurance law and bad faith remedies. Private-employer group plans generally fall under ERISA, which preempts state bad faith claims (29 U.S.C. § 1144; Pilot Life Ins. Co. v. Dedeaux (1987) 481 U.S. 41).

This is the first thing we sort out with every caller. It's also the reason this page doesn't read like a general disability guide. For an overview of how we approach these claims across insurers, see our long-term disability insurance claim denial page.

Individual disability income policies

An individual policy is one you applied for and bought yourself, often through an agent, with premiums you paid directly. These policies are contracts governed by the California Insurance Code. When the insurer breaks the contract, you can sue for the benefits owed. When it also handles the claim unreasonably, California's bad faith law may add tort damages on top of the contract benefits.

Many physicians, dentists, attorneys, and business owners carry individual coverage precisely because it follows them from job to job. That portability is a reason these policies tend to stay outside ERISA.

Private employer group plans and ERISA

ERISA, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, is the federal law governing most benefit plans that private employers offer their workers. It supersedes state laws that relate to those plans, except laws that regulate insurance. In Pilot Life, the U.S. Supreme Court held that state common-law bad faith claims are preempted for ERISA plans, although later savings-clause decisions narrowed parts of that reasoning.

Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases. If your Principal coverage is an ERISA plan, we'll explain why that matters and suggest you look for other counsel promptly. There's a real clock involved. Federal claims rules require ERISA disability plans to allow at least 180 days after you receive the denial to file an internal appeal (29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(h)(4)), and that appeal record often shapes what a court later sees. The U.S. Department of Labor (EBSA) publishes consumer information about ERISA claims and appeals.

Government and church plans

Not every plan that comes through a job is an ERISA plan. Plans sponsored by government employers (cities, counties, the State, school districts) and church plans are generally exempt from ERISA. People covered through those plans, such as teachers, police officers, firefighters, public employees, and religious workers, generally retain California bad faith remedies against the insurer. Plan structure and the identity of the defendant can still matter, so we review the documents before drawing conclusions. Our article on how public employee insurance denials are different explains more.

When coverage came through work but you paid for it

Some policies arrive through an employer but are paid entirely by the employee through payroll deduction. Whether that coverage is an ERISA plan can turn on facts like who paid the premiums and how involved the employer was in setting it up. That's why we ask for premium records early.

When coverage came through work but you paid for it
Coverage typeHow it usually arisesGoverning lawCalifornia bad faith claimDoes our firm evaluate it?
Individual disability income policyPurchased directly, often through an agentCalifornia Insurance CodeAvailable when the insurer's conduct supports itYes
Private-employer group LTD planOffered as a workplace benefitERISA (29 U.S.C. § 1144 preemption)Generally preemptedNo, we refer these out promptly
Government employer planCity, county, State, or school district employerGenerally exempt from ERISA; California law generally appliesGenerally retainedYes, for qualifying claims
Church planReligious employerGenerally exempt from ERISAGenerally retainedYes, for qualifying claims
Employee-paid coverage obtained through workPayroll deductionDepends on premium and employer-involvement factsDepends on whether ERISA appliesWe review documents to decide

Key insight: Section 10110.6 matters whichever path your case takes. Because it voids discretionary clauses in disability policies covering California residents, it can affect the standard a court applies when reviewing a denial. Courts may review a denial de novo where no valid discretionary grant exists. De novo review means the court decides the question fresh instead of deferring to the insurer's judgment.

What Does It Cost to Have Our Firm Review a Principal Denial?

For insurance bad faith cases, Gianelli & Morris works on contingency. At Gianelli & Morris, we take insurance bad faith cases on a contingency fee basis, which means our fees are taken as a percentage of any award we recover. If your situation involves a different kind of matter, we'll explain the fee arrangement during the free consultation rather than guess at it here.

A contingency arrangement means you aren't writing hourly checks while your income is already cut off. Ask us how litigation expenses are handled, too, because attorney fees and case costs are separate topics and you deserve a clear answer on both.

