Skip to main content
Gianelli & Morris attorneys Alex Gianelli, Joshua S. Davis, Robert S. Gianelli and Loring Rose

Protecting insuredrights since 1979

We fight insurance companies that refuse to pay.

Insurance companies don’t always play fair. Our insurance claim attorneys help policyholders fight denied, delayed, or underpaid insurance claims and recover what they’re owed.

Free Consultation

California Own-Occupation Disability Denial Lawyer

Free Consultation

Under California law, an own-occupation disability policy generally pays when you can't perform the material duties of your own job, even if other work is possible. If the insurer denies the claim or shifts you to an any-occupation test, courts commonly apply two years to bad-faith claims and four years to claims on the policy, though policy terms and tolling can change that. ERISA employer plans follow different rules.

Robert S. Gianelli is a partner at Gianelli & Morris who represents California policyholders in disputes over health, life, disability, and property insurance. He received the California Lawyer Attorney of the Year (CLAY) Award, and he represented plaintiffs in Arce v. Kaiser, a class action over autism treatment. Our firm has 40+ years serving California policyholders. This page explains what an own-occupation denial means, why a claim can be moved to an any-occupation standard, and what you can do next. It builds on our broader guide to long-term disability insurance claim denials.

If you built a career on one specialized skill and an illness or injury took it away, a letter saying you can still "work" can feel like a second injury. You're not imagining the difference between your job and any job. Many policies were written around exactly that difference.

If your own-occupation claim was denied, cut off after a surveillance report, or relabeled as an any-occupation claim, our Los Angeles team can review the policy and the denial letter with you. At Gianelli & Morris, we take insurance bad faith cases on a contingency fee basis, which means our fees are taken as a percentage of any award we recover. We focus on individual and other non-ERISA policies, and we'll tell you early if your coverage falls outside that. Call 213-489-1600 for a free consultation to discuss your legal options.

Key Takeaways

  • In a California disability policy, an own-occupation definition looks at the material duties of the occupation you held when the disability began. An any-occupation definition asks whether you can do other gainful work the policy describes.
  • Under California Insurance Code § 10110.6, a clause giving the insurer discretionary authority to decide eligibility or interpret a disability policy covering a California resident is void.
  • Insurance Code § 790.03 gives policyholders no private right to sue (Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund, 1988). A wrongful-denial lawsuit is a common-law bad-faith claim, and § 790.03 describes the conduct standard the Department of Insurance enforces.
  • Private-employer group plans governed by ERISA don't allow a bad-faith tort claim or punitive damages. Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases.
  • Suit deadlines depend on the claim type, the policy's own suit-limitation language, accrual, and tolling. An attorney should confirm any filing date.

What Is at Stake When an Own-Occupation Claim Is Denied?

In California, a denied or terminated own-occupation claim usually stops the monthly benefit meant to replace your income, while the condition that ended your career stays the same. California suit deadlines, including the two-year period courts commonly apply to bad-faith claims under Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 339(1), generally begin running from the insurer's denial, and a policy's own terms can shorten or shift that timing.

The cost goes beyond one monthly check

People often buy own-occupation coverage because their income depends on a narrow skill set. Consider a few hypothetical examples. A surgeon develops a tremor. A trial lawyer can no longer sustain hours of concentration after a brain injury. A dental hygienist's cervical spine condition makes chairside work impossible. Each might still be capable of some job, and that's exactly the gap own-occupation coverage was designed to fill.

When benefits stop, the pressure lands fast. Mortgage payments, tuition, and medical bills don't pause for an appeal. Some policies include a waiver of premium provision, which excuses premium payments while you're disabled. A denial can raise the question of whether premiums are suddenly due again, and an unpaid premium can create a separate lapse problem.

Here's what that means for you.

A denial can push people toward a quick decision, such as taking a lower-paying job outside their field. Depending on how your policy is worded, that move can affect the claim. Some own-occupation definitions keep paying if you work in a different occupation. Others reduce or end benefits when you do. Read the definition before you change careers, not after.

