Skip to main content
Gianelli & Morris attorneys Alex Gianelli, Joshua S. Davis, Robert S. Gianelli and Loring Rose

Protecting insuredrights since 1979

We fight insurance companies that refuse to pay.

Insurance companies don’t always play fair. Our insurance claim attorneys help policyholders fight denied, delayed, or underpaid insurance claims and recover what they’re owed.

Free Consultation

California Out-of-Network Insurance Denial Lawyer

Free Consultation

In California, you can usually challenge an out-of-network denial, but the path depends on who regulates your coverage. Under Cal. Health & Safety Code § 1371.4, health care service plans must pay for emergency services and care until the patient is stabilized. Other out-of-network denials generally go through the plan's grievance process and then state review. The exception is a self-funded employer plan, which follows federal ERISA rules instead.

Robert S. Gianelli is a partner at Gianelli & Morris. The Los Angeles firm has spent 40+ years serving California policyholders, and he takes on the health plans and insurers that refuse to pay for care. He has received the California Lawyer Attorney of the Year (CLAY) Award, and his notable cases include Arce v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, a class action over denied autism treatment. This page explains how out-of-network denials work in California, which agency reviews them, and when a refusal to pay can become a bad-faith claim. It builds on our broader work as a Los Angeles health insurance denial lawyer.

Your plan may have refused an out-of-network specialist, an emergency room bill, or a referral your doctor said you needed. Our Los Angeles team can go through the denial letter with you and explain which review path applies. As a firm, we have recovered hundreds of millions of dollars for policyholders. At Gianelli & Morris, we take insurance bad faith cases on a contingency fee basis, which means our fees are taken as a percentage of any award we recover. Call 213-489-1600 for a free consultation to discuss your legal options.

Key Takeaways

  • Under California law, a health care service plan must reimburse emergency services and care until stabilization, including care at an out-of-network hospital (Health & Safety Code § 1371.4).
  • For DMHC-regulated plans, the plan must resolve a standard grievance within 30 days, or within 72 hours when the case is expedited.
  • A DMHC Independent Medical Review application is ordinarily due within six months of the plan's written grievance response, and the DMHC can accept later applications for good cause.
  • Health insurers regulated by the California Department of Insurance must pay a complete claim, or contest or deny it in writing, within 30 calendar days of receiving it (Insurance Code § 10123.13).
  • Private-employer group plans are generally governed by ERISA, which removes the bad-faith tort remedy. Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases.

What Does an Out-of-Network Denial Put at Risk?

An out-of-network denial rarely arrives as a single problem. It usually shows up as three: a bill, a gap in care, and a set of deadlines that start running before most people know they exist. The harm from an out-of-network denial is often less about one unpaid claim and more about the treatment you delay while the dispute drags on.

The bill you weren't expecting

An out-of-network provider has no contract with your plan, so it hasn't agreed to accept the plan's rate as payment in full. When a claim is denied, or paid at a reduced "allowed amount," the provider may try to bill you for the rest. That practice is called balance billing.

Balance billing is when a provider bills you for the difference between its full charge and what your plan paid. California and federal surprise-billing protections limit it in emergencies and at many in-network facilities, but those protections don't cover every out-of-network visit.

The bills can move to collections while you're still appealing. That's one reason the denial letter and the explanation of benefits matter so much. They show what the plan decided and why.

The care you put off

People often stop treatment when a plan refuses an out-of-network specialist. Some wait for an appeal. Others try an in-network provider who may lack the right expertise.

Winning an Independent Medical Review can require the plan to reimburse you or authorize care, but it doesn't compensate you for pain or worsening caused by the delay. Under Cal. Health & Safety Code § 1374.34, once the DMHC adopts a decision that a service is medically necessary, the plan must reimburse services already provided, or authorize services not yet provided, within five working days. Harm from the delay itself is a separate question. That question belongs to bad-faith and tort law.

The clocks that run in the background

Several deadlines can run at once: the plan's grievance window, the six-month IMR window, any suit-limitation clause in your policy, and the limitations periods for a lawsuit. None of them waits for you to finish reading your Evidence of Coverage. We cover each deadline in detail below. The practical point here is that the date on your denial letter matters.

So what can you actually do about it? That depends on a sequence of questions, and the order matters.