What happens at the first conversation

The first call is a free consultation to discuss your legal options. We'll ask how you got the coverage, when the claim was filed, what Principal said in its denial or termination letter, and where you are in any appeal. The goal is to answer the threshold question quickly: is this a California insurance case or an ERISA case?

If it's ERISA, we tell you, and you can move on to other counsel without losing time. If it's an individual or other non-ERISA policy, the conversation turns to the policy, the claim file, and the medical proof.

Documents worth gathering before you call

You don't need everything to start. But the following records make the first review far more useful:

  • The full policy, including riders, amendments, and the signed application
  • Every denial, termination, or reduction letter from Principal
  • Premium payment records showing who paid and how
  • Any plan document or summary plan description, if the coverage came through work
  • Your treating physicians' records and any written opinions about your limitations
  • Any independent medical exam, records review, functional capacity evaluation, or surveillance report the insurer shared
  • A description of your job duties as you actually performed them

If you're missing pieces, that's normal. Part of a lawyer's job is requesting the complete claim file.

What Is at Stake After a Principal Disability Claim Is Denied?

A denied or terminated disability claim usually means the replacement income you planned for is gone at the moment you can least replace it. Under California law, the deadlines that govern your options can start running from the insurer's unequivocal denial, and a disability policy's own "Legal Actions" clause can cut off a lawsuit even when a general statute of limitations has not expired. Waiting to see whether things improve can cost you more than time.

Income, savings, and medical care

Disability benefits often cover a mortgage, a car payment, and the gap left by a paycheck that's no longer coming. When they stop, people drain retirement accounts, borrow from family, or skip treatment they can't afford. Skipped treatment then becomes a problem in its own right, because gaps in care can show up later in the insurer's file as evidence you weren't really impaired.

The record you build right now

Whatever you send Principal after a denial becomes part of the record. Inconsistent descriptions of your symptoms, a casual comment on social media, or a doctor's note that doesn't address your actual job can all be cited later. That doesn't mean you should stop communicating. It means each submission deserves thought.

Termination after years of payments

Some of the most difficult calls come from people whose claim was approved, paid for a long stretch, and then cut off. A termination can follow a records review, an exam, surveillance, or a shift in the policy's definition of disability. When a long-paid claim ends without a change in your medical condition, the question becomes what the insurer relied on and whether that basis holds up.

A rescission threat

Occasionally an insurer doesn't simply deny the claim. It tries to cancel the entire policy, claiming an answer on the application was wrong. That threatens not only past benefits but all future coverage. We address rescission in its own section below.

If your Principal claim was denied or terminated and you're trying to figure out which deadline applies, call 213-489-1600. We'll start with the question of what law governs your policy, because every other answer depends on it.

How Do We Review a Denied Disability Claim? Promise, File, Proof

When a denied Principal claim comes to us, we work through a six-step review we call Promise, File, Proof. The sequence starts with which law governs the policy, then reads what the policy actually promised, rebuilds what the insurer did, and tests the denial against the medical and vocational evidence before choosing a path. It's a method for evaluating a claim, not a prediction of how any case ends.

Step 1: Confirm which law governs the policy

Everything flows from this answer. We look at the policy or certificate, the application and enrollment forms, premium payment records, and any plan document. If the coverage is part of an ERISA plan, we explain why and refer the person out promptly. If it's an individual or other non-ERISA policy, we continue with a California contract and bad faith analysis. Section 10110.6 is flagged here because its effect on discretionary clauses matters either way.

Step 2: Read exactly what the policy promised

Next comes the definition of disability Principal applied. Some policies cover inability to perform your own occupation. Others require inability to perform any occupation, and many switch from one to the other after a set period. We also review elimination periods, offsets, exclusions, and any rescission theory. That definition sets what the medical and vocational proof has to show.

