Skip to main content
Gianelli & Morris attorneys Alex Gianelli, Joshua S. Davis, Robert S. Gianelli and Loring Rose

Protecting insuredrights since 1979

We fight insurance companies that refuse to pay.

Insurance companies don’t always play fair. Our insurance claim attorneys help policyholders fight denied, delayed, or underpaid insurance claims and recover what they’re owed.

Free Consultation

California Group Long-Term Disability Denial Lawyer

Free Consultation

Most group long-term disability plans that California employers provide are governed by ERISA, the federal benefits law. ERISA generally preempts California bad-faith claims for those plans, which limits recovery to the benefit plus potential interest, attorney fees, and equitable relief. Government and church plans are exempt, and their members generally retain California bad-faith remedies against the insurer.

Robert S. Gianelli is a Los Angeles partner at Gianelli & Morris who represents policyholders in health, life, disability, and property insurance disputes. Our firm has 40+ years serving California policyholders. We need to be direct with you about one point at the start: Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases. We evaluate selected individual and other qualifying non-ERISA long-term disability disputes, including many group policies covering public employees. If your plan turns out to be an ERISA plan, our first conversation is built to tell you that quickly, so you can find other counsel and protect your appeal deadline.

Robert Gianelli received the California Lawyer Attorney of the Year (CLAY) Award, and his notable cases include Arce v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, a class action over denied autism treatment. At Gianelli & Morris, we take insurance bad faith cases on a contingency fee basis, which means our fees are taken as a percentage of any award we recover. Call 213-489-1600 for a free consultation to discuss your legal options, whether you live in Los Angeles County or elsewhere in California.

Key Takeaways

  • Group disability coverage that a private employer provides is usually governed by ERISA, and ERISA plans don't allow a California bad-faith tort claim, punitive damages, or emotional-distress damages.
  • Plans run by government employers and church plans are exempt from ERISA, so teachers, police officers, firefighters, and other public employees generally keep California bad-faith remedies against the insurer.
  • ERISA disability plans must give you at least 180 days after you receive a denial to file an internal appeal, under 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(h)(3)(i) and (h)(4).
  • California Insurance Code § 10110.6 voids clauses in life and disability policies covering California residents that give the insurer discretionary authority over eligibility or policy interpretation.
  • California courts generally apply a two-year period to bad-faith tort claims and a four-year period to claims on the written policy, but policy suit-limitation clauses, accrual, and tolling can shift those dates.

Is Your Group Disability Plan Governed by ERISA or California Law?

Under California and federal law, the first question in any group long-term disability denial is which law governs the plan. If a private employer sponsors the plan, ERISA almost always controls the dispute and preempts California bad-faith claims; if the plan belongs to a government employer or a church, ERISA generally doesn't apply. That single answer decides the remedies available, the court rules, and even which lawyers can help you.

ERISA is the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, the federal law that regulates most benefit plans that private employers offer. It covers pensions, health plans, and disability plans alike.

Preemption means a federal law displaces state law on the same subject. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1144, ERISA supersedes state laws that relate to employee benefit plans, with a savings clause for laws that regulate insurance. In Pilot Life Ins. Co. v. Dedeaux (1987) 481 U.S. 41, the U.S. Supreme Court held that state common-law bad-faith claims are preempted for ERISA plans. Later Supreme Court savings-clause decisions narrowed parts of that reasoning, but the bottom line for most private-employer disability plans is the same: no bad-faith tort lawsuit.

What's really at stake in the answer

This isn't a technicality. It changes what your case can recover.

Under California law, an insurer that unreasonably withholds disability benefits can face a lawsuit for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. That claim can reach damages beyond the unpaid benefits. Under ERISA, recovery is generally limited to the benefit itself plus potential interest, attorney fees the court may award, and appropriate equitable relief.

Here's a simple way to see it. Picture two Los Angeles nurses with the same diagnosis and the same insurer. One works for a private hospital system and gets coverage through its ERISA plan. The other works for a county-run facility. If both claims are cut off on the same flawed paper review, they could face very different legal paths and remedies. Same insurer. Same medical file. Different law.

Who decides whether your plan is ERISA?