Why the timing questions arrive early

Several clocks can apply at once, and they don't all start at the same moment:

  • Bad-faith tort claims: Courts commonly apply two years, often running from the insurer's unequivocal denial.
  • Claims on the written policy: Courts commonly apply the four-year period for written contracts.
  • The policy's "Legal Actions" clause: California requires disability policies to contain a provision limiting when suit can be filed, discussed in the deadlines section below.
  • Employer ERISA plans: Federal rules give claimants at least 180 days after receiving a disability denial to file an internal appeal. Missing that window can create serious problems for a later lawsuit.

None of these periods should be calculated from a web page. They're a reason to have the denial reviewed promptly. For broader background on rejected claims, see our discussion of what to do when a long-term disability insurance claim is rejected.

Is Your Disability Policy Governed by California Law or ERISA?

Under federal law, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) governs most disability coverage that a private employer provides, while individually purchased policies fall under California insurance law. ERISA supersedes state laws that relate to employee benefit plans under 29 U.S.C. § 1144, except laws that regulate insurance, and in Pilot Life Ins. Co. v. Dedeaux (1987) the U.S. Supreme Court held state common-law bad-faith claims preempted for ERISA plans.

Later Supreme Court decisions narrowed parts of Pilot Life's reasoning. Even so, a private-employer group plan generally doesn't support a California bad-faith tort claim. That single question decides which remedies exist, which deadlines matter, and who can help you.

Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases. We evaluate selected individual and other qualifying non-ERISA long-term disability disputes. If your coverage turns out to be an ERISA plan, we'll explain why that matters so you can find other counsel quickly.

Clues that point to an individual, California-governed policy

No single fact settles the question, but these details often point toward a policy governed by California law:

  • You applied for the policy yourself, often through an agent or broker.
  • You paid the premiums directly from your own account.
  • The policy stayed with you when you changed employers.
  • Your documents are a full policy with a schedule page, not a summary plan description from an employer.

The full history still matters. An individual policy can sometimes be treated as part of an ERISA plan if an employer established or maintained it as part of a benefit program. That's why the application, enrollment forms, and premium records come first in any review.

Government and church plans

Plans for government employers and church plans are generally exempt from ERISA. Teachers, police officers, firefighters, other public employees, and religious workers generally keep California bad-faith remedies against the insurer, although the plan's structure and who the defendant is can affect the analysis. We explain more in our article on how public employee insurance denials are different.

What ERISA changes for employer-plan claims

For private-employer plans, ERISA changes both the process and the remedies. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1132, a participant can sue to recover benefits due under the plan. Recovery is generally limited to those benefits plus potential interest, attorney fees in the court's discretion under § 1132(g), and appropriate equitable relief under § 1132(a)(3). Emotional-distress and punitive damages aren't available. ERISA benefit suits can be filed in state or federal court.

One California rule matters on either path. Under Cal. Ins. Code § 10110.6, a provision in a life or disability policy covering a California resident that reserves discretionary authority to the insurer to decide eligibility or interpret the policy is void and unenforceable. That keeps an insurer from writing itself a rule that its own reading of the policy wins.

Own Occupation vs. Any Occupation: What Is the Difference?

In a California disability policy, an own-occupation definition asks whether you can perform the material duties of the occupation you held when the disability began. An any-occupation definition asks whether you can perform other gainful work the policy describes. Many policies use both, paying under the own-occupation test for a period stated in the policy and then switching to the any-occupation test.

Material and substantial duties is a phrase many policies use to describe the core tasks of your occupation. In plain language, it means the work that actually defines the job, not occasional or peripheral tasks you could hand off.