Step 3: Rebuild what the insurer actually did

California's Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations require a thorough, fair, and objective investigation and a written first-party denial stating every basis for the decision with its factual and legal grounds. We reconstruct the timeline from denial letters, claim notes, exam and review reports, surveillance, and correspondence. Gaps or shifting reasons point toward a bad faith theory. A thorough, well-explained denial points toward a focused dispute over benefits.

Step 4: Test the medical and vocational proof

This step weighs your treating doctors' opinions, your functional limits, and your job's real demands against the insurer's reviewers. Did those reviewers examine you? Did they see the complete records? Did they address the policy's actual definition of disability? Strong treating evidence that the insurer never fairly confronted makes its defense harder to sustain. Thin or conflicting evidence calls for developing more proof before choosing a path.

Step 5: Measure the conduct against California standards

Insurance Code § 790.03(h) lists unfair claims practices. It doesn't create a right to sue, but its standards are evidence of what reasonable claims handling looks like. Because punitive damages require clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice, this step asks what the insurer's own records can actually prove. That answer decides whether to plead bad faith alone or also develop a punitive damages theory.

Step 6: Choose the path and protect the deadlines

Options range from a pre-suit demand to a lawsuit for breach of the policy, with or without a bad faith claim. We weigh the strength of the proof, the available remedies, and the earliest applicable deadline. Trial preparation shapes how evidence is organized from the start. Our bench includes lawyers with jury trial experience against major insurers.

Limits of this review. It isn't advice about your specific case, and it can't change what your policy says or what your medical record shows. Outcomes depend on the policy, the evidence, and the insurer's conduct.

Own Occupation or Any Occupation: Which Definition Did Principal Apply?

Under California law, a disability policy is a contract, so the definition of "disability" written into your Principal policy is the starting point for whether you qualify for benefits. The definition the insurer applied, and whether it applied the right one at the right time, is often the center of the dispute.

What "own occupation" and "any occupation" mean

Own-occupation coverage pays when you can't perform the material duties of your own occupation, even if you could do some other kind of work. A surgeon with a hand tremor may be disabled under an own-occupation definition while still able to teach. Some policies define "occupation" narrowly by specialty; others describe it more broadly.

Any-occupation coverage pays only if you can't perform any occupation for which you're reasonably suited by education, training, or experience. That's a harder standard to meet, and it puts vocational evidence front and center.

Many policies begin with an own-occupation period and then shift to an any-occupation standard. A termination letter that arrives around that transition deserves a close look at whether the insurer analyzed the new standard properly or simply declared you employable. Physicians face particular questions here; our page on how disability is defined for physicians addresses them.

Elimination periods, offsets, and exclusions

An elimination period is the waiting period between the date you become disabled and the date benefits start. Disputes about when disability began can affect whether it was satisfied.

Offsets reduce your monthly benefit by other income, such as certain government disability benefits or other coverage, depending on the policy wording. Errors in offset calculations can quietly shrink benefits for years.

Exclusions and limitations, including those for pre-existing conditions or certain categories of illness, also depend on the exact policy language, read together with California law. The words in your policy matter more than the insurer's summary of them.

A hypothetical example

Consider a hypothetical dentist with an individual own-occupation policy who develops a degenerative neck condition. Her treating physician documents that she can't hold the sustained posture chairside dentistry requires. The insurer's file reviewer, who never examined her, concludes she can do "sedentary work." That conclusion may be true and still beside the point, because the policy asks whether she can perform the duties of dentistry, not whether she can sit at a desk. Mismatches like this are what Step 2 and Step 4 are designed to find.

Medical professionals often see added scrutiny on these claims, which we discuss in doctors with LTD policies face extra scrutiny.

What Turns a Disability Denial Into Insurance Bad Faith in California?

Not every wrong denial is bad faith. Under California law, an insurer acts in bad faith when it unreasonably withholds benefits owed under the policy, and the California Supreme Court held in Egan v. Mutual of Omaha Ins. Co. (1979) 24 Cal.3d 809 that denying disability benefits without a thorough investigation breaches the implied covenant of good faith. The exception is a genuine, reasonable dispute grounded in a fair investigation.

The implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing is a promise California law reads into every insurance policy: the insurer won't do anything to unfairly interfere with your right to receive the benefits of the contract. Breaching it is a tort, which is why bad faith can carry damages a simple contract claim can't.

The investigation standard from Egan

In Egan, the insurer declined the insured's offer of a medical examination before denying disability benefits. The Supreme Court held that an insurer may not deny a claim without thoroughly investigating its basis. The Court affirmed the compensatory damages but reversed the punitive award, so Egan stands for the investigation duty, not for a punitive verdict.

The genuine dispute doctrine and treating physicians

The genuine dispute doctrine lets an insurer avoid bad faith liability when it denied a claim based on a reasonable, good-faith disagreement about coverage or value. It isn't a blanket shield. In Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co. (2007) 42 Cal.4th 713, the California Supreme Court held the defense protects an insurer only when its position rests on a reasonable, good-faith investigation. A jury could find bad faith where the insurer reached its medical conclusion without fairly investigating and disregarded the treating physician's evidence.

That's why the nature of the insurer's medical review matters so much. An independent medical examination (IME) is an exam by a doctor the insurer selects. A paper review is an opinion from a reviewer who reads records but never sees you. Neither is improper on its own. The question is whether the review was fair, complete, and aimed at the policy's actual definition of disability.

Surveillance and credibility

Insurers sometimes rely on surveillance video or social media to question a claimant's limitations. A few minutes of someone carrying groceries doesn't necessarily show what that person can do across a workday. We ask what the footage actually depicts, whether it was weighed against the medical record, and whether the insurer gave your doctors a chance to respond.

Where Insurance Code § 790.03 fits

Cal. Ins. Code § 790.03(h) lists unfair claims settlement practices, including misrepresenting policy provisions, failing to adopt reasonable standards for prompt investigation, and failing to promptly explain the basis for a denial. Under Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund Ins. Cos. (1988) 46 Cal.3d 287, § 790.03 creates no private right of action; the Insurance Commissioner enforces it. Policyholders keep their common-law bad faith claims, and the statute's standards remain evidence of what reasonable claims handling looks like. Our page on California Insurance Code 790.03 goes deeper.

A denial letter that never explains its reasoning is a frequent starting point. See failing to explain a denial for how those letters are evaluated.

Is a slow decision bad faith even without a denial? It can be. Unreasonable delay in investigating or paying a claim can support a bad faith theory under California law, even before a formal denial arrives. Whether it does depends on the reasons for the delay and the harm it caused.

Can Principal Rescind Your Policy Over an Application Answer?

Under California law, an insurer may try to rescind a policy based on concealment or a material misrepresentation in the application. The Insurance Code's concealment and misrepresentation provisions are the statutory bases insurers invoke for rescission, and whether the challenged answer was actually material is often the central question. Rescission is not automatic just because an answer was imperfect.

Rescission means unwinding the policy as if it never existed. The insurer typically refunds premiums and refuses all claims. For someone who's already disabled, that can mean losing coverage they can never replace.

What the insurer has to show

Under California's Insurance Code, concealment, whether intentional or unintentional, can entitle the insurer to rescind, and a representation that's false in a material point can do the same. Materiality asks whether the true information would have changed the insurer's decision to issue the policy or the terms it offered. An omission about a minor, unrelated doctor visit may not meet that test. A misstated diagnosis directly tied to the disabling condition might.

Where the evidence lives

Rescission cases turn on documents most policyholders never see. We look at the signed application, the questions as actually worded, and the underwriting file. Underwriting guidelines can show whether the insurer would have issued the policy anyway. We also look at timing. A rescission that surfaces only after a large claim arrives raises its own questions about how and when the insurer investigated.

Why the framing matters

When a rescission theory appears, the focus of the case shifts from your medical condition to your application and the insurer's underwriting. That's a different evidentiary fight, and recognizing it early changes what gets requested and when.