A court decides, based on facts about the plan. The answer usually turns on who sponsors the coverage, who pays the premiums, and how involved the employer is. The certificate of coverage, enrollment forms, payroll deduction records, and any summary plan description all matter. Don't assume your plan is ERISA, or non-ERISA, from a label on a brochure.

What Does It Cost to Have Gianelli & Morris Review a Group LTD Denial?

The first conversation costs you nothing. The firm offers a Free Consultation to Discuss Your Legal Options, and for insurance bad faith cases we work on contingency, so our fees come from a percentage of any award we recover. That arrangement applies to bad-faith claims; for other kinds of matters, we explain fee terms during the consultation rather than assuming they work the same way.

Contingency fee means the attorney's fee depends on a recovery. If there is no recovery in a bad-faith case, there's no attorney fee. Case expenses are a separate subject, and we discuss how they're handled before any agreement is signed.

What happens in the consultation

We start with the governing-law question. If your coverage is part of an ERISA plan, we'll tell you so and explain why that matters. We'll also point you to the federal appeal deadline so it doesn't slip past while you look for an ERISA lawyer. That's the honest version of help we can give on those cases.

If your policy is individually purchased, or part of a governmental or church plan, the conversation keeps going. We'll ask about the denial letter, your doctors' opinions, your job duties, and the policy language. You'll leave with a clearer picture of whether California insurance law applies and what the next decision point is.

What Happens If Your Employer Disability Plan Is an ERISA Plan?

If your employer disability plan is governed by ERISA, federal law sets the rules for appeals and lawsuits, and you generally must complete the plan's internal appeal before suing, with at least 180 days after receiving the denial to file it under 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(h)(3)(i) and (h)(4). The exception is narrow: courts may excuse exhaustion in limited circumstances, such as when the plan fails to follow required claim procedures. Gianelli & Morris doesn't represent claimants in ERISA cases, but you should understand this path before choosing counsel.

The internal appeal usually decides the case

29 U.S.C. § 1133 requires an ERISA plan to give written notice of a benefit denial with specific reasons and a reasonable opportunity for a full and fair review. The federal claims regulation, 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1, sets minimum procedures for every ERISA plan, insured or self-funded, including decision timelines for disability claims and appeals.

Administrative record means the collection of documents the plan considered during the claim and appeal. In many ERISA cases, the court's review is generally limited to that record. So the appeal is often your best chance to add medical opinions, functional testing, and vocational evidence. Waiting until the lawsuit can be too late.

Key insight: In an ERISA disability case, the internal appeal is less like a form and more like building the trial file. Whatever isn't in the record may never reach the judge.

How courts review ERISA denials

Standard of review is the yardstick a judge uses to check the plan's decision. Under de novo review, the judge decides for themselves whether you're disabled under the plan. Under the abuse of discretion standard, the judge asks only whether the plan's decision was unreasonable, which is far more deferential.

Plans often include clauses giving the insurer discretion to interpret the policy. California voids those clauses. Under Cal. Ins. Code § 10110.6, a provision in a life or disability policy covering a California resident that reserves discretionary authority to the insurer is void and unenforceable. That rule can affect how a court reviews the denial in either an ERISA or a non-ERISA case.

What an ERISA lawsuit can recover

A participant can sue to recover benefits due under the plan under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(1)(B). ERISA recovery is generally limited to the benefit plus potential interest, attorney fees in the court's discretion under § 1132(g), and appropriate equitable relief under § 1132(a)(3). There's no bad-faith tort claim, no punitive damages, and no emotional-distress damages. And ERISA benefit suits can be filed in state or federal court, because § 1132(e)(1) gives the courts concurrent jurisdiction over them.

The U.S. Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) oversees ERISA plans and publishes consumer information about claims procedures. It's a useful starting point while you look for an ERISA attorney.

The table below compares the two paths.