How We Evaluate an Out-of-Network Denial: Gate, Record, Remedy

We evaluate a California health insurance denial in six steps. The sequence starts with which law governs. Then it looks at the deadlines, the denial letter itself, the right review route, the quality of the insurer's investigation, and finally which remedy fits. Each step answers a question that changes the next one, so skipping ahead (for example, filing suit before identifying the regulator) can cost you a review path you'd otherwise have. This is a strategic framework. It isn't a promise of any particular result.

Step 1: Identify the governing path

Who sponsors and regulates your coverage shapes everything that follows. HMOs and most managed-care plans fall under the Knox-Keene Act and the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC). Health insurance policies regulated by the Department of Insurance (CDI) follow the Insurance Code. A private employer-sponsored group plan generally points toward ERISA.

If the coverage is ERISA-governed, we explain why a different path applies, because we don't handle those cases. If the regime is unclear, we resolve that question first. Useful documents here include your Evidence of Coverage or policy, enrollment and premium records, any employer plan documents, and your insurance ID card.

Step 2: Lock down the clock

We read the policy's own suit clause and identify every denial date that might start a deadline. If a period is close to expiring, preserving the claim comes before refining strategy. An equivocal or ongoing denial is treated as an open question that counsel has to resolve, not something to assume away.

Step 3: Take the denial letter apart

Under Cal. Health & Safety Code § 1367.01, only a licensed physician or a competent licensed health care professional may deny or modify a request for medical-necessity reasons. The denial must be in writing and must include the criteria used and the clinical reasons. Routine prospective decisions are due within five business days of receiving the reasonably necessary information. Urgent decisions are due within 72 hours.

A non-clinician reviewer, missing criteria, boilerplate reasons, or a late decision can strengthen both the administrative appeal and any later bad-faith claim. Our page on insurers failing to explain a denial covers why those gaps matter. If the letter is complete on its face, the focus shifts to the medical merits.

Step 4: Choose the review route

For DMHC plans, the grievance comes first and Independent Medical Review comes after. CDI policies have their own IMR. We use expedited review when a client's condition is urgent. We build the IMR submission around the treating physician's evidence, and we decide early whether litigation should run alongside administrative review or after it.

Step 5: Test the insurer's investigation

A documented, reasoned medical disagreement may point toward a contract claim or administrative relief. A one-sided review that ignored your doctor may support a tort claim. We also check for an arbitration clause early, because it affects where the dispute can be heard.

Step 6: Match the remedy and the scale

The last step compares three options: an individual appeal, an individual lawsuit, or a broader challenge to a practice. The deciding factors are the strength of the evidence, how urgent your medical needs are, and whether the same denial is being applied to other members. Our class work against major health plans is the reason we always ask whether a blanket out-of-network rule is affecting more people than you.

If you'd like us to apply these six steps to your denial, call 213-489-1600 and have the denial letter in front of you.

When Must a California Plan Pay for Out-of-Network Care?

Under California law, a plan's network limits aren't absolute. Emergency care, certain surprise bills at in-network facilities, gaps in timely in-network access, and mid-treatment provider departures can each require a plan to cover or protect out-of-network care. Each situation follows its own rule, and the exceptions within each one matter.

Emergency room care at an out-of-network hospital

Under § 1371.4, a health care service plan must reimburse emergency services and care provided to its enrollees until the care results in stabilization. The statute also requires plans to maintain access so providers can get timely authorization for post-stabilization care.

Stabilization generally means the treating physician has determined your condition is stable enough that no material deterioration is likely during a transfer or discharge. After that point, further out-of-network care may need plan authorization.

Plans sometimes argue after the fact that a visit wasn't a true emergency. If that happened to you, our explanation of what to do when your insurer says your ER visit wasn't an emergency walks through the issue.

Surprise bills from out-of-network doctors at in-network facilities

Suppose you scheduled surgery at an in-network hospital and an out-of-network anesthesiologist or assistant surgeon took part. California's surprise-billing law for state-regulated plans and policies generally limits what you owe that doctor for non-emergency services to your in-network cost sharing. The main exception is advance written consent that meets the law's requirements. The federal No Surprises Act adds similar protections for many plans, including some that California law doesn't reach.