Own Occupation vs. Any Occupation: What Is the Difference?
FeatureOwn-Occupation DefinitionAny-Occupation Definition
Core questionCan you perform the material duties of the occupation you held when disability began?Can you perform other gainful work the policy describes, often work suited to your education, training, and experience?
Working in another fieldSome policies keep paying; modified versions reduce or stop benefits if you work elsewhereEarning income in another occupation generally weakens the claim
Main evidenceYour actual job duties, specialty, and how the condition prevents themFunctional capacity, transferable skills, and whether suitable jobs exist at the required pay
When it appliesFrom the start of benefits, sometimes for the life of the claimFrom the start, or after the own-occupation period ends, depending on the policy
Frequent disputeHow the insurer characterizes your occupationWhether vocational reports reflect your documented limitations

How policies describe "your occupation"

Policies differ on what counts as your occupation. Some refer to the occupation you were performing when the disability began. Others mention a medical or dental specialty by name, which can matter a great deal for physicians and dentists whose work centers on procedures. We discuss that in detail in how disability is defined for physicians with long-term disability policies.

The question isn't your job title. It's what your work required day to day: the procedures, the hours, the physical positions, the cognitive load, and the travel.

Variations in own-occupation wording

Not every policy labeled "own occupation" works the same way. A few patterns appear often enough to check for:

  1. Pure own-occupation wording pays if you can't perform your occupation, even if you work in another field.
  2. Modified own-occupation wording pays only if you can't perform your occupation and aren't working in another one.
  3. Residual or partial disability riders pay a reduced benefit when you can work, but with a loss of income or duties.

Residual disability is a benefit some policies pay when you can still work in a limited way but have lost a measured share of your income or time because of the condition. It's usually calculated by a formula in the rider.

The definition is the starting point

Your policy's written definition is where the analysis begins, not where it ends. How that definition applies to your real duties, your medical record, and California law is where disputes get decided. Two people with the same diagnosis can have very different claims because their work demanded different things.

Promise, File, Proof: How We Review a Disability Denial

We review a denied or terminated own-occupation claim through six questions we call Promise, File, Proof. It's a sequence of decisions, not a forecast of any result, and the answer at each step shapes the next one. The first question is always whether California insurance law governs the policy, because that answer decides which remedies exist at all.

Step 1: Confirm which law governs the policy

We start with the policy or certificate, the application and enrollment forms, premium payment records, and any plan document. The goal is to determine whether this is an individual or other non-ERISA policy, or part of a private employer's ERISA plan. If it's ERISA, we explain why and refer you out promptly. If it's governed by California law, the contract and bad-faith analysis continues, and Insurance Code § 10110.6 applies to any discretionary clause.

Step 2: Read exactly what the policy promised

Next we identify the definition of disability the insurer actually applied, and whether it matches the one in effect for your claim period. We also review the elimination period, offsets, exclusions, and riders.

An elimination period is the waiting period, stated in the policy, between the start of your disability and the date benefits begin. If the insurer raises a misrepresentation theory, the focus shifts to the signed application, the underwriting file, and whether any alleged misstatement actually mattered.

Step 3: Rebuild what the insurer actually did

California's Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations require a thorough, fair, and objective investigation. They also require a written first-party denial stating every basis for the denial with its factual and legal grounds. In Egan v. Mutual of Omaha Ins. Co. (1979), the California Supreme Court held that denying disability benefits without a thorough investigation breached the implied covenant of good faith. We rebuild the timeline from the denial letters, claim notes, reviewer reports, and correspondence. Gaps or shifting reasons point toward a bad-faith theory. For more on this issue, read about an insurer failing to explain a denial.

Step 4: Test the medical and vocational proof

Here we weigh your treating doctors' opinions, functional limitations, and job demands against the insurer's reviewers. Did those reviewers examine you? Did they see the complete records? Did they address the policy's actual definition of disability? Under Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co. (2007), an insurer's "genuine dispute" defense protects it only when its position rests on a reasonable, good-faith investigation. If the evidence is thin or conflicting, the next move may be developing more medical or vocational proof before choosing a path.