What an ERISA lawsuit can recover
IssueERISA group plan (private employer)Non-ERISA plan (government, church, or individual policy)
Governing lawFederal ERISA statute and claims regulationCalifornia insurance and contract law
Bad-faith tort claimGenerally preemptedGenerally available against the insurer
Punitive damagesNot availablePossible only on clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice
Emotional-distress damagesNot availablePossible as part of a bad-faith tort claim
Attorney feesCourt may award under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(g)Fees to recover tortiously withheld benefits may be recoverable as damages under Brandt
Internal appealGenerally required; at least 180 days to file for disability plansDepends on the policy; no federal exhaustion rule
Representation by Gianelli & MorrisNot handled; referred out promptlySelected cases evaluated

Which Group Disability Policies Fall Outside ERISA in California?

In California, the main group disability policies outside ERISA are governmental plans and church plans, both of which ERISA exempts. Public employees, including teachers, police officers, firefighters, and city, county, and school district workers, generally retain California bad-faith remedies against the disability insurer. The qualifier matters: plan structure and the identity of the defendant can still affect the claim, so each plan needs a document review.

Public employees in Los Angeles County

Los Angeles County has an enormous public workforce. Cities, the county, school districts, and public safety agencies all employ people who may have group disability coverage through their employer. When that coverage is part of a governmental plan, ERISA's preemption rules generally don't reach it.

That changes the conversation. A public employee whose claim was denied after an unreasonable investigation may be able to bring a California bad-faith claim, not just a claim for back benefits. Our article on how public employee insurance denials are different covers this distinction in more depth.

Church plans

Plans maintained by churches and certain religious organizations are also generally exempt from ERISA. Religious workers and employees of church-affiliated organizations may have California remedies available. Whether a particular plan qualifies can be a contested question, so the plan documents need a careful read.

Individual policies and limited voluntary arrangements

A disability policy you bought on your own, outside any employer plan, is governed by California law. Professionals such as physicians often hold these policies, sometimes with strong own-occupation definitions.

In limited situations, a policy employees buy entirely with their own money, with minimal employer involvement, may also fall outside ERISA. Courts look closely at the employer's role, such as whether it endorsed the plan or contributed to premiums. This is fact-specific, so premium payment records and enrollment materials are often the most important documents in the first review.

How We Review a Denied Non-ERISA Disability Claim: Promise, File, Proof

For a California disability policy outside ERISA, Gianelli & Morris proposes a six-step review called Promise, File, Proof. It asks what the policy promised, what the insurer's file shows, and whether the denial survives the medical and vocational proof. This is a proposed review sequence, not a guarantee of any result, and outcomes depend on the policy, the medical record, and the insurer's conduct.

Step 1: Confirm which law governs the policy

Everything depends on this answer. We look at the certificate of coverage, the application, enrollment forms, premium payment records, and any summary plan description. If the coverage came through an ERISA plan, we explain why that matters and refer you out promptly. If it's an individual or other non-ERISA policy, the California contract and bad-faith analysis continues.

Step 2: Read exactly what the policy promised

Next comes the definition of disability the insurer applied.

Own occupation coverage pays if you can't perform the material duties of your own job. Any occupation coverage pays only if you can't perform any job you're reasonably suited for by education, training, and experience. Many group policies switch from the first to the second after a set period, and that switch is a common point of termination.

We also review the elimination period, which is the waiting period between the start of disability and the start of benefits. Offsets, exclusions, and riders come next. The policy's written definition is the starting point for what the medical proof must show. It isn't the whole story, because California courts have applied their own standard for total disability even where the policy language seems clear.

Some insurers try to undo coverage after a claim through rescission, which means treating the policy as void from the start because of alleged concealment or misrepresentation in the application. The California Insurance Code allows rescission for concealment and for representations that are false in a material point. That makes materiality the central question: did the alleged misstatement actually matter to the insurer's decision to issue the policy? We request the underwriting file to find out.

Step 3: Rebuild what the insurer actually did

California's Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations require insurers to conduct a thorough, fair, and objective investigation. A first-party denial must be in writing and state every basis for the denial, with its factual and legal grounds.

In Egan v. Mutual of Omaha Ins. Co. (1979) 24 Cal.3d 809, the California Supreme Court held that an insurer may not deny a disability claim without thoroughly investigating its basis. There, the insurer declined the insured's offer of a medical examination before denying benefits, which breached the implied covenant. We reconstruct the claim timeline from the claim file, claim notes, correspondence, and reviewer reports. Gaps or shifting reasons point toward bad faith. A thorough, well-explained denial instead points toward a focused dispute over benefits.