These rules protect you from the bill, but they don't necessarily settle the dispute between the plan and the provider. Keep every bill and explanation of benefits, because they show whether the protection was applied.

When the network can't give you timely care

The DMHC's timely access regulations set maximum appointment wait times for plan members. When a plan can't offer an appropriate in-network provider within those standards, the plan is generally expected to help arrange care, which can include an out-of-network referral.

Provider directories that list doctors who aren't accepting patients, or who aren't in the network at all, can undermine a plan's claim that adequate in-network care existed. We describe that problem in our page on ghost networks and claim denials. Screenshots of the directory listings you relied on can become evidence.

When your doctor leaves the network mid-treatment

Under Cal. Health & Safety Code § 1373.96, a Knox-Keene plan must, at your request, provide for completion of covered services by a terminated provider for specified conditions. Those conditions include an acute condition, a serious chronic condition, a pregnancy, a terminal illness, care of a newborn, and a surgery that was already authorized and scheduled. The provider generally has to agree to the plan's terms. Continuity of care also has time limits that depend on the condition, so ask early.

Is Your Out-of-Network Denial About Medical Necessity or Coverage?

Under California law, the reason for the denial determines the review you can get. Medical-necessity disputes can go to Independent Medical Review, while pure coverage or contract disputes generally go through the regulator's complaint process instead. The DMHC decides which track a complaint belongs on, but how you frame your grievance can affect that decision.

Medical-necessity disputes

Many out-of-network denials are medical-necessity disputes in disguise. The plan says an in-network surgeon can do the procedure, and your doctor says only a specific out-of-network specialist has the needed expertise. That disagreement is about medical judgment.

Medical judgment brings in the utilization-review rules of § 1367.01. A clinician has to make the call, in writing, using stated criteria. The Knox-Keene Act's statement of purpose in § 1342(a) also describes keeping the professional as the determiner of the patient's health needs, which is why your treating physician's letter carries weight.

Coverage and contract disputes

Some denials turn purely on contract language. Examples include an HMO member who saw a non-network doctor without a referral, or a policy that excludes all out-of-network benefits. Those disputes ask what the contract says and whether an exception (emergency, timely access, continuity of care) overrides it. Our out-of-network service denials resource covers more examples.

Underpaid out-of-network claims

PPO and EPO members often face a different problem: the plan paid, but far less than expected. Here's why that matters. Underpayment disputes usually turn on how the policy defines the "allowed amount" and whether the insurer followed its own method.

For CDI-regulated health insurance, Cal. Ins. Code § 10123.13 requires the insurer to pay a complete claim, or notify the claimant in writing that it is contested or denied, with specific reasons, within 30 calendar days of receipt. A delayed or unexplained underpayment is a problem worth documenting.

Which Agency Reviews Your Denial: DMHC, CDI, or Federal ERISA Rules?

In California, the agency that reviews an out-of-network denial depends on how your coverage is regulated. HMO and most managed-care members go to the DMHC, members with CDI-regulated health insurance go to the Department of Insurance, and self-funded employer plans fall outside both and follow federal ERISA rules. Insured employer plans can be covered by both state and federal rules at once.

Which Agency Reviews Your Denial: DMHC, CDI, or Federal ERISA Rules?
Coverage typeState regulatorReview pathBad-faith tort available?
HMO or managed-care plan (Knox-Keene), individual or Covered CaliforniaDepartment of Managed Health CarePlan grievance, then DMHC IMR or DMHC complaintGenerally yes, against the plan
CDI-regulated health insurance policy (many PPO policies)California Department of InsuranceInsurer appeal, then CDI IMR under Ins. Code § 10169 or a CDI request for assistanceGenerally yes, against the insurer
Insured private-employer plan that is a Knox-Keene planDepartment of Managed Health CareKnox-Keene grievance and DMHC IMR, plus federal ERISA claim rulesNo; ERISA limits remedies
Self-funded private-employer planNone (federal oversight by the Department of Labor)Federal ERISA internal appeal and external reviewNo; ERISA limits remedies
Government or church employer planDMHC or CDI, depending on the coverageState grievance and IMR pathGenerally retained, depending on plan structure and defendant

DMHC plans: grievance first, then Independent Medical Review

Under Cal. Health & Safety Code § 1368, every health plan must maintain a DMHC-approved grievance system and tell members how to use it. The plan must resolve a standard grievance within 30 days, or within 72 hours when there's an imminent and serious threat to your health. Our guide to the California health insurance grievance system explains what plans must provide.