Step 5: Measure the conduct against California standards

Insurance Code § 790.03(h) lists unfair claims practices, and its standards remain evidence of what reasonable claims handling looks like even though the statute creates no private right to sue. California's punitive-damages statute requires clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice. So this step asks a practical question: what can the insurer's own records prove? That answer decides whether to plead bad faith only or also develop a punitive-damages theory.

Step 6: Choose the path and protect the deadlines

Options range from a pre-suit demand to a lawsuit for breach of the policy, with or without a bad-faith claim. Under Brandt v. Superior Court (1985), attorney fees reasonably incurred to recover benefits that were tortiously withheld can be recovered as damages. We organize the evidence from the first review as if a jury may someday see it, and we weigh the strength of the proof, the available remedies, and the earliest applicable deadline before recommending a direction.

Not sure where your claim stands in that sequence? Call 213-489-1600 and have your policy, the denial or termination letter, and any claim correspondence nearby. We'll go through them with you during a free case review.

Why Do Insurers Deny Own-Occupation Claims?

Under California's claims regulations, an insurer must put every basis for a first-party denial in writing, so the denial letter is the first place to look. The stated reasons on own-occupation claims can fall into several categories, and each calls for different evidence: how the insurer characterized your occupation, what its medical reviewers concluded, what surveillance appeared to show, whether the application was accurate, or whether a policy limitation applies.

Your occupation gets described differently than you performed it

One recurring dispute is the insurer describing your occupation in general terms instead of the duties you actually performed. Picture a hypothetical interventional cardiologist whose practice was mostly catheter procedures. If the insurer frames the occupation as "physician," it may argue that office consultations remain possible. The policy language and your real duties decide which description fits. Medical professionals face this issue often enough that we've written about how doctors with LTD policies face extra scrutiny.

Practice records, procedure logs, billing codes, and schedules can show what your occupation actually required.

Paper reviews and independent medical exams

A paper review is a records-only evaluation by a doctor the insurer retains, who reads your file but never examines you. An independent medical examination (IME) is an in-person exam by a doctor the insurer selects and pays. Neither is automatically unfair. But each has questions worth asking. Did the reviewer see your complete records? Did the opinion address your occupation's real duties or only general work capacity? Did it engage with what your treating physicians wrote?

Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co. held that a jury could find bad faith where an insurer reached its medical conclusion without fairly investigating and disregarded the treating physician's evidence.

Surveillance and social media

Some terminations follow a surveillance report or a review of social media posts. A video of someone carrying groceries for a few minutes says little about whether that person can perform a surgeon's work for ten hours, or a litigator's sustained concentration across a trial day. Context matters. We compare what the footage or posts actually show against the specific duties your occupation required.

Application misstatements and rescission

Rescission means the insurer treats the policy as if it never existed, usually returning premiums instead of paying benefits. California's Insurance Code allows rescission for concealment or for a representation that is false in a material point. That makes materiality the central question. Would the true answer have changed the insurer's underwriting decision? The underwriting file and the insurer's own guidelines often hold that answer.

Policy limitations and exclusions

Some policies limit benefit duration for certain conditions, such as mental health conditions or illnesses diagnosed mainly through self-reported symptoms. Others contain pre-existing condition exclusions. Whether a limitation actually applies is often disputed. A condition with physical findings and a psychiatric component, for instance, may not fit neatly inside a mental-health limitation.

What Happens When a Policy Switches to Any Occupation?

In California, many disability policies stop asking about your own job after the stated own-occupation period and begin asking whether you can perform any gainful occupation. An any-occupation denial isn't a finding that your condition improved; it can simply reflect a different question applied to the same medical facts.

A gainful occupation, as policies commonly define it, is work you could reasonably do given your education, training, and experience. Some policies also require that it pay a set percentage of your pre-disability earnings. The precise wording sits in your policy's definitions section.

Reading the any-occupation definition carefully

The switch is where many claims change direction. An insurer that paid for years under the own-occupation standard may send a letter shortly before the transition date asking for updated records, new forms, or an exam. That's normal claims handling in itself. The question is whether the insurer then applies the any-occupation definition as written, including any earnings threshold and any requirement that the work fit your training and experience.