What should you do if Principal says your application was wrong? Don't sign a release or cash a premium refund check without understanding what it means for your claim. Gather your copy of the application and any notes about who filled it out. An agent's role in completing the form can matter.

What Can You Recover If Principal Denied Benefits in Bad Faith?

Under California law, a policyholder with an individual or other non-ERISA disability policy can recover unpaid benefits for breach of contract and, when bad faith is proven, tort damages beyond the policy limits. Punitive damages are available only on clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice under California's punitive damages statute; private-employer ERISA plans generally limit recovery to the benefit plus potential interest, attorney fees, and appropriate equitable relief.

Brandt fees

Brandt fees come from Brandt v. Superior Court (1985) 37 Cal.3d 813, a case that arose from a denial of disability benefits. The California Supreme Court held that attorney fees an insured reasonably incurs to compel payment of benefits the insurer tortiously withheld are recoverable as damages. Fees for pursuing the bad faith claim itself are not. This is a narrow but meaningful category, and it applies only when bad faith is established.

Recovery comparison

Recovery comparison
CategoryIndividual or other non-ERISA policy (California bad faith)Private-employer ERISA plan (generally)
Unpaid policy benefitsRecoverable for breach of the written policyRecoverable in a suit for benefits under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(1)(B)
Attorney feesBrandt fees for recovering tortiously withheld benefits; not fees for the bad faith claim itselfAvailable in the court's discretion under § 1132(g)
Other economic losses caused by the bad faithMay be recoverable as tort damages with proofGenerally not available
Emotional distressMay be recoverable as tort damages with proofNot available
Punitive damagesOnly on clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or maliceNot available
Interest and equitable reliefDepends on the claims and proofPotential interest and appropriate equitable relief under § 1132(a)(3)

The federal statute is 29 U.S.C. § 1132. Government and church plans are generally exempt from ERISA and generally retain California bad faith remedies against the insurer, though plan structure and the defendant can matter.

How value is assessed

There's no formula, and we won't offer an average. Value depends on the monthly benefit, how long the policy would pay, the strength of the medical and vocational proof, whether the insurer's records support bad faith, and whether there's evidence that could meet the punitive standard. Our page on remedies for bad faith insurance practices explains these categories in more depth.

How Long Do You Have to Sue Over a Denied Disability Claim in California?

California courts generally apply a two-year limitations period to bad faith tort claims under Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 339(1) and a four-year period to claims on the written policy under Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 337(a). These periods commonly run from the insurer's unequivocal denial, but accrual, tolling, and the policy's own suit-limitation clause can shorten or shift them, so any filing date should be confirmed by an attorney.

California requires disability policies to include a "Legal Actions" provision under Cal. Ins. Code § 10350.11. It bars a suit until 60 days after written proof of loss and bars any suit more than three years after the time proof of loss is required. Read next to the four-year contract period, that clause can be the earlier deadline. Your policy's exact wording controls.

An unequivocal denial is a clear, final refusal to pay, as opposed to a request for more information or a letter saying the claim is still under review. Pinning down that date is one reason we ask for every letter you received, in order.

The policy's own "Legal Actions" clause
DeadlineSourceApplies toWhat can change it
No suit until 60 days after written proof of loss; none after three years from when proof of loss is requiredCal. Ins. Code § 10350.11Required "Legal Actions" provision in disability policiesThe policy's actual wording and when proof of loss was due
Two years, commonly appliedCode Civ. Proc. § 339(1); Love v. Fire Ins. Exchange (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 1136Bad faith tort claims for breach of the implied covenantAccrual date, commonly the unequivocal denial, and tolling
Four years, commonly appliedCode Civ. Proc. § 337(a)Claims for breach of the written policyThe policy's suit-limitation clause can shorten it
At least 180 days after receiving the denial to file an internal appeal29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(h)(4)ERISA disability plans (we do not handle these)Plan terms may allow more time

Why we don't calculate your date on this page

Two people with the same insurer can face different deadlines because their policies, denial dates, and correspondence differ. A termination after years of payments raises different accrual questions than a denial at the start of a claim. The safer course is a prompt attorney review of the actual documents, not an estimate from general rules.