Independent Medical Review (IMR) is a free, state-run review in which independent physicians decide whether a denied, modified, or delayed service is medically necessary. Under Cal. Health & Safety Code § 1374.30, you generally must file a grievance first. You don't have to stay in the plan's process for more than 30 days, or three days in expedited cases. The application is ordinarily due within six months of the plan's written response, and the DMHC can accept later applications for good cause.

Under Cal. Health & Safety Code § 1374.31, the DMHC expedites a review when there's an imminent and serious threat to health, and it may waive the grievance prerequisite in extraordinary and compelling cases. You can start through the DMHC complaint process or the Independent Medical Review application. Our page on the role of the DMHC in health insurance denials adds background.

CDI-regulated health insurance

Under Cal. Ins. Code § 10169, the Department of Insurance runs its own Independent Medical Review system for the health policies it regulates. Coverage questions that aren't about medical necessity can go to the department through Department of Insurance consumer help.

Employer plans governed by ERISA

ERISA preemption is the federal rule that the Employee Retirement Income Security Act supersedes state laws that relate to private employee benefit plans. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1144, laws that regulate insurance are saved from preemption. In Pilot Life Ins. Co. v. Dedeaux (1987) 481 U.S. 41, the Supreme Court held state common-law bad-faith claims preempted for ERISA plans, although later decisions narrowed parts of its reasoning.

For private-employer group plans, ERISA generally removes the bad-faith tort, punitive damages, and emotional-distress damages, and limits recovery to the benefit plus potential interest, attorney fees under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(g), and appropriate equitable relief under § 1132(a)(3). A benefits suit under § 1132(a)(1)(B) can be filed in state or federal court.

Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases. If your plan falls under ERISA, we'll explain why a different path applies. One point matters even then: if your employer's coverage is an insured Knox-Keene plan, such as an employer-sponsored HMO, you keep the DMHC grievance and IMR rights. ERISA changes your lawsuit remedies, not that review path.

Under 29 U.S.C. § 1133, an ERISA plan must give written notice of a denial with specific reasons and a reasonable opportunity for a full and fair review. The Department of Labor's claims regulation sets first-decision deadlines of 72 hours for urgent care, 15 days for pre-service claims, and 30 days for post-service claims. The pre-service and post-service periods can each be extended once by up to 15 days. Group health plans must allow at least 180 days after you receive a denial to file the internal appeal. Insured employer plans must meet both this federal schedule and California's deadlines. Self-funded plans follow the federal schedule alone. The U.S. Department of Labor (EBSA) handles questions about those plans.

Government and church plans are exempt from ERISA. Teachers, police officers, firefighters, other public employees, and religious workers generally keep California bad-faith remedies against the insurer, though plan structure and the defendant can matter. Our page on how public employee insurance denials are different explains more.

How Long Do You Have to Challenge an Out-of-Network Denial in California?

California has no single deadline for an out-of-network denial. Administrative review windows, policy suit clauses, and lawsuit limitations periods can all apply at once, and accrual, tolling, and contractual limitation provisions in your policy can shorten or shift any of them. Treat the table below as a map of general rules, not a calculation for your case.

How Long Do You Have to Challenge an Out-of-Network Denial in California?
DeadlineApplies toGeneral ruleAuthority
Plan grievance decisionDMHC-regulated plans30 days; 72 hours if expeditedKnox-Keene grievance system, H&S Code § 1368
IMR applicationDMHC-regulated plansOrdinarily within six months of the plan's written grievance response; later filings may be accepted for good causeH&S Code § 1374.30
Claim payment or written denialCDI-regulated health insurers30 calendar days after receipt of the claimIns. Code § 10123.13
Policy "Legal Actions" clauseCDI-regulated health policiesNo suit before 60 days after written proof of loss; none after three years from when proof of loss is requiredIns. Code § 10350.11
Bad-faith tort lawsuitNon-ERISA coverageCommonly two years, often running from the insurer's unequivocal denialCode Civ. Proc. § 339(1); Love v. Fire Ins. Exchange (1990)
Breach of the written policyNon-ERISA coverageCommonly four yearsCode Civ. Proc. § 337(a)

Lawsuit limitations periods

California courts generally apply the two-year period of Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 339(1) to bad-faith tort claims, following Love v. Fire Ins. Exchange (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 1136. They apply the four-year period of Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 337(a) to claims on the written policy. Both periods commonly run from the insurer's unequivocal denial, which makes identifying that date one of the first things we do.