But there's a catch.

A definition that sounds broad on paper can be narrower in practice. "Any occupation" rarely means literally any job in existence. If the policy ties the test to your background and a minimum income level, an insurer's list of hypothetical jobs has to satisfy both.

Testing the vocational evidence

Insurers commonly support an any-occupation denial with vocational reports. A transferable skills analysis is a report that compares the skills from your past work with the demands of other jobs to identify positions you could supposedly fill. A labor market survey checks whether those jobs actually exist and what they pay.

We test those reports against your record:

  • Do the physical and mental limitations the vocational consultant assumed match your treating doctors' opinions?
  • Did the consultant account for medication side effects, fatigue, or the need for unscheduled breaks?
  • Do the identified jobs pay enough to meet any earnings threshold in the policy?
  • Did a functional capacity evaluation (a structured test of what you can physically do over a session) actually measure the abilities the jobs require?

Social Security and other offsets

Many disability policies reduce the monthly benefit by other income, such as Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) or certain pension or workers' compensation payments. The policy's language generally determines which offsets apply and how they're calculated. Some policies also require repayment of an overpayment if you later receive a retroactive SSDI award.

An SSDI approval doesn't bind your private insurer. It can still be relevant evidence, particularly when the insurer encouraged or required you to apply and later argues you can work.

When Does a Disability Denial Become Insurance Bad Faith in California?

Under California law, an insurer breaches the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing when it unreasonably withholds benefits due under the policy. That covenant is a duty the law reads into every insurance contract, requiring the insurer to treat your interests at least as seriously as its own when handling your claim. The main limit is the "genuine dispute" defense, which, under Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co., protects an insurer only when its position rests on a reasonable, good-faith investigation.

Is every wrong denial bad faith? No. In California, an insurer can be wrong about coverage without acting in bad faith. A bad-faith claim generally requires that benefits were due and that the insurer withheld them unreasonably or without proper cause. A denial that was mistaken but reasonable may support a contract claim for benefits without supporting a tort claim.

Investigation failures

Egan v. Mutual of Omaha Ins. Co. involved an insurer that denied disability benefits without a thorough investigation, including declining the insured's offer of a medical examination before the denial. The California Supreme Court held that failure breached the implied covenant and affirmed the compensatory damages. (The court reversed the punitive award, so Egan stands for the investigation duty, not for punitive damages.)

Where Insurance Code § 790.03 fits

Cal. Ins. Code § 790.03 lists unfair claims settlement practices when done knowingly with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice. The list includes:

  • misrepresenting pertinent facts or policy provisions, § 790.03(h)(1);
  • failing to adopt reasonable standards for prompt investigation, § 790.03(h)(3);
  • failing to attempt in good faith a prompt, fair settlement once liability is reasonably clear, § 790.03(h)(5); and
  • failing to promptly explain the basis for a denial, § 790.03(h)(13).

In Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund (1988), the California Supreme Court held that § 790.03 creates no private right of action, so the statute sets a conduct standard the Department of Insurance enforces while the lawsuit itself is a common-law bad-faith claim. You can also ask the regulator for help through the Department of Insurance consumer help program. We explain more about California Insurance Code 790.03 and bad faith.

Key insight: A denial letter that cites one reason, followed by a later letter citing a different reason, is worth a close look. Shifting explanations don't prove bad faith on their own, but they bear directly on whether the insurer's investigation was reasonable.

What Can You Recover After a Wrongful Disability Denial?

Under California law, a policyholder with an individual or other non-ERISA disability policy may recover unpaid benefits under the contract and, when the insurer acted in bad faith, tort damages. If the coverage is a private-employer plan governed by ERISA, recovery is generally limited to the benefits due plus potential interest, attorney fees in the court's discretion under § 1132(g), and appropriate equitable relief under § 1132(a)(3).