Step 4: Test the medical and vocational proof

Paper review means a records-only review by a doctor hired by the insurer who never examines you. An independent medical examination (IME) is an in-person exam by a physician the insurer selects.

In Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co. (2007) 42 Cal.4th 713, the California Supreme Court held that the "genuine dispute" defense protects an insurer only when its position rests on a reasonable, good-faith investigation. A jury could find bad faith where the insurer disregarded the treating physician's evidence. So we ask whether the insurer's reviewers examined you, saw your complete records, and addressed the policy's actual definition of disability. Thin or conflicting evidence may call for more medical or vocational proof before choosing a path.

Step 5: Measure the conduct against California standards

Cal. Ins. Code § 790.03(h) lists unfair claims settlement practices, such as misrepresenting policy provisions and failing to promptly explain a denial. Under Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund Ins. Cos. (1988) 46 Cal.3d 287, that statute creates no private right to sue. The Department of Insurance enforces it. But its standards remain evidence of what reasonable claims handling looks like, and your lawsuit itself would be a common-law bad-faith claim.

This step also decides whether to develop a punitive damages theory. Under California's punitive damages statute, those damages require clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice. That depends on what the insurer's own records can prove.

Step 6: Choose the path and protect the deadlines

Options range from a pre-suit demand to a lawsuit for breach of the policy, with or without a bad-faith claim. We weigh the strength of the proof, the available remedies, and the earliest applicable deadline. Trial preparation shapes how evidence gets organized from the first file review, because a case should be built so it can be proven to a jury if it gets that far.

Step 6: Choose the path and protect the deadlines
StepCore questionKey documentsDecision it drives
1. Governing lawERISA or California law?Certificate, enrollment forms, premium recordsRefer out, or continue the California analysis
2. Policy promiseWhich disability definition applies?Full policy, riders, application, underwriting fileWhat the medical and vocational proof must show
3. Insurer's conductWas the investigation thorough and fair?Claim file, notes, denial letters, IME and surveillance reportsBad-faith theory or focused benefits dispute
4. Medical proofDid the insurer fairly confront treating evidence?Treating records, functional evaluations, job descriptionStrength of a genuine-dispute defense
5. Conduct standardsWhat can the records prove?Claim guidelines, reviewer communicationsWhether to pursue punitive damages
6. Path and deadlinesDemand or lawsuit, and by when?Denial date records, suit-limitation clauseResolution efforts or filing

If you hold a public-employee, church, or individual disability policy and want this review applied to your denial, our team can walk through the first two steps with you in a free case review. Reach us at 213-489-1600, and have your denial letter nearby when you call.

Why Do Insurers Deny or Terminate Group Disability Claims?

California disability insurers commonly rely on a handful of grounds when they deny or end benefits under a group policy, and each one has a matching legal question. Under Egan and Wilson, any of these grounds must rest on a thorough, fair investigation; a stated reason that ignores treating-physician evidence can support a bad-faith claim on a non-ERISA policy. On an ERISA plan, the same flaws matter in the appeal, but the remedies are federal.

The switch from own occupation to any occupation

This transition is one of the most common termination points. An insurer may concede you can't do your own job but argue you can do some other job. The quality of that argument depends on the vocational analysis behind it. Did it account for your actual restrictions, your education, and realistic jobs? Or did it list job titles without matching them to your limits?

Doctors and other specialists face their own version of this problem. Our pages on how disability is defined for physicians and on why doctors with LTD policies face extra scrutiny cover it in detail.

Paper reviews and IMEs that conflict with treating doctors

A file reviewer who never met you may reach a different conclusion than the specialist who has treated you for years. That conflict doesn't automatically win the case for either side. But Wilson makes clear that the genuine-dispute defense doesn't protect an insurer that reached its medical conclusion without fairly investigating.

Surveillance and social media

Some terminations follow a surveillance report. A video of someone carrying groceries once doesn't show whether that person can work a full day, every day. The question is whether the insurer weighed that footage against the full medical picture, or treated a few minutes of video as the whole story.