Policy suit clauses

Under Cal. Ins. Code § 10350.11, CDI-regulated health policies must say that no suit may be brought before 60 days after written proof of loss, or after three years from when proof of loss is required. In Blue Shield of Cal. Life & Health Ins. Co. v. Superior Court (Kawakita) (2011), a published decision, the insurer's own clause gave the insured three years to sue for breach of the implied covenant. Your policy's wording matters, so have an attorney review it promptly.

When Does an Out-of-Network Denial Become Insurance Bad Faith?

Under California law, a denial isn't automatically bad faith just because it was wrong. Bad faith requires that the insurer unreasonably withheld benefits, and a denial resting on a reasonable, good-faith investigation is generally protected even if a court later disagrees with it. The question is how the insurer reached its decision, not only what it decided.

The implied covenant and the genuine dispute defense

In Gruenberg v. Aetna Ins. Co. (1973) 9 Cal.3d 566, the California Supreme Court held that every insurance policy carries an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. An insurer that unreasonably withholds benefits can be liable in tort. The duty comes from the law, not only from the policy terms.

The genuine dispute doctrine protects an insurer whose denial rests on a reasonable, good-faith investigation. In Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co. (2007) 42 Cal.4th 713, the Court held that a jury could find bad faith where an insurer reached a medical conclusion without fairly investigating and disregarded the treating physician's evidence.

That's directly relevant to out-of-network disputes. Consider a hypothetical: a plan denies an out-of-network specialist without addressing the treating doctor's explanation of why no in-network surgeon could do the procedure. The plan's file would be the central evidence. Our overview of bad faith insurance lawsuit grounds covers other fact patterns.

Where Insurance Code § 790.03 fits

Cal. Ins. Code § 790.03 lists unfair claims settlement practices in subdivision (h). It creates no private right of action. In Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund Ins. Cos. (1988) 46 Cal.3d 287, the Court held that enforcement belongs to the Insurance Commissioner. The statute still describes what reasonable claims handling looks like, and the lawsuit itself is the common-law bad-faith claim. Our page on California Insurance Code 790.03 and bad faith explains the distinction.

DMHC enforcement offers another reference point. The department has taken enforcement actions against several California health plans over claim denials. Regulators enforce these standards. Individual policyholders pursue bad-faith claims.

What damages can be recovered

In a non-ERISA case, damages can include the withheld benefits and the financial losses the denial caused. In appropriate cases they can also include emotional distress, which California recognized in Crisci v. Security Insurance Company. Under Brandt v. Superior Court (1985) 37 Cal.3d 813, attorney fees reasonably incurred to recover tortiously withheld benefits are recoverable as damages.

Brandt fees are the portion of your attorney fees spent recovering the policy benefits themselves. Fees for pursuing the bad-faith claim itself aren't recoverable. Punitive damages under California's punitive damages statute require clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice, and they're never assumed. These remedies don't apply to ERISA-governed private-employer plans, as explained above. See our page on remedies for bad faith insurance practices.

Arbitration clauses

Some health plan contracts require binding arbitration, which changes where a dispute is heard. If a case goes to arbitration, Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 1281.91 lets a party disqualify a proposed neutral arbitrator by giving notice within 15 calendar days of the disclosure. One court-appointed arbitrator may be disqualified without cause. Checking for the clause early avoids surprises.

Case Results From Our Health Coverage Litigation

Our health coverage results come from cases tried or litigated against major health plans and medical groups. None of the results below was an out-of-network case, but each one involved access to care that a plan or medical group refused or delayed, which is the core issue in many out-of-network disputes. Past results don't predict the outcome of any future matter.