What Can You Recover After a Wrongful Disability Denial?
Coverage TypeGoverning LawBad-Faith Tort ClaimPotential Recovery
Individually purchased disability policyCalifornia contract and insurance lawAvailable when benefits were unreasonably withheldUnpaid benefits; Brandt fees; emotional-distress damages when proven; punitive damages only on clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice
Private-employer group planFederal ERISANot available (preempted)Generally benefits due plus potential interest, discretionary attorney fees, and appropriate equitable relief
Government-employer plan (teachers, police, firefighters, public employees)Exempt from ERISA; California law generally appliesGenerally retained against the insurerGenerally similar to individual policies, depending on plan structure and the defendant
Church plan (religious workers)Generally exempt from ERISAGenerally retained against the insurerGenerally similar to individual policies, depending on plan structure and the defendant

Brandt fees, emotional distress, and punitive damages

Brandt fees are the attorney fees you reasonably incur to recover policy benefits an insurer tortiously withheld, which California treats as damages under Brandt v. Superior Court (1985). Fees for pursuing the bad-faith claim itself aren't included. Brandt arose from a denial of disability benefits, which makes it especially relevant here.

Emotional-distress damages may also be recoverable in a California bad-faith tort claim, a principle traced through cases such as Crisci v. Security Insurance Company. Punitive damages are a separate question. They require clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice, so they depend heavily on what the insurer's internal records show. Read more about remedies for bad faith insurance practices.

Our track record, in context

We have recovered hundreds of millions of dollars for policyholders across our practice. In one example, Robert S. Gianelli and co-counsel obtained a $7,225,000 jury verdict in LaRue v. Accountable Health Care, IPA against a contracted medical group that failed to provide a timely surgical referral. The firm has handled other significant cases against insurers and financial companies, which we can discuss with you during a consultation.

Neither was an own-occupation disability case. They show the firm's experience holding insurers and health care organizations accountable, and they don't predict the result of any other case.

How Long Do You Have to Sue Over a Disability Denial in California?

California courts generally apply two years under Code of Civil Procedure § 339(1) to bad-faith tort claims, following Love v. Fire Ins. Exchange (1990), and four years under Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 337(a) to claims on the written policy. These periods commonly run from the insurer's unequivocal denial, but accrual, tolling, and the policy's own suit-limitation provision can shorten or shift them.

An unequivocal denial is a clear, final refusal by the insurer to pay the claim. Pinpointing that date can be harder than it sounds, especially when benefits were paid for a while and then terminated, or when the insurer kept corresponding after the first denial.

How Long Do You Have to Sue Over a Disability Denial in California?
DeadlineSourceWhat It CoversKey Caveat
2 yearsCode Civ. Proc. § 339(1); Love v. Fire Ins. Exchange (1990)Bad-faith tort claims for breach of the implied covenantCommonly runs from the unequivocal denial; tolling may apply
4 yearsCode Civ. Proc. § 337(a)Claims for breach of the written policyThe policy's suit-limitation provision may affect timing
No suit until 60 days after written proof of loss; none after 3 years from when proof of loss is requiredInsurance Code § 10350.11 (required "Legal Actions" provision)Suits on disability policiesHow it interacts with the periods above depends on the policy and facts
At least 180 days to file an internal appealFederal ERISA claims-procedure regulationPrivate-employer group disability plansGianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA cases; seek counsel quickly

The policy's own suit-limitation clause

Cal. Ins. Code § 10350.11 requires disability policies to include a "Legal Actions" provision. It bars suit until 60 days after written proof of loss has been furnished, and bars suit more than three years after the time proof of loss is required. Ongoing disability claims involve periodic proofs of loss, which is one reason the analysis can get complicated.

Why a lawyer should confirm the date

These rules interact. A two-year bad-faith period, a four-year contract period, and a three-year policy provision may all point to different dates for the same claim. Tolling doctrines can extend some periods, and late correspondence from an insurer can muddy when a denial became final. Treat every date on this page as general information. Have an attorney calculate the deadline that actually applies to you, and do it before the earliest possible date has passed.