Condition limitations and offsets

Some group policies cap benefits for certain conditions, such as mental health conditions, at a set number of months. Others require proof through specific tests. Many policies also reduce the monthly benefit by Social Security disability payments, pension benefits, or other income.

Offset means a dollar-for-dollar reduction in your disability payment for other income you receive. The policy language generally determines which income counts and how the reduction is calculated. Errors in offset math are worth checking line by line.

Incomplete or inconsistent denial letters

A denial that doesn't explain its basis is a problem under California's claims regulations and under ERISA's notice requirement. Our article on failing to explain a denial explains why the content of the letter matters. A pattern we see often is a letter that names a reason but never connects it to specific medical findings or to the policy's own definition.

So what can you do about it? Read your denial letter alongside your policy. Note every reason given. Then compare each reason to your doctors' records. That comparison is where most disability disputes are won or lost.

What Can You Recover When a Non-ERISA Disability Insurer Acts in Bad Faith?

Under California law, when a disability insurer outside ERISA unreasonably withholds benefits, you may be able to recover more than the unpaid benefits. Recoverable damages can include the withheld benefits, Brandt fees incurred to recover those benefits, emotional distress damages, and, only on clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice, punitive damages. None of these apply to ERISA plans, where recovery is generally limited to the benefit plus potential interest, discretionary attorney fees, and equitable relief.

Brandt fees

Brandt fees are attorney fees you reasonably incur to compel payment of policy benefits that the insurer tortiously withheld. In Brandt v. Superior Court (1985) 37 Cal.3d 813, which arose from a denied disability claim, the California Supreme Court held these fees recoverable as damages. Fees for pursuing the bad-faith claim itself aren't recoverable under that rule.

Why proof drives the value

A breach of the policy alone supports contract damages. A bad-faith claim requires showing the insurer acted unreasonably. Punitive damages need a higher showing still. That's why the claim file, reviewer communications, and the insurer's own guidelines matter so much. Our overview of remedies for bad faith insurance practices goes deeper on each category.

Why proof drives the value
Damage categoryWhat it coversAvailable under ERISA?Available on a non-ERISA California policy?
Withheld benefitsMonthly benefits due under the policyYesYes
Attorney feesFees to recover benefitsCourt discretion under § 1132(g)Brandt fees for tortiously withheld benefits
Emotional distressAnxiety, distress caused by the bad-faith conductNoPossible as part of a bad-faith tort claim
Punitive damagesPunishment for oppression, fraud, or maliceNoOnly on clear and convincing evidence
Equitable reliefCourt orders beyond money, such as reinstatementAppropriate relief under § 1132(a)(3)Depends on the claims pleaded

How Long Do You Have to Challenge a Group Disability Denial in California?

California has no single universal deadline for a disability denial. California courts generally apply the two-year period of CCP § 339(1) to bad-faith tort claims and the four-year period of CCP § 337(a) to claims on the written policy, commonly running from the insurer's unequivocal denial. Those periods can be shortened or shifted by the policy's own suit-limitation clause, by when the claim accrued, and by tolling, so an attorney should confirm any filing date.

Disability policies in California must contain a legal actions provision. Under Cal. Ins. Code § 10350.11, no lawsuit can be brought until 60 days after written proof of loss, and none after three years from the time proof of loss is required. How that clause interacts with the general limitations periods depends on the facts, which is one more reason not to calculate a deadline on your own.

The statutes courts commonly apply

Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 339 sets a two-year period for obligations not founded on a written instrument. In Love v. Fire Ins. Exchange (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 1136, the court applied that period to bad-faith tort claims. Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 337(a) sets four years for actions on a written contract, which includes the policy itself.

The statutes courts commonly apply
DeadlineApplies toSourceWhat can change it
At least 180 days to file an internal appealERISA disability and group health plans29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(h)(3)(i), (h)(4)The plan may allow more time; check the denial letter
No suit before 60 days after proof of loss; none after 3 years from when proof is requiredCalifornia disability policiesCal. Ins. Code § 10350.11Policy wording, proof-of-loss timing
Generally 2 yearsBad-faith tort claimsCCP § 339(1); Love (1990)Accrual, tolling, contractual limits
Generally 4 yearsBreach of the written policyCCP § 337(a)Accrual, tolling, contractual limits

If you have a denial letter dated more than a few months ago, the safest step is a prompt attorney review of every date in your file. For ERISA plans, the internal appeal deadline usually comes first and is the one people most often miss.