Where Are Los Angeles Disability Bad Faith Cases Filed and Heard?

In Los Angeles County, a disability bad faith lawsuit against an insurer is ordinarily filed in the Los Angeles County Superior Court as an unlimited civil case. Your filing and case assignment notice control where your hearings take place. An individual disability bad faith case is not ordinarily designated a complex case, which is a separate status under the California Rules of Court.

State court or federal court

Insurers sometimes move cases to federal court. An insurer sued by a California resident can remove a case on diversity grounds only if it is both incorporated and headquartered outside California, and more than $75,000 must be in controversy. In Los Angeles, a removed case goes to the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California. Removal changes procedure and timing, and it's one reason we evaluate the defendant's corporate citizenship before filing.

The California Department of Insurance

The California Department of Insurance regulates insurers that sell disability coverage in California and enforces the claims-handling standards in Insurance Code § 790.03. You can submit a complaint through the Department of Insurance consumer help page. A regulatory complaint can prompt a response from the insurer. It does not replace a lawsuit, and it doesn't pause the deadlines discussed above.

What local experience actually means here

For us, local experience means knowing how the Los Angeles County Superior Court handles civil insurance cases, how removal fights tend to unfold, and how a California jury hears evidence about an insurer's claim file. We've been representing California policyholders since 1979, and that history is in insurance disputes, not general personal injury work.

What Robert Gianelli and Our Team Bring to a Disability Denial

Under California law, the right outcome depends on evidence, not on who your lawyer is. What a firm can offer is a disciplined method, real trial readiness, and a track record against large insurers, and Gianelli & Morris has represented policyholders exclusively in insurance disputes for more than four decades. Here's what that looks like in concrete terms.

Robert S. Gianelli

Robert S. Gianelli is known for insurance bad faith litigation and class actions, and he has represented policyholders in disputes involving health, life, disability, and property insurance. His recognition includes the California Lawyer Attorney of the Year (CLAY) Award, which you can read about in Attorney Gianelli Receives CLAY Award. He was twice named a Consumer Attorney of the Year finalist, and he shares the Consumer Attorneys of California "Street Fighter of the Year" honor with a colleague at the firm.

Firm results, stated precisely

Our firm's verified results come from health coverage and annuity cases, not disability cases. We share them because they show how we work against large insurers, not to suggest what your case is worth:

  • LaRue v. Accountable Health Care, IPA: Robert Gianelli, with co-counsel, obtained a $7.2 million jury verdict for failure to provide a timely surgical referral.
  • Gallimore v. Kaiser: a class action over reconstructive surgery, with estimated benefits to Kaiser members exceeding $150 million.
  • Our firm has also obtained favorable results for policyholders in other insurance and annuity disputes.

The firm also holds an AV Preeminent® rating, and we have recovered hundreds of millions of dollars for policyholders over the years. Past results do not guarantee any future outcome.

What you can expect from us

We'll tell you early whether your Principal coverage is a California insurance case or an ERISA case. If it's ours to evaluate, we'll explain what the policy promised, what the claim file shows, and which deadline comes first. And we'll be direct about weaknesses as well as strengths. If you've been told your rejected claim is final, our article on a long-term disability insurance claim rejected covers what often comes next.

The information on this page is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is unique, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Contact a qualified attorney to discuss your specific situation.

Talk to us about your Principal denial

The Legal Actions clause in your policy and California's limitations periods can begin running from the insurer's denial, so the date on your denial letter matters. Call Gianelli & Morris at 213-489-1600 for a free case review of your Principal disability denial. Bring the policy and every letter you received, and we'll start by confirming whether California law governs your claim.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to hire a lawyer for a Principal disability denial?