Case Results From Our Health Coverage Litigation
CaseCoverage issueResult
LaRue v. Accountable Health Care, IPA (L.A. Super. Ct. No. BC566095)Failure to provide a timely surgical referral to a Health Net member on an Affordable Care Act plan$7,225,000 jury verdict against Accountable Health Care, IPA, Health Net's contracted medical group
Gallimore v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc.Excess skin surgery under California's reconstructive surgery lawClass action trial; estimated benefits to Kaiser members exceeding $150 million
Arce v. Kaiser Foundation Health PlanDenial of autism treatmentClass action; basis of Robert Gianelli's CLAY Award
Trujillo v. United Health GroupCoverage for prosthetic limbsClass action on behalf of amputees seeking prosthetic coverage
Dion v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc.Residential mental health treatmentResidential treatment coverage for severe mental illness

In LaRue, Rob Gianelli and co-counsel Rene Kern of the Kern Law Group obtained the verdict on claims of negligence and violation of Civil Code § 3428. It is the firm's health-coverage jury verdict on record. Gallimore's figure is an estimate of benefits to members, not money recovered. Our page on coverage denials for excess skin surgery describes the issue in that case.

Why does this matter for an out-of-network denial? Because when one denial reflects a uniform rule, such as a blanket refusal to authorize out-of-network specialists for a condition, the same question we asked in those class cases applies: who else is affected? You can read more about Robert Gianelli's practice on his attorney profile. He is also a Consumer Attorneys of California Street Fighter of the Year honoree and a two-time Consumer Attorney of the Year finalist.

Where Out-of-Network Disputes Are Decided in Los Angeles County

An out-of-network dispute in Los Angeles is usually decided first by an agency, not a court. Most out-of-network disputes start with the plan's grievance process and the DMHC or the California Department of Insurance, and only some move on to the Los Angeles County Superior Court.

State court in Los Angeles

A civil insurance lawsuit filed here goes to the Los Angeles County Superior Court. An individual out-of-network bad-faith case is ordinarily an unlimited civil case. It isn't a "complex" case, which is a separate designation under California Rules of Court rule 3.400. Your case notice and assigned department determine where the case is heard. Filing rules and forms are available through California Courts.

LaRue was tried to verdict in the Los Angeles County Superior Court. That's the local court experience we bring.

Federal court and removal

An insurer sued in state court can sometimes move the case to the federal court for the Central District of California. On diversity grounds, that requires an insurer that is both incorporated and headquartered outside California, and more than $75,000 in controversy. A corporation is a citizen of every state where it's incorporated and of the state of its principal place of business. Many California health plans fall into neither category, so removal isn't automatic.

State agencies

The DMHC and the California Department of Insurance are the agencies that review most out-of-network denials. Their IMR decisions can carry significant weight, and an IMR decision in your favor must be implemented under § 1374.34. A lawsuit addresses what an IMR can't, such as harm from delay or an unreasonable investigation.

What Does It Cost to Hire Us, and What Should You Bring?

At Gianelli & Morris, a bad-faith case costs you nothing up front. We take insurance bad faith cases on contingency, so there's no fee unless we recover, and our fee is a percentage of any award. For administrative matters such as a grievance or an IMR application, we explain fee arrangements during the free consultation instead of assuming one model fits.

What we do in a first conversation

We ask about your coverage, the denial, and the dates. Then we explain which of the six steps described above applies first, and which deadlines may be running. We won't predict a result. We'll tell you what the records show and what they don't.

Documents worth gathering

  • The denial letter and every explanation of benefits
  • Your Evidence of Coverage or policy, and your insurance ID card
  • Any employer plan documents, if the coverage came through work
  • Referral or authorization requests and the plan's responses
  • Bills and collection notices from out-of-network providers
  • Screenshots of provider directory listings you relied on
  • Grievance or appeal correspondence, including dates
  • Letters from your treating doctor explaining why out-of-network care was needed

If you haven't filed a grievance yet, our guide to writing an appeal letter for a health insurance denial can help you organize your doctor's evidence. You don't need every document before contacting us. Bring what you have.

The information on this page is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Contact a qualified attorney to discuss your specific situation.

Talk to Us Before Your Review Window Closes

Your IMR application is ordinarily due within six months of the plan's written grievance response, and a bad-faith claim is commonly subject to a two-year period that often runs from the insurer's unequivocal denial. Gianelli & Morris has been serving California policyholders since 1979 and represents people throughout Los Angeles County and California. Call 213-489-1600 for a free consultation to discuss your legal options and bring your denial letter.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to hire a lawyer for an out-of-network denial?