Where Are Group Disability Cases Heard in Los Angeles?

Civil insurance lawsuits brought in Los Angeles County are filed in the Los Angeles County Superior Court. An individual disability insurance bad-faith case is ordinarily an unlimited civil case, and the case notice and assigned department determine where it is heard. The main exception is removal: an insurer may move the case to federal court in certain circumstances, and ERISA benefit claims can proceed in either state or federal court.

Unlimited civil case is the California category for civil lawsuits seeking more than the limited-case dollar threshold. Most disability bad-faith cases fall here because the unpaid benefits and other damages add up over time.

When an insurer can move the case to federal court

Removal means a defendant transfers a case from state court to federal court. Under federal diversity rules, a corporation is a citizen of every state where it's incorporated and of the state where it has its principal place of business. Diversity also requires more than $75,000 in controversy. An insurer sued by a California resident can remove on diversity only if it is both incorporated and headquartered outside California.

The agencies involved

The California Department of Insurance regulates disability insurers and enforces the unfair claims practices standards of § 790.03. You can file a consumer complaint there about a disability insurer's conduct. A complaint doesn't replace a lawsuit or stop a deadline, but it creates a record. For ERISA plans, the Department of Labor's EBSA handles questions about plan claims procedures.

For more on how Insurance Code § 790.03 fits into a bad-faith claim, see our page on California Insurance Code 790.03.

What Should You Gather Before Your Free Case Review?

You don't need a perfect file to start. The documents that decide the governing-law question, the policy certificate, enrollment forms, and premium payment records, are the most useful to bring first. Everything else helps us move faster once we know California law applies.

Documents to collect

  • The policy or certificate of coverage, with any riders and amendments
  • Your enrollment forms and the signed application, if you have it
  • Pay stubs or records showing who paid the premiums
  • Any summary plan description your employer gave you
  • Every denial, termination, or reduction letter
  • Correspondence with the insurer, including emails and claim portal messages
  • Treating physician records and any written opinions about your work limits
  • Your job description, or a short written summary of what your job actually required

If you don't have the claim file, that's normal. In a non-ERISA case, the insurer's claim file and underwriting file are among the first things we work to obtain.

What you can expect from us

Gianelli & Morris has been serving policyholders since 1979, and the firm holds an AV Preeminent® rating. We have recovered Hundreds of Millions of Dollars across our practice, a firm-wide figure that reflects decades of cases and doesn't predict any single outcome. Robert Gianelli is a two-time Consumer Attorney of the Year finalist and shares the Consumer Attorneys of California Street Fighter of the Year honor with a colleague.

What that means for you is practical. We'll tell you early whether your policy is one we can take on. If it is, we'll explain the review steps, the deadlines we see in your file, and how fees work for your type of claim. And if it isn't, we'll say so plainly so you can move to an ERISA attorney without losing time. You can read more about Robert's background on his attorney profile, or visit our main long-term disability insurance claim denial page for individual policy disputes.

A word about what not to do

Don't sign anything from the insurer that releases claims before you understand what you're giving up. Don't assume a phone call to the adjuster counts as an appeal. And if the denial letter gives an appeal deadline, write it on your calendar today.

The information on this page is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Contact a qualified attorney to discuss your specific situation.

Get a Clear Answer About Your Group Disability Denial

A denied disability claim usually arrives at the worst possible time, when you're sick, out of work, and trying to keep up with bills. The first answer you need isn't complicated legal theory. It's which law governs your plan, and which deadline comes first.

If you're a public employee, a church-plan member, or an individual policyholder in California, Gianelli & Morris can review whether California insurance law gives you a path beyond the unpaid benefits. If your plan is an ERISA plan, we'll tell you that, too, and flag the 180-day minimum appeal window so it doesn't run out while you search for the right lawyer. Call 213-489-1600 to schedule a no-cost consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to hire a lawyer for a group disability denial?