For insurance bad faith cases, Gianelli & Morris works on a contingency fee basis, meaning our fees are taken as a percentage of any award we recover, consistent with that contingency arrangement. The first conversation is a free consultation to discuss your legal options. Ask us how litigation expenses are handled, since those are separate from attorney fees, and for any matter outside bad faith we'll explain the fee arrangement at that consultation.

How long do I have to sue Principal after my disability claim was denied in California?

California courts generally apply two years to bad faith claims (Code Civ. Proc. § 339(1)) and four years to claims on the written policy (§ 337(a)), commonly measured from the insurer's unequivocal denial. Disability policies must also contain a Legal Actions clause under Insurance Code § 10350.11 that bars suits more than three years after proof of loss is required, which can be the earlier deadline. Accrual and tolling can shift these dates, so have an attorney confirm yours promptly.

Does Gianelli & Morris handle employer-provided Principal disability plans?

Not if the plan is governed by ERISA. Most private-employer group disability coverage falls under ERISA, and our firm does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases. We'll help you figure out whether your plan is ERISA so you can find appropriate counsel quickly, since ERISA disability plans set an internal appeal deadline of at least 180 days after you receive the denial. Government and church plans are generally exempt from ERISA, and we evaluate qualifying claims under those plans.

What is my Principal disability denial case worth?

There's no average or formula. Value depends on the monthly benefit, how long the policy would pay, the strength of your medical and vocational evidence, and whether the insurer's conduct supports a bad faith claim. Under California law, bad faith can add tort damages and Brandt fees, and punitive damages require clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice.

Can I sue Principal under Insurance Code § 790.03?

No. Under Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund (1988), § 790.03 creates no private right of action, and the Insurance Commissioner enforces it. You can still bring a common-law bad faith claim, and the statute's unfair claims practices standards can be evidence of what reasonable claims handling looks like.

Principal paid my claim for years and then stopped. Can I challenge that?

Often, yes, if your policy is an individual or other non-ERISA policy. A termination is reviewed like a denial: what definition of disability applied, what the insurer relied on, and whether its investigation was thorough and fair under Egan and Wilson. Terminations that coincide with a shift from own-occupation to any-occupation coverage deserve particularly close review.

What if Principal says I made a mistake on my application?

California's Insurance Code lets an insurer seek rescission for concealment or a material misrepresentation, but the misstatement has to matter. The key questions are whether the answer was actually false, how the question was worded, and whether the true information would have changed the insurer's decision. Don't sign a release or cash a premium refund check before understanding what it means for your claim.

Should I accept a settlement offer from Principal?

Not before you understand what you're giving up. A settlement typically ends your right to future benefits and any bad faith claim, so it needs to be measured against the full value of the policy and the strength of your evidence. An offer by itself doesn't prove the claim is undervalued or fairly valued; it's a number to evaluate against your documents.

Does a discretionary clause in my policy mean the insurer's decision is final?

Not for a California resident. Cal. Ins. Code § 10110.6 makes void any clause in a life or disability policy covering a California resident that reserves discretionary authority to the insurer to decide eligibility or interpret the policy. That can affect how much deference a court gives the insurer's decision, including in some employer-plan cases.

How long does a disability bad faith case take?

We don't quote average timelines because they depend on factors specific to each case. Timing is shaped by whether the insurer removes the case to federal court, how much of the claim file must be obtained in discovery, whether medical or vocational experts are needed, and whether the case resolves or goes to trial. We'll walk you through the factors that apply to your situation.

Will my Principal case go to trial?

Some cases resolve before trial and some don't, and no lawyer can honestly promise which way yours will go. We prepare the evidence from the start as if a jury will hear it, because that preparation also shapes any resolution discussion. The decision whether to settle or go to trial is ultimately yours.

How do I pay my bills while my disability case is pending?

A lawsuit doesn't produce interim benefit payments, so many people look at other sources while a case proceeds, such as government disability benefits they may separately qualify for. Be aware that many disability policies offset certain other benefits, so check your policy's offset language before assuming how one affects the other. Keep up with medical treatment if you can, since gaps in care can be cited against your claim later.