Filing a Disability Insurance Lawsuit in Los Angeles County

A California disability insurance lawsuit brought by a Los Angeles resident is commonly filed in the Los Angeles County Superior Court as an unlimited civil case. That's the court's category for civil cases above the limited-civil dollar threshold, with full access to discovery and trial. An insurer may remove the case to the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California only if diversity jurisdiction exists, which requires the insurer to be both incorporated and headquartered outside California and more than $75,000 in controversy.

An individual disability bad-faith case is ordinarily an unlimited civil case. It isn't a "complex" case, which is a separate designation under the California Rules of Court. Where your case is actually heard depends on the case notice and the department the court assigns, so check those documents rather than assuming a particular courthouse.

Under federal rules, where corporations are "from"

For diversity purposes, a corporation is a citizen of every state where it's incorporated and of the state where it has its principal place of business. An insurer incorporated in another state but headquartered in California can't use diversity to move a case brought by a California resident into federal court. A non-ERISA case without diversity generally stays in state court.

What shapes how long a case takes

We can't give you an honest month count for a disability case, and we won't invent one. The factors that drive timing include:

  • how quickly the insurer produces the complete claim file and claim-handling guidelines;
  • whether medical or vocational experts are needed on both sides;
  • the number of depositions, including the insurer's reviewers and adjusters;
  • whether the parties agree to mediation, and when;
  • the trial date the court sets.

Some cases resolve after the claim file comes in. Others need full discovery and a trial date before an insurer reassesses its position.

Where the Department of Insurance fits

The California Department of Insurance licenses and regulates disability insurers and enforces the unfair claims practices standards. A complaint to the Department can prompt a response from the insurer. It isn't a substitute for a lawsuit, though, and it doesn't pause the deadlines discussed above.

How Fees and Your First Conversation With Us Work

At Gianelli & Morris, bad-faith insurance cases are handled on contingency: our fee comes from a percentage of any award we recover, consistent with our contingency fee arrangement. The first conversation is a free consultation, and we'll explain how any fee arrangement and case expenses would work for your specific matter before you decide anything. If your matter turns out to be something other than a bad-faith claim, we'll walk through the fee arrangement for that type of case at the consultation.

What to bring to a free case review

The more of these you have, the more specific the conversation can be. Don't worry if some are missing. Insurers often hold documents you've never seen.

  1. Your full policy, including riders, amendments, and the schedule page
  2. Your signed application, if you have a copy
  3. Every denial, termination, or benefit-change letter
  4. Claim forms and correspondence with the insurer
  5. Any IME, paper-review, or surveillance report the insurer shared
  6. Treating physician records and work-restriction notes
  7. A written description of your job duties, or a job description

Who you'll be working with

You can read Robert S. Gianelli's background on his attorney profile. He's been recognized by Consumer Attorneys of California with its "Street Fighter of the Year" Award and twice named a Consumer Attorney of the Year finalist. Our firm also holds an AV Preeminent® rating. Credentials don't decide cases, but they tell you who has been doing this work and for how long: our firm has served policyholders since 1979.

The information on this page is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is unique, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Please contact a qualified attorney to discuss your specific situation.

Your denial letter started a clock, and California's two-year bad-faith period and your policy's three-year "Legal Actions" provision won't wait for the insurer to reconsider. Gianelli & Morris reviews own-occupation and any-occupation denials for policyholders in Los Angeles and throughout California. Call 213-489-1600 to schedule a free case review and find out which deadline applies to you.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does an own-occupation disability lawyer cost in California?

At Gianelli & Morris, insurance bad-faith cases are handled on a contingency fee basis, meaning our fee is a percentage of any award we recover. You don't pay an hourly fee up front for that type of case. For any other type of matter, we explain the fee arrangement and how case expenses are handled during the free consultation.