Gianelli & Morris offers a free consultation to discuss your legal options. For insurance bad faith cases, the firm works on a contingency fee basis, meaning fees are a percentage of any award recovered. For other kinds of matters, fee terms are explained during the consultation, and case expenses are discussed separately before any agreement.

Does Gianelli & Morris handle ERISA long-term disability denials?

No. Gianelli & Morris does not handle ERISA-governed employee benefit cases. The firm evaluates selected individual and other qualifying non-ERISA disability disputes, such as many governmental and church plans. If your plan is governed by ERISA, the firm can explain why and point out the appeal deadline so you can find ERISA counsel promptly.

How do I know if my employer disability plan is covered by ERISA?

Under federal law, most disability plans that private employers sponsor are ERISA plans, while governmental and church plans are generally exempt. The answer depends on who sponsors the plan, who pays premiums, and how involved the employer is. Your certificate of coverage, enrollment forms, payroll records, and summary plan description usually hold the answer, but a court makes the final call when it's disputed.

How long do I have to appeal or sue after a disability denial in California?

For ERISA disability plans, you must be given at least 180 days after receiving the denial to file an internal appeal under 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1. For non-ERISA California policies, courts generally apply two years to bad-faith tort claims and four years to claims on the written policy, commonly from the insurer's unequivocal denial. Policy suit-limitation clauses, accrual, and tolling can shorten or shift those periods, so have an attorney confirm your dates.

Can a teacher or police officer in Los Angeles sue a disability insurer for bad faith?

Generally, yes. Governmental plans are exempt from ERISA, so teachers, police officers, firefighters, and other public employees generally retain California bad-faith remedies against the insurer. Plan structure and the defendant can still affect the claim, so the plan documents need a careful review before anyone can say what's available.

What is my non-ERISA disability bad-faith case worth?

Under California law, value depends on the withheld benefits, any Brandt fees incurred to recover them, emotional distress caused by bad-faith conduct, and, only on clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice, punitive damages. The strength of the insurer's own records drives much of that value. No honest lawyer can give a number before reviewing the policy and claim file.

My insurer cut off benefits after a paper review. Is that bad faith?

Not automatically. Under Wilson v. 21st Century Ins. Co., California's genuine-dispute defense protects an insurer only when its position rests on a reasonable, good-faith investigation, and a jury could find bad faith where the insurer disregarded treating-physician evidence. The question is whether the reviewer saw your complete records and addressed the policy's actual definition of disability.

Can I sue my disability insurer under Insurance Code § 790.03?

No. Under Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund, § 790.03 creates no private right of action; the Department of Insurance enforces it. But on a non-ERISA policy, you can bring a common-law bad-faith claim, and the unfair claims practices listed in § 790.03(h) remain evidence of what reasonable claims handling looks like.

Will my disability case go to trial?

Many insurance cases resolve before trial, but some don't, and there's no way to predict which path a case will take at the start. Preparing the evidence as if it may need to be proven to a jury tends to make settlement discussions more productive. In ERISA cases, a judge rather than a jury usually decides, often on the administrative record.

Does it matter that my policy gives the insurer "discretion" to decide claims?

It can. Under Cal. Ins. Code § 10110.6, a clause in a life or disability policy covering a California resident that reserves discretionary authority to the insurer is void and unenforceable. That rule can affect how a court reviews a denial, which is why we look for those clauses in every policy we read.

How do I pay my bills while my disability dispute is pending?

Many claimants apply for Social Security disability benefits while challenging a private disability denial, though many group policies reduce benefits by Social Security payments once approved, and the policy language generally determines how. Talk with your doctors and a benefits advisor about short-term options. If you want to discuss how a pending dispute affects your situation, call Gianelli & Morris at 213-489-1600.

Should I accept a lump-sum buyout offer from my disability insurer?

Not before you understand what you're giving up. A buyout usually ends all future benefits and releases claims, possibly including a California bad-faith claim on a non-ERISA policy. Compare the offer to the remaining benefits under the policy, consider offsets, and have an attorney review the release language before signing.