In California, Gianelli & Morris handles insurance bad-faith cases on contingency, so our fees come out of any award we recover and you pay no attorney fee unless we recover. Administrative steps such as a DMHC grievance or Independent Medical Review are handled differently. We explain fee arrangements for those matters during your free consultation.

How long do I have to file a lawsuit over an out-of-network denial in California?

California courts generally apply a two-year period to bad-faith tort claims under Code of Civil Procedure § 339(1) and a four-year period to breach of the written policy under § 337(a). Both commonly run from the insurer's unequivocal denial. Accrual, tolling, and suit-limitation clauses in your policy can shorten or shift these periods, so have an attorney review your dates promptly.

What is my out-of-network denial case worth?

In California there's no formula, and we won't give you an invented range. Value depends on the benefits withheld, the out-of-pocket costs and harm the denial caused, whether the insurer's investigation was unreasonable, and whether ERISA limits your remedies. Under Brandt v. Superior Court, fees spent recovering withheld benefits can also be recoverable in a non-ERISA bad-faith case.

My plan paid part of the out-of-network bill. Should I accept that?

Under California law, a partial payment doesn't necessarily end your right to challenge how the claim was calculated. For CDI-regulated health insurance, Insurance Code § 10123.13 requires the insurer to pay a complete claim, or explain in writing why it's contested or denied, within 30 calendar days. Ask the plan how it calculated the allowed amount before you sign any release.

What if I saw an out-of-network doctor without getting prior authorization?

In California, missing a prior authorization doesn't always end the claim. Emergency care must be reimbursed until stabilization under Health & Safety Code § 1371.4, and continuity-of-care and timely-access rules can require out-of-network coverage in some situations. If none of those exceptions applies, the plan's contract terms usually govern, so the reason you went out of network matters.

How long does an out-of-network denial dispute take?

For DMHC-regulated plans in California, the plan must resolve a standard grievance within 30 days, or 72 hours if expedited. IMR follows after that. A lawsuit takes longer, and its timing depends on discovery, any arbitration clause, whether the case is removed to federal court, and the court's schedule. We'll explain the factors that apply to your case rather than guess at a number of months.

Do I need a lawyer to appeal an out-of-network denial?

No. California's grievance and Independent Medical Review processes are designed for members to use on their own, and IMR is free. A lawyer can help when the regulator is unclear, a deadline is close, the denial reflects an unreasonable investigation, or delayed care caused harm that an IMR can't compensate.

What if the out-of-network provider sends my bill to collections during the dispute?

In California, surprise-billing protections may limit what you owe for emergency care and for certain non-emergency care at in-network facilities. Tell the provider in writing that the claim is under appeal, and keep copies of every bill and collection notice. Those records can support both the administrative review and any later damages claim.

Will my out-of-network denial case go to trial?

Most California health coverage disputes are resolved through the plan grievance, Independent Medical Review, or negotiation. Some cases do go to trial or arbitration, depending on the evidence and the contract. Gianelli & Morris tried LaRue v. Accountable Health Care, IPA to a $7,225,000 jury verdict in the Los Angeles County Superior Court. Past results don't predict any future outcome.

Can my employer plan's denial be challenged under California law?

It depends on the plan. Private-employer group plans are generally governed by ERISA, which removes the bad-faith tort and limits recovery to the benefit plus potential interest, attorney fees, and equitable relief. Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases. Insured employer HMOs still give members DMHC grievance and IMR rights, and government and church plans generally keep California bad-faith remedies.

To find out which category your plan falls into, call 213-489-1600 for a free consultation.

How do I pay for treatment while the dispute is pending?

Under California law, an IMR decision that a service is medically necessary requires the plan to reimburse you for care already received, or authorize care not yet received, within five working days (Health & Safety Code § 1374.34). Some people pay out of pocket and keep receipts. Others ask for expedited review when their health is under an imminent and serious threat.

Does a DMHC complaint replace a lawsuit?

No. In California, Insurance Code § 790.03 standards are enforced by regulators, and a DMHC or CDI review decides coverage and medical necessity. Neither one compensates you for harm caused by an unreasonable denial. That remedy comes from a common-law bad-faith claim, which is available for non-ERISA coverage.