How long do I have to sue after my disability claim was denied in California?

California courts commonly apply two years to bad-faith tort claims under Code of Civil Procedure § 339(1) and four years to claims on the written policy under § 337(a), often running from the insurer's unequivocal denial. Your policy must also contain a "Legal Actions" provision under Insurance Code § 10350.11 that bars suit more than three years after proof of loss is required. Tolling and accrual can shift these dates, so have an attorney confirm yours promptly.

What is my disability denial case worth?

Under California law, the starting point is usually the unpaid benefits owed under your individual or non-ERISA policy, plus future benefits if the disability continues. If the insurer acted in bad faith, you may also seek Brandt fees, emotional-distress damages when proven, and punitive damages only with clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice. For private-employer ERISA plans, recovery is generally limited to benefits, potential interest, discretionary fees, and equitable relief.

Should I accept a lump-sum buyout offer from my disability insurer?

In California, a buyout usually means giving up all future benefits under the policy in exchange for a single payment, and often releasing any bad-faith claim too. Whether that's sensible depends on your age, prognosis, the benefit period left, and whether the insurer handled your claim properly. Have the offer and the release language reviewed before you sign, because a signed release is generally hard to undo.

Can my insurer cut off benefits because I started working in a different field?

It depends on your policy's definition. Some California own-occupation policies keep paying if you can't perform your own occupation, even while you earn income elsewhere. Modified own-occupation definitions reduce or end benefits once you work in another occupation, and residual disability riders may pay a partial benefit. Check the definition before making a career change.

How long does a disability insurance case take in Los Angeles?

There's no reliable average we can honestly give. In Los Angeles County Superior Court, timing depends on how quickly the insurer produces its claim file, whether experts are needed, how many depositions occur, whether mediation happens, and when the court sets trial. Some disputes resolve after a demand, while others proceed through full discovery.

Do I need a lawyer to challenge an own-occupation denial?

California law doesn't require one, and some people resolve claims on their own. But own-occupation disputes often turn on the policy's exact wording, the insurer's vocational and medical reports, and deadlines that interact in complicated ways. A lawyer can obtain the claim file, test the insurer's reasoning against California's good-faith standards, and calculate the deadline that applies.

If you'd like a second set of eyes on your denial letter, call Gianelli & Morris at 213-489-1600 for a free consultation.

What if my disability insurer is based outside California?

An out-of-state insurer that sells a disability policy to a California resident is still subject to California insurance law, including Insurance Code § 10110.6 on discretionary clauses. The insurer may try to remove a lawsuit to the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California. That's possible only if it is both incorporated and headquartered outside California and more than $75,000 is in controversy.

Will my disability case go to trial?

Some California disability cases resolve through a demand or mediation, and others go to trial before a jury. Nobody can honestly predict which path your case will take at the start. We organize the evidence from the first review as though a jury may see it, which keeps trial a realistic option if the insurer won't reassess its position.

Does a Social Security disability approval prove my own-occupation claim?

No. An SSDI award doesn't bind a private disability insurer under California law, because the insurer applies the policy's definition rather than Social Security's. It can still be relevant evidence, particularly if the insurer required you to apply. Your policy's language generally determines whether SSDI benefits reduce your monthly payment and whether a retroactive award creates an overpayment.

How do I manage expenses while my disability case is pending?

Contingency representation in California bad-faith cases means you don't pay an hourly attorney fee up front, which helps. Some people also pursue SSDI or other benefits while the dispute continues, but those can trigger offsets under your policy. Review those consequences before applying, and keep paying premiums if your policy requires it so the coverage doesn't lapse.

My disability coverage comes through my private employer. Can Gianelli & Morris help?

Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases, and most private-employer group disability plans fall under ERISA. Federal rules give you at least 180 days after a disability denial to file an internal appeal, so look for ERISA counsel quickly. If your coverage is an individual policy or a government or church plan, those are generally outside ERISA, and we can evaluate the